Classic Cakes LLC - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

I’ve had many smith island cakes from here and they were all very delicious. They have the BEST smith island cakes

Very fresh baked goods . Very dependable and a pleasure to do business with them. We bought assortment of cup cakes for birthday gathering and peanut butter cheese cake brownies sheet style. Awesome treats.

The strawberry smith island cake is DELICIOUS!!!

I am positive that there is no cake that is as delicious as a Smith Island Cake...🎂 Gotta add that if others visit Smith Island, it's such a way of living that isn't found anywhere else & I truly believe it's "Heaven on Earth"!! ⚓️🌊

Classic chocolate frosting/yellow cake smith island cake was absolutely delicious. The cupcakes were not good at all… they were very dry and the frosting was very waxy/oily

The price seems a little high but it's worth it! The cakes are delicious and made with care. The personnel are kind and knowledgeable about the products.

Went in to get a wedding cake, but come to find out they haven't done it in 2 years because they are still "looking." Maybe you should let people know that

Always a good experience from these guys. We usually get a few cakes throughout the year for birthdays and they are always fantastic. God bless!

Best Smith Island cakes on the shore! Tasty cupcakes, too!

Best freaking cake I've ever had...

Always the best cake, no matter what.kind

Love their cakes. We come here for every birthday now. We have 7 people in our family and luckily the birthdays are spread out. But we get the strawberry Smith island cake and it is amazing. We did the pumpkin spice cake in September and I loved it. In my opinion I like it alot better then the strawberry cake.

I absolutely love Classic Cakes!! They have amaZing desserts, and the chocolate covered strawberries were over there top today! The largest and prettiest strawberries I've ever seen!! Great job guys! And the gentleman that waited on me today conducted business in one of the most professional manners ever. Not to mention, I called there this morning to find out availability, and he was so informative and extremely helpful. He was the reason I ended up choosing them over the other place I called. I've been buying Smith Island Cakes from here since they opened the doors, and they're just as professional as they were the day they opened! You won't be disappointed with anything you buy from this place!! They're top notch all the way around!

Most delicious cake and Salisbury

I don't know what happened to my 3 Smith Island Cakes, but the 2 chocolate layer cakes were very, very dry