Bake Me A Cake in Orange City - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

Wow!!🤩 I ordered Lemon cupcakes. I was having a pregnancy craving! They answered my text very quickly and was very professional. The cupcakes arrived in a timely manner. BOY WAS I IMPRESSED! These cupcakes were perfect. They were the perfect amount of sweetness and the cupcake itself was so soft and moist. 100% recommend and will be coming back soon!

They bake the best pizzas the way they roll up the pizza is great!!!!!!! The pizza sauce is YUMMMMMMM they even added my fam hot sauce!!!!! You should go is the point of my not funny joke btw they bake cakes not pizzas :)

Thank you for a great cake! My kids liked it so much!

Long story short Mercedes service is soo worth it! Top notch! I can’t wait to use her service again and shes apart of an organization that arranges baking classes with well renowned bakers!🤩 Initially there was a schedule mix up, which I was disappointed on. But they went over an beyond with there customer recovery. When I got re-scheduled for the next day. Mercedes immediately greeted me with a warm embrace😊. I immediately forgot why I was disappointed 😆. She sat me down ,pulled out a sketch book and got all the info she needed from me to make the Graduation Cake I envisioned come alive.Then tailored it based on the theme and flavors i mentioned or chose. I could not be any more satisfied with the results. The Graduate that received the cake absolutely adored it. Loved it soo much the Oreo cookie Winnie the Pooh was holding went missing(last picture). Her family and friends thoroughly loved the cupcakes as well. So much that they began a game of guessing the ingredients after each bite 😋. Mercedes I can’t thank you enough for making this such a hit celebration 🎉 🍾. Will be seeing more of you definitely. 😁

Very friendly owner, she hugged me and wished us a Merry Christmas, even though to his was our first time there. Just such a nice atmosphere and vibe. The sample cakes are gorgeous! She definitely has a lot of talent. Excited to try our Christmas cannoli's.

I wish I could give them 6/5 stars! I met with Mercedes and immediately knew this was the place to get bridal shower cupcakes and a cake. We got 4 dozen mini cupcakes and a two tier cake, and let me tell you, it did not disappoint. The only ones disappointed were myself and mother as the guests went in for seconds for the main cake before we could even try some ourselves! I couldn't make this up. Everyone raved about how delicious it was. I am so pleased with everything; thank you from the bottom of my heart!

Great place to Pre Order your Birth Day Cake at PuertoRican Flavor as well as delicious Cup Cakes and miny lollipop cakes ! All delicious flavors !

Fantastic, beautiful, amazing designer cake at an extremely reasonable price delivered on time. I can’t begin to say what a wonderful experience we had. They’re also very nice and easy to work with in getting the order just right. In addition, they made suggestions which brought more work on them but made the cake even better. Finally, the cake tasted great (not too sweet, good flavor) and we had very little left over after everyone had their fill. We will definitely ordering more cakes from Bake me a Cake!

Very pleasant family owned! Cake tasting went great, drawing up the cake was good as well. Very talented work. Very detailed. Cakes were great, very tasteful, not dry at all.

Mercedes is a spectacular artist and she's just as sweet as the cakes she bakes. I had a wonderful experience here. I ordered a 1st birthday cake and got a free smash cake. The cakes were impeccable! Far beyond what I imagined. I definitely will be returning!

Best cake decorating in Florida. Stop in and see a legend at work.

From the moment you sit down for your cake consultation with Mercedes to the delivery of your spectacular cake is a top notch experience! My daughter’s wedding cake was incredible! We can’t thank the Bake Me A Cake team more!!

They did a wonderful Twinkle Twinkle Little Star cake for my son's first birthday. I highly recommend them. Very artistic, very professional, very good cake!

Small but filled with talent. Gorgeous surroundings, friendly staff. Make an appointment!

Awesome family owed business. Mercedes, Alex and Michael allowed us to take some of their time with questions. Mercedes was not afraid to share info about questions I had. Love,love, love....

The absolute best place in central Florida for cakes. Everything is delicious and the owner is the best cake maker ever!

We used bake me a cake for our rasta-themed baby shower and the cake turned out adorable! It really tied our far-out theme into a baby shower beautifully. They helped me plan everything via text and it was a very convenient process that left me above and beyond happy. I would definatley use this bakery again in the future for any special occasion.

