Vito's Pizza Shop - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

You need this Pizza in your life...

We love our Vitos pizza. It's easy to order and set a time to pick up. It's always hot and tasty.

Vito is a fantastic pizza place… But there is no seating indoors or table service. The atmosphere is exactly what you’d expect from a takeout pizza shop. The staff were very friendly and the pizza was ready quickly. We keep coming back because the pizza is so delicious. I especially like their pepperoni cups on the pizzas they get nice and crispy. And they reheat well when you have leftovers.

This is the best pizza we’ve had IN YEARS! The sauce was amazing, there weren’t any huge chunks nor was it crazy over powering, perfectly seasoned! All the ingredients melded in a symphony of flavor! EXCELLENT sauce/cheese/crust/ topping ratio, we got half pep and it was a true half and half. The slices folded exactly how you want a NY style pizza to do. Not only am I an EXTREMELY picky eater but I made pizza for 6 years professionally (I haven’t for a while, now I travel for work) and I am in awe of how truly incredible this pizza was. I wish I had taken a picture before we DEMOLISHED our 18” pizza. The service was prompt and polite and while waiting for our food I could see they make their dough in house and grate the cheese in house as well. I like a greasy pizza while the friend I split it with doesn’t and it left us both more than satisfied! The mouthfeel was everything you could hope for! Good price point for the ART that they make. I’m at a lose for word to describe how absolutely fantastic this pizza was, I will 100% be getting another pie before we leave this location and will stop by if ever back in town. Do yourself a favor and experience this pizza for yourself.

I loved this pizza I recommend it

I've lived in Fort Mill for 3 years and Charlotte my entire life and I've never tried Vito's! We decided to give it a shot yesterday and ordered an 18" cheese pizza with bold pepperoni and garlic crust. We also ordered Vito's sticks (stix?), which is basically a cheese bread (they use a 10" pizza dough, it seems) with a cup of sauce. Both items were fantastic, i feel silly for not trying earlier. The dough was fresh, thin and with a bit of "chew" to it. The sauce is great and the bold pepperoni get crispy and have a tiny bit of spice. I called around 530 or 535pm and was told my pick up order would be ready around 620pm. It seemed a bit long but worth it. The price is definitely higher than your chain pizza but, again, it's a completely different level of pizza. Another place that makes NY pizza i enjoy is Brooklyn's Pizza off of Rea Rd in Charlotte, and I have to say this has taken over as my favorite place for a NY pie. Give this place a shot if you haven't. I'll definitely be giving this small, local owned pizza shop more of my money as long as they keep giving me awesome pies! Since it's only a few minutes away it's definitely going to become a regular place for us when we decide to get pizza.

The pizza is always great and the staff is always friendly.

This was my first time ordering Vito's. I had a veggie pizza and Vito's stix. Everything was fresh and hot and DELICIOUS!! I am thrilled to find a delicious pizza here in Fort Mill! I can't wait to order again! Thank you!

This is my go to pizza spot. No other place can touch it.

I just have to rave about this place. Just picked up 2 small pizzas this afternoon and they were absolutely Delicious! The toppings were super fresh, the sauce to die for and the pizza crust just yummy. One of the best pizzas I’ve ever had. The other reviewers are right, excellent pizza!

Crazy short hours, crazy location in a plaza with two barber shops and a parking lot liable to eat your tires, but crazy good food. Reasonable prices and friendly folks behind the counter honored all my OCD requests. One of the best food stops on my vacation last month and by far the best I've experienced on my handful of visits to the Carolinas over the years. If I'm ever in the area again during their operating hours, I'll definitely be back!

Delicious Pizza! My only complaint is the price, but the special was very reasona le so I can't get far with that complaint. Just a minute from carowinds campground. Ordered online and picked up 15 minutes later

Excellent pizza and people. I love their little pepperonis and flavor assortment. Fair pricing and much better than chain pizza.

The food is decent, but expensive. When we’ve ordered extra cheese, it is always cheesy. There have been times we have ordered and the pizza is ready quickly and others where it’s a long wait. They are only open until 8:30 and certain days of the week.

