Twisted Sheep Pizza and Brew - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

First time we had a cheeseburger pizza and it was surprisingly delicious! I am a Brussels sprouts fanatic and ppl who hate them will only eat mine (mine are amazing) and I try them every where I go all over the world and these were pretty damn good. I would only say a little less sauce and more nuts. 😉 Definitely coming here again!

This is a must go for pizza. I highly recommend the Buffalo Pizza and I’m not the biggest Buffalo sauce fan. Service from the staff was amazing. If I was from around here this would be a weekly stop. Must try!

Excellent service, they opened up on an off day for our large group. Calvin and his crew were great. Fantastic food, good atmosphere, I definitely want to come back next time I’m in Florida

Absolutely delicious. The staff is super friendly, and the price will "not break the bank".

Hi, I noticed you're kinda hidden, are you in need of someone to stand out front on the sidewalk with a sign with your restaurant name to advertise & show that you're in the plaza?

The pizza here is excellent. Lots of fun options & variety.

Best crust in Florida. Very tasty pizza with unique toppings. The staff is friendly and attentive.

Real Gluten Free and Vegan options that are actually delicious!!! Allergy friendly!

Pizza is great at this cute little hole in the wall. They have great selections for pizza and the burgers are great!

Great pizza and great prices! Had various local brews on tap and an incredible assortment of different pizza, burger and salad options. Would definitely recommend anyone stop by and grab a bite here!

They have some of the most uniquely delicious pizza creations I've seen. I decided on the Buff Chick pizza and I was thoroughly impressed. This is THE spot for pizza.

Good pizza. The chicken and waffle fry pizza kinda tastes like Chick-fil-A sauce.

Place has gone way downhill in my opinion. Much better pizza & SERVICE at many of the other pizza establishments in and around this one. I personally will stick to Low Brow & Baci.

Wow. Delicious. Omg out of this world pizza. As someone who is very picky about pizza this is a big time I'll be back. Definitely will be my go to.

Food was excellent and service was impeccable by Claire.

Absolute best crust ever. Wife NEVER eats the crust but devoured this one. Perfectly light and crispy.

The southern jam burger cured my bad day

Great pizza and salad. Nice selection of craft brews. My only complaint would be ( since they ask for payment first ); being asked to tip before having received any food or service

Absolutely amazing pizza. A must try!

Five stars for Twisted Sheep Pizza! We were staying in Naples for vacation and wanted a delicious, unique pizza experience on our last night. Twisted Sheep totally delivered (pun intended!). First off, the convenience was amazing. They were super close to our rental and had tons of great reviews online, which sealed the deal. We called in our order for two specialty pizzas (because, why choose just one?) and they were ready right on time. But the real star of the show was the pizza itself. Fresh, piping hot, and absolutely delicious! There was enough variety on the menu to please everyone in our group of seven, and we all went to bed satisfied and happy. Twisted Sheep is definitely the perfect spot for a unique and delicious pizza experience in Naples. Highly recommend!

Had company and had food delivered. Arrived fairly fast for delivery on a Friday Night. Kuddos! Introduced my friends to this great pizza place with the Candied Bacon Bruchetta (WOW), Kung Pao Meatballs (substituted this/used to be on the menu and they can still make it), Mamas Meatballs, buffalo chicken wings, Roni Pepperoni pizza (hot honey on the side for a picky eater), and Eat More Chicken pizza. We used the hot honey on both and OMG was that good. Sweet with a little kick in the pants. Even the picky eater was impressed with what he was willing to try (I think he ate half the roni himself!) Thank you for impressing my guests. When they return they want to order from you again!

Great place! Pizza is delicious and so were the brussel sprouts, brisket nachos, and chicken wings. Very good selection of beer and wine and sodas. The Hazy IPA was extremely tasty. 😊 The staff is friendly and on top of things. Love the decor! We've been here several times and have never been disappointed. Across the street from Naples Towne Center in the Sherwin Williams strip.

Overall a little disappointing. Beer selection is poor and beer isn't brewed on site. Pizza was pretty good but nothing amazing. Staff was friendly. To summarize, the pizza was just okay, and the beer portion of the place was underwhelming and disappointing. Probably won't be back.

We got this pizza delivered while in town for vacation. Very good!

I've had confit wings from them before & they were consistently delicious. This time they were soggy & weird. Decided to try the pizza and I can be fussy, but it wasn't good. I probably won't patronize again.

I'm from NYC and this pizza gives me the courage to live in FL.