Our family has gotten cakes from Bake Me A Cake for over 10 years ! It is definitely one of the best bakeries in town! I highly recommend them for all your Celebrations!!!

I love my quinceañera cake! I drew out a design and Mercedes was so sweet working with me and giving me options for different flavors, fillings, and decoration ideas, as well as making the cake come to life! The cake tasted delicious and all of my guests were in love! We love how it came out and we could not have done it without you guys!

I recently discovered this bakery and they have amazing cupcakes and cakes. This place is a must if you are looking for your dream cake the sky is the limit. Ask for Michael...he is awesome!

Beautiful cakes, wonderful staff, delicious cupcakes!

Love Bake Me A Cake, the most beautiful cakes I've ever seen!!!

Bake Me A Cake, is a great cake place. If you're looking for a cake place for any event I highly recommend them. Mercedes is a sweet lady and did spectacular job on the cake for my sister's baby shower. Michael was also very knowledgeable and helpful during the whole process, he presented to me all the cake flavors and gave me an affordable price. The entire drive home I was completely amazed, as to how one can make a cake look so appealing. It not only looked beautiful but tasted good as well. I will definitely be using them for future events.

Love this place. Constant variety, wonderful food, and authentic Colombian pastries which is unheard of on this side of town.

Wonderful cupcakes and pastries! Gorgeous cakes displayed in the lobby. I was so excited that the retail shop is finally open so I can come in and buy pastries whenever. Wonderful staff, they have such a family style shop! Cute shop!

The best cupcakes and cake I've ever had in my life! The reason I'm not giving 5 stars is because since I went the first time, I've stopped in 3 additional times during business hours and they're always closed or have no product to sell. I wish their hours would reflect when the store front is actually open. I wanted to get half a dozen cupcakes for my co workers today and had to go elsewhere. Like I said, the most amazing cupcakes and the nicest staff, but they really should adjust their hours so people aren't going out of their way.

Most Delicious cakes and pastries you can imagine!

Bake Me a Cake provided cupcakes and cookies for our recent event and they were absolutely amazing! Everyone said they were the best cupcakes they had ever eaten. One person at the event said they had made her wedding cake and it was perfect. Looking forward to ordering more in the future.

Bake Me A Cake did an outstanding job on my son's first birthday cake. My first inquiry was responded to immediately and from that point on Michael guided me through the process. He was patient and attentive- I know I was annoying in trying to nail down my son's cake. Our theme was "dogs" because that is my son's favorite word and he's obsessed with our 2 dogs (that and ball). Just brainstorming I asked if they could model our dogs and they said they could!! How cool is that?! They exceeded my expectations! The cake topper looked just like our pups and they included a big red ball to match. The other extremely cool part is they included a small smash cake!! Both of the cakes tasted amazing, too! Can't wait to order more cakes and try their bakery! Outstanding in all ways!

I just had the opportunity to try a sampling of their cupcakes ahead of the anticipated opening and was not disappointed. Apparently, the chef has won awards previously and it really shows. The cupcakes were very moist and flavorful, decorated absolutely beautifully, and really show some very high-end baking mastery and decorating skills. I'm really excited to have a place like this nearby. With B's Cupcakes in Winter Park closed down, Bake Me A Cake is definitely the future.

Preparing for our Baby Reveal Party / Baby Shower was so stressful ! But, Bake Me A Cake was extremely friendly, and helpful. They just asked me for the theme and design I wanted, and picked it all up from there. Our theme was Bumble Bees (the cake being a literal beehive). Bake Me A Cake, did an outstanding job ! The outcome of the cake was above and beyond what we expected. I personally dislike fake-kid-looking cakes, and want them to look as realistic as possible. Bake Me A Cake did just that; Chocolate molded Bee's were swarming it, and branches with flowers made it pop beside the hive, making it look even more realistic ! My only reasoning to not mark it a fifth star, would be the customer service. I really wanted cake pops instead of cupcakes, but because one of the employees said she was tired from making a batch from a different party earlier in the week, she refused to make them for me. I feel that if I'm paying for a service, I should be able to pick what I want for my own party.