Delicious New York Style Pizza. We ordered the Top Cat, Hawaiian and White Spinach and all were amazing! The pizzas were very large and we had no problems feeding our 4 children and friends.

WOW!! First time. They really took their time with my pizza and it was worth every minute! Absolutely delicious indeed. I will definitely be back.

Excellent local pizza shop. Very friendly with quality food.

My family is from New Jersey & we’re all pretty picky about our pizza. I was visiting my parents in Pineville & we decided we wanted pizza. VITO’s is just over a mile from their house so we decided to give them a try - ordered an 18” half pepperoni, half meatball pie. It was kinda weird that you get charged for a whole pie’s worth of each topping, but whatever. The crust was great: good flavor, nice texture, appropriate thickness, and just-right chewiness. Sauce was minimal which is the right approach, in my opinion - and it was quite the flavor bomb with lots of garlic and oregano. Good cheese coverage, toppings were plentiful and delicious. Staff was friendly and kind while we waited for our pie to cook. It was a pleasure to meet these folks, support a local business, and enjoy some damn tasty NY-style pizza. I hope my parents make VITO’s their regular pizza place!

First time trying this pizza place and was pleasantly surprised! They were going to have the pizza out at the exact time I scheduled it for (we arrived a little early) so it was piping hot. Also ordered a salad and it was delicious and very fresh! Awesome value for the price—I've had much worse for more money. Give this one a try!

It's our go-to spot in Fort Mill, even though we have to drive to the other side of town to get it. Love their garlic crust and they come up with great specials every month. I had a calzone last time with meatball - money. And don't sleep on the dessert pizza.

The meatball pizza is crazy good. mmmmmmmm 😊

Really great New York style pizza. The best we can find in all of fort mill and Charlotte area! Will be repeat customers for sure!!

Fantastic pizza. Great value. Highly recommend!!!!

Love this pizza! Closest I can find to the good stuff up North! Highly recommend the garlic crust and the cannolis are fantastic, too.

Delicious Stromboli best I have ever eaten!!

As close to NY Pizza without NYC water.

Vito’s is a great little family business with really good pizza. Each time we’ve order it’s always super fresh and hot and delicious. My kids love it as well!

Went there for my first time a week or so ago. I had no idea what to get and the girl at the cou ter recommended I get the special which was a double pepperoni and hot honey with basil pizza. I was only supposed to eat half and save the rest for the next day. I ate the whole thing it was that good. 10/10 pizza.

Super friendly and helpful staff. Pizza is NY style and very good. Whether you visit their store location or food truck, you'll be pleased. Calzones and strombolis are quite good. It's our "go to" for pizza in Fort Mill!

Deliciousness in a box. I used to get them for lunch at work uptown and now I'm so happy they have a store closer to home. Now I only want more days and hours 😊

We absolutely love Vito's! We always order the classic pepperoni pizza (the pepperoni cups are to die for!) and it is always consistently delicious. Really happy to have a local pizza place this good- only wish they were open more days of the week!

Vito's is awesome and our favorite! Pizza reminds me of NJ/NY! We followed their pizza truck forever until they got a store! So good and the owners are the sweetest!

Delicious pizza and friendly staff! Best pizza around.

Excellent pizza, best in the area!!! Extremely clean space and great customer service. A hidden gem that I'm sure won't be hidden much longer.

Great NY style pizza. Be sure to order ahead.

I loved going to the Vito’s restaurants in Florida. This place definitely gave me a taste from home. The pizza was absolutely amazing and worth every penny. The staff there were so nice and pleasant. They even gave me referral card! Over amazing place. The place smell so good as soon as you walked in!

I really enjoyed seeing their son behind the counter putting in some work! I'm not going to lie and say the pizza was the best I ever had because it honestly wasn't, but finding the best pizza ever depends on who you are and what you have had. I will come back and not for the pizza, but to show my support for this Mom and Pop business that is teaching their son at an early age how to be a productive member of society. Much Love from Thats1classylady!

Vito’s is great! Enjoyed the food and nothing like supporting a small business right in your neighborhood.

Delicious pizza, priced fairly! 10/10 would recommend to anyone!