Be aware that the menu changes…I was looking forward to ordering the French Onion and Mac N Cheese or the Carnitas & cheese sandwich after seeing pics & reviews online, but they are no longer on the menu, so I had the OG Burger, which was OK, that’s not why I made the trip here. The Keels Farm cider on tap paired well with/ the burger.

Super creative pizza combinations - delicious!

Brisket pizza had 3 maybe 4 little tiny pieces of brisket. Not sure. Poor and disappointed.

Ordered takeout last night. My pizza was shaped like an egg. It was supposed to be 14" round and it was 14"x9". The center of this odd shaped pizza wasn't sufficiently done

Restaurant was pretty good 👍🏼 Service and Atmosphere was top, food was good. We had the OG Burger and the „Eat the chicken“ Pizza (not 100% sure on the name, but something like that).

Some of the best pizza I’ve ever eaten in my life! Absolutely love the South of the Border pizza and the Holy Moly. Also the craft sodas are great. Worth every penny!

Fast and friendly service. Food was hot and very delicious.

Pizza was great!!! We got the pepperoni and it had a sweet glaze drizzled on top which added something extra. Delicious! Loved the soda pop machine! Great unique flavors. There was a big crowd inside but we were able to sit outside on the sidewalk.

Had the Kung pao Brussels sprouts and candied bacon bruschetta. Both were excellent. Our party also got the Margherita bomb and the French onion Mac and cheese. Very happy with our food. Service was good and we got our food quickly.

This is a quaint place neat art work. Really good pizza, the crust stands on its own. Lots of options for vegetarian and carnivores alike. Also the quality of the menu items are very high. Do not judge by first view, looks like a small diner.

Cool little pizza joint. Soda fountain was great, unique flavors. Pizza was good. Very busy .

The staff working tonight were so sweet, explained & recommended menu items, and encouraged me to come back! 🥹🫶🏿 To add the food was AMAZING definitely recommend the Kung Pao Brussels Sprouts! We were going to do take out but decided to stay in the end & eat outside. Will be coming back! ✨🤩

Hot fresh excellent flavors. We ordered the buff chick & bbq chicken. Both would absolutely order again. Charming interior with artwork and plenty of seating. There is an exterior patio as well. (Bit chilly today - so we indoor seating as a family)

Excellent pizza! Ordered the margarita pizza and it was quite good. Service was fast and friendly. Got it to go and was ready in less than 20 minutes. Twisted Sheep has a nice patio area that noticed when picking up the pizza

Ordered Roni Pepperoni Pizza, I really enjoyed it, it tasted beyond my expectations. Nice and friendly service. Higher recommend this place!

Enjoyed our afternoon snack, we tried the Hawaiians Cousin, and it was great! Love the thin crispy crust, and our son loved the fountain soda options, too!

This is our new favorite place! Everything is 100% amazing. The nachos w brisket, the bruscetta w candied bacon, the PINEAPPLE CREAM SODA can't find anywhere else.... THE PIZZA. Omg. I ordered the hamburger pizza with a whole kickass burger on top !!! TEMPED PERFECTLY. She got the pepperoni pizza and she loved it (and she's from CT 💀) The ingredients taste top notch too.

Good local place, I think they are very new as their website still needs some work. The food is pretty good, there is a lot of "odd" food but it is still very good. Would go back again!

Pizza had a great flavor. Will have to go back and try other items on their menu.

Found a nice little gem. We had the pepperoni with hot honey and it was delicious! Will definitely be back.

Truly an amazingly GREAT experience! The pizza is phenominal!!!

Awesome little pizza joint! Being from NY I always have a tough time finding good pizza in Naples and this place hits the spot! My new favorite spot. Cool artwork throughout the place and a little patio. Highly reccomend the pomegranate and tomato salad too!

Our first visit was on a Saturday in October 2023 at noon. There was one family that was just leaving and the rest of the restaurant was empty. We ordered a Roni pepperoni pizza and some beers from the tap. We tried an IPA and we tried an ale. Both beers were not as cold as they should have been and we noticed the person pouring. The beers had a lot of foam in the glass and had to keep filling the glass to get it full. The pizza came out fairly quick. Was delicious. No complaints from us.

Hands-down, the best pizza in Naples… period! You can’t go wrong with Screaming Sheep. I’m partial to their Hawaiian pizza, but honestly, even the stuff with arugula on it tastes great! Price is a reasonable and they have a nice selection of beer.

Goodness!!! All I can say is yes! We had wings, burgers, pizza, and salad. Everything is fresh and fabulous. 8 wings is enough for one person. This place I can’t rave enough about. I hope they franchise and bring it to central Florida. Thank you for the fresh food.

The og burger was amazing! We also had the buff chick pizza, superb. 10/10 would recommend

OMG!!! pizza is amazing, so many different pizzas to choose from, not your ordinary pizza place, I got the carnavor pizza my friend got the Buffalo chicken pizza, it actually had huge peices of Buffalo chicken on it,both were perfect!, I got a new favorite pizza place in Naples

Great Pizza and Wings! Buff Chick is amazing.

Great pizza super friendly staff, clean and comfortable. This is our go to spot when we are craving a really good pizza. 👍😋

Delicious Pizzas (also with Vegan Cheese as an option), known for unique flavors and combinations. We got a draft beer, although I would recommend skipping this and going for the draft craft sodas, some of the best I've ever had!

My Honest review? Food wasn’t noteworthy enough to come back. I thought it was overpriced, over sold, with mediocre service and bland food. Conversation with staff was very transactional. Im sure they have their loyal following for their own good reasons, but for me, I dont have a memorable reason to come back. What I do remember is getting the bill and feeling fleeced on overall quality and value. Its over priced mediocre food. The issue isn’t that it was bad food. The issue hat I paid for my meal should’ve been great and it wasn’t. With so many other great restaurants in Naples who are truly great at what they do, I feel my money is better spent elsewhere. I wasn’t sold. Its almost like they operate from a perspective of knowing they will always have the never ending flow of tourists who will always come and go regardless. They know they can increase their profit margins using mediocre ingredients and small servings for the price. Theres a vast supply of really great Italian food here. This just isnt it. For me.

Super cool vibe. Amazing service and best Buffalo Chix Pie around. Our go to for a fun pizza night and yummy soda too!

I ate here a while back and just remember having a good experience food and service wise so today when my parents came to visit, we decided to go. Three of us ordered burgers which were absolutely amazing. They came with french fries, which were crispy and actually seasoned which restaurants rarely do. We were all very happy with our burgers. One of us ordered a pizza, which was also just delicious. The service was spot on as well. I look forward to coming here more often and trying some of their salads and pizzas.

Excellent pizza! The crust was perfect, loved the curled up pepperonis, fresh mushrooms (so much better than canned), delicious brussel sprouts as an appetizer and even with delivery, the food was still hot. Definitely recommended!

Wife says we're not going back so I guess we're not going back. Service was slow, pizza was OK but skimped on toppings and left a LOT of bare crust around the edges. They were a lot more focused on getting us to vote for them online in some contest than they were in good service and good pizza. We like to support locally owned businesses, but not this one.

Hidden jem for truly artisan food. Amazing pizza and extremely tasty appetizers!

Crust on the pizza was good. 4/5 Pizza flavors were good. 4/5 Service was outstanding & friendly! 5/5 The novelty of a small item in the center of the pizza is weird & not necessary. 🙄 Atmosphere is weird, like a blank retail store feel. Sorta sterile and not at all like a pizza parlor or pub. 😐 Also minus 1 for small plastic beer glasses. ☹️😢

First time trying Twisted Sheep. Ordered from the website for pickup. Order was ready on time and service was good. To me, the pizza was just average.

Great food, everything was fresh and hot. And service was great. I will recommend and bring friends. Thanks

Easy on-line ordering for take out or eat in. Fast, friendly service, and the pizzas are the best we've ever had. Just tried the Holy Moly Pizza which is our new favorite. The French Onion Mac & Cheese is out of this world delicious.

Awesome all around. The staff was lovely. I had the pizza sandwich and wow not what I expected so much flavor and very fresh you could taste how fresh it was. Great sodas too. Great spot for lunch.

The food was amazing and I love the atmosphere! You can eat inside or outside. There are picnic tables on the side that was a very cool surprise, with lots of shade and super clean. Top it off with excellent service! I'll definitely be going back!

Really cool little spot. Friendly Service and good food. I am always on the look out for good pizza in this area and so far they have one of the best. The wings were great.

Wanted to try out a new place in the area that we haven’t gone to before and Twisted Sheep is amazing! Pizza was so good. Will come back again :)

I live right down the street and had no idea this was there but I am glad I do now! The bbq chicken pizza was sooo good and I loved their pineapple cream soda!! 10/10 for sure, can't wait to try more!!

The pizza & salad were good but the girl at the counter clearly didn't like her job and was giving off a negative vibe the whole time we were there

We enjoyed everything we ate. The pizza was a thumbs up by our New Jersey friends. This place is a hidden jem - you won't be disappointed!