Cedar Key Pizza and Subs in Cedar Key - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

Enjoy the quality of the ingredients on the pizza

We are visiting Cedar Key called to see if they deliver but we were too far out. Immediately got a call back saying he would deliver to us!! Amazing service and pizza is amazing as well as the garlic knots!! Highly recommend.

Pizza and salad were delish! Ordered and ate at the bar next door! What a great combo!!

The Cauliflower Crust Pizza was amazing!!! The best I have found. Great service too!

This isn't Pizza Hut folks!! Sooooo MUCH Better!!! Super nice staff...the greek pizza was over the top good!!! Cedar Key is such an awesome place with so many mom and pop restaurants... They have bounced back from the hurricane...and it's still the best last place in Florida!!! I saw some bad reviews for Cedar Key Pizza and Subs from a year ago or so.... But that was a different proprietorship... These folks have it going on!!! If you're in Cedar Key....a definite must! Over the top good...fresh ingredients.... Super accommodating and friendly staff!!

We both forgot part of our order. They promptly delivered it to us. Awesome people 100 percent recommended 😎

Holy cow! This place is amazing! Hand stretched dough, premium fresh toppings, I can't say enough good about this place! Make sure you try it if you are visiting, highly recommend the Rye Key pizza.

just got a cheese pizza has a very weird taste to it and it’s very small for 20 bucks for a “medium” wouldn’t recommend. the philly was good but very dry.

We ate here at least 3 times during our stay plus today,food is excellent, service is professional and courteous. Highly recommend you give this buisness a try,doesn't open till 4:00 but worth the wait. Great job guys 👍👍

The pizza was ok the staff super friendly They only have take out

Owner very nice and the pizza was great

The man at the register was so patient and polite with me. He had a room full of people behind me waiting to pickup. I was wanting to use my gift card and he was taking the time to help me use it. He never made me feel like I was a burden. He never got an attitude or made me feel rushed. He just took his time and was there to help. We ordered the chicken bacon ranch pizza and it was delicious! Their key lime pie was perfect and so was the cheesecake! 10/10 recommend coming here when you’re tired of all the seafood lol. Food and service was amazing!

Pizza is alright. The crust isn't that good. any pizza chain is better. The other people that leave bad reviews are probably right.

We are here til the end of March, had pizza & Santorini Salad the first night in and loved them both!! Excellent pizza and delicious salad. Went back the following week for Saturday night pizza again and just love their pizza. YOU WILL NOT BE DISAPPOINTED. Will be back again before we go back home. Don’t change anything!!

The best pizza and delicious santorini salad ever!!!

Pizza was wonderful. Staff was friendly.

Pretty damn good pizza - and I'm from NY! It's mostly a take out place so 'atmosphere' is not really a part of the equation. Loved it !

The Philly Steak pizza was one of a kind and the Greek salad was one of the best. The owner was very friendly and I would love to try the whole menu. You should definitely check this place out. Medium Philly cheese pizza and Greek Salad $41. So many unusual custom pizza suggestions and diverse menu.

The service was great set outside with my dog. They brought my pizza out when it was ready

Owner was very friendly - pizza was great. You can tell they care about their business.

Very friendly people! Pizza was great! Will return.

The best pizza! The owner was closing and was kind enough to stay open, make pizza for me and my husband and deliver it to the pub next door!

Delicious pizza. Just the right amount of toppings, and the crust is crispy and perfect.

I know the owner of this establishment must be a proud person who wants to put out a good product and that's why I'm giving you 3 stars instead of 1. I wanted so badly to like your pizza. The web pics looked amazing, the pizza and garlic knots just were not. You're using frozen dough, most places do but you have to Thaw the dough ball in oil and it needs time to rise... Your pizza could be so much better if you simply let it proof. It isn't thin and crispy it isn't doughy, its underproofed, hard and not good. You can't get garlic knots out of the same under proofed dough... Listen you can do this but you need to ask for some help from your distributors on how to use the product. If you are buying from Sam's, just ask the Cafe folks how to do it. Your toppings are good, but you gotta fix the dough. I'm being honest with you because I am pro business and it's hard to make it with the storms and everything... Get some bread dough for your garlic knots cut THAT into pieces and do a garlic knot pull apart, hell you could use frozen biscuits but under proofed pizza dough with a little butter and parm is still underproofed pizza dough. Now the other stuff. Put a curtain up, nobody wants to see the back room a mess even if they are just picking up. I don't want you to be upset by this review. I don't know you, I just wanna see you do well and I promise if you fix the dough you will. Its bad man... Remember it doesn't cost anything to proof dough longer.

Excellent pizza and subs. It's to go only or sit outside. Good prices

I ordered a Philly cheese steak and my wife ordered a personal pan pizza.......this was one of the best cheese steaks I've tasted. My wife's pizza was incredible, this food was better than any chain restaurant.

Greek salad was amazing. I would highly recommend.

Awesome food. Owners and employees are super friendly. Get the Greek salad! House made dressing is the best you'll get - anywhere!

Service with a smile, and delicious food... can't miss

The sweetest famiky ever took over and they are the best they make everything fresh and its always amazing if your gonna come to cedar key with children this is your best bet ❤️ 💕

SuperNice ❤️👍 Beautiful I love Pizza 🍕 slide

Good pizza and friendly service!

Holy moly! This is great pizza! And super nice people. We visit Cedar Key from Orlando and we have no pizza as good as this. Don't suppose y'all deliver that far?

Great….go there…!! Yum! Steak sub!

Philly cheesesteak was amazing and my family really enjoyed the pizza! We got to Cedar Key later than expected and showed up 45 minutes before closing, and they were so nice! Great family owned business.

Wonderful service. They made our (large) order in a very timely manner with all smiles the entire time. I highly recommend this place for fast service and great, quality food.

Great pizza and subs! Nice change on an island that mainly offers seafood. Very nice and personable people.

Worst pizza we've ever had cheap pre-made cardboard crust fake salty cheese and very over priced!! We threw it in the garbage

Great pizza! Great service! Super friendly staff.

I eat here constantly, at least twice a weekend. I even got my coworkers turned over to their food. High quality all around, for subs, pizza and their dessert of Cinnamon Twists are to die for. 10/10 highly recommend.

I ordered the calzone with pineapple to be made in a couple of hours. It was no problem. I called after a bit and requested fresh garlic and it said added and for free.

Great place. We ordered a pizza, sandwiches, and the antipasto salad. They were slam busy, everything came out exactly as we ordered it and in a timely manner. We would definitely go back.

Great tasting pizzas and wings.

Tired of seafood. So we tried Cedar Key Pizza. We ordered pizza and Greek salad. AMAZING. Friendly people and great food. Definitely will return. YUM Thank you

It's a take out,but pizzas the best I've had

Delicious Pizza and Subs also great great customer service !!!!

Fantastic gluten free pizza, thanks Michael!

Calzone was delicious! Not sure where the ricotta was couldn't taste it. The husband got their meat lovers pizza and enjoyed it. Nice place to stop along on our vacation.

We really liked this place! The man taking our order was super friendly. The pizza was absolutely delicious! And the prices were very reasonable. We will definitely have it again when we come to visit next year.

We got in late and decided to give this a try instead of cooking. It was a GREAT idea! We had a nice salad and a delicious calzone both big enough to split! It was really good. I highly recommend 🥟🤤

Great calzone nice place glad to have it in cedar key

Excellent food and service. It will definitely be on our list of places to eat on our return visit.

We were visiting for Thanksgiving holiday & stopped by to order a delicious pizza,they brought outside & was perfect 😋😋

Pizza and salads we're very much appreciated visiting from ne Florida on heels of a hurricane. Charming place

Best Pizza in town. Gluten free pizza available which was fantastic.

This place is amazing. The pizza was perfect. The medium is big enough to feed 2 adults. And the Italian sub is fantastic. Can’t wait to go back. We ate everything so we didn’t take pictures lol.

Best Pizza and Garlic knots around!!!! Owner is awesome!!!!

I guide out of Cedar Key and stop every chance I get. They have a great variety of pizzas for me to bring home to the family and all of them are great. Not to mention the people that run it are as good as they come. We tried the Rye Key pizza today and it might be my favorite yet!

Wonderful people and great crispy pizza.

Came to town for a couple nights in our RV and decided on pizza from here and it did not disappoint! Be sure to grab some if you’re in town!

Pizza was good, service very friendly, however the wings were uneatable. They were soggy and very fatty and unappetizing. I ordered the garlic parmesan and ended up throwing most away. However, the pizza was tasty and fresh. Maybe just a bad batch of wings?

Best pizza and wings ! We had the personal pan with green peppers and the garlic Parmesan wings last night. They delivered it and everything and they brought us free pizza coupons today because they thought we didn’t like the wings. Very sweet people and great food!

Took a staycation to Cedar Key. Our first night we didn't feel like cooking and ordered pick-up from here and were not disappointed! The calzone was delicious & I loved the welcoming homy atmosphere when I picked up. *Edit: we got pick-up on our last night as well, we just couldn't do another clam dinner & I didn't want to cook. We got a sausage pizza and garden salad. The salad was the perfect size for two to share and the pizza was the bomb!

I’m a pizza lover but I did not like the pizza or the cheesy bread. I hate leaving a bad review but it just didn’t taste very good.

We got a small personal pizza and a meatball sub. Excellent flavor and great owners. We'll be ordering from them again soon.

Chen best employee ever! We had a great experience for this services! Pizza not bad but service the best!

We stopped in to order a pizza and the owners were very helpful with finding other local business we needed while we waited for our pizza to cook. The pizza was delicious and the garlic knots were awesome.

The BEST subs and salads in Cedar Key! Greek salad is amazing and the Italian sub is amazing! A must!

Perhaps the best pizza I've ever had! A delicious medium crust hosts an excellent assortment of toppings. The sauce is neither bitter nor bland. The courtesy and commitment offered by the management and staff is, perhaps, the best topping of all.

Clean, family friendly. Good tropical storm pizza and calzone.

The meat on the subs that my husband and I ordered were bland. I regret getting a turkey sub from here. I should have gotten a pizza instead.The guy at the front was on top of it with the orders which was awesome.

The BEST PIZZA we have ever had on this beautiful island we call home Cedar key Fl.! Carrie and Michael are so very friendly and attentive they make your pizza with love!!! We are so very happy to have them!!! If you’re in Cedar Key it is A MUST EAT!!! They will definitely take care of you and trust us they will NOT DISAPPOINT!!!!!

Outfreak'nstanding...Garlic knots were awesome, the meat lovers and the Rye Key pizzas were delicious. Crust not to thin, not to thick and a very good portion of cheese and all fixings. Was our first visit to this establishment and I have to say hats off to the new owners. Thank you, we will be back soon and often. Great job of promoting the other local businesses.

Ordered a pizza, was done promptly and excellent flavor.

spectacular! GOOD PIZZA! What a friendly place in town!

Not a lot of pizza options (and we wouldn’t expect there to be), but I would recommend eating elsewhere. The staff was not the least bit friendly and she let our pizza sit there even though she knew we were waiting. She didn’t greet nor part ways in a friendly manner and the quality of the pizza was poor. Unfortunately customer service makes or breaks an experience and since she likely deals with a lot of traveling people, it would be better to be friendly. There are other awesome restaurants (Annie’s Cafe, 83 West, etc.) that I would spend my money on.

Great subs. Pizzas and salads also highly prized. Super friendly people. Order ahead and pick up when ready.

I cannot recommend a pizza place more, especially in cedar key. The pizza and cinnamon sticks were simply delightful, and the man who spoke to us was extremely kind and happy, as opposed to the majority of the population here, who are grumpy and monolithic. 10/10 - Superb

Great pizza. Perfect crust, hot and delicious. Friendly pup loving people!

The pizza is great and the owners are outstanding. Thanks for delivering up stairs and not hitting my truck. Lol 😆

Good food but dose not open until 2 pm so useless for lunch

What a great place. Good food with very large calzones. Owners are super friendly. Will be back

Ordered a pepperoni pizza with the bread sticks tonight for me and my son. Fast service friendly staff, the pizza and sticks were great. Enough leftover for lunch tomorrow. Thanks

Great pizza! Fast service! Family owned!

Nice little golf cart area. Or you could just walk.

First time there and the pizza was very yummy will definitely will order from here again

We were not very impressed with our food here. The subs were about $10 and lazily thrown together. Was super disappointed and hate to write a review like this. I'm not usually a Karen, but numerous things he charged us for were more expensive than his menu pricing.

The pizza is awesome!!!! Cauliflower crust is amazing

Got a medium pizza 🍕 was kind of small but taste great 👍

Great service and pizza was very good. Looked and tasted like with fresh ingredients and was better than the best name brand pizza companies. If we ever go back to Cedar Key, they're definitely on our "go to" list!

Looooooooooved the Trash Can Pizza!!!!!

Other than the extra long time it took (2hours) for our pizzas and meatball sub (which was great!) I would pass the word along about tasting good but expect the long wait.

Awesome! This will definitely be our go to place when we visit Cedar key again!

Hours ,vrs life who buys a business and then closes early ,it's food it's the business.

Always atleast one meal here everytime we go!

If you are ever in Cedar key.... This locally owned and operated establishment is a MUST! Always remember that you are on "Island time" when you do anything on Cedar Key! Relax....when you get there...and enjoy the community atmosphere.... For a night in.....noone needs to drive....whatever.... This family owned business made our trip over the top! The ingredients are all fresh! They use real mozzarella folks!!! Best pizza....wings....that we have EVER had! They accommodated us.....as in.... Called up for a delivery... and they were not delivering that night.....due to circumstances beyond their control... But....because we were a repeat customer....and near by....they accommodated us) My wife literally said...."This is the best pizza I have ever had!" Check them out! Their food is "Out of Bounds!!

I had the best meatball sub ever!!! You can tell it was made with love! The sauce and meatballs were fantastic! I’m a chef so trust me on this! We wished we would have found this restaurant sooner! Very friendly young family owned business ❤️

Excellent hand tossed pizza. We loved the vegetable...fresh and tasty. Staff are very friendly and welcoming.

Very good pizza. They stayed open a few minutes late to take make us a pizza to go.

Great dinner...we got wings, pizza and cheesy bread....took about 30 minutes for it to be ready...food was hot...wings were awesomely spicy...pizza crust was crispy just like we like it...cheesey bread was great...will definitely eat there again when we come back to town. Thank you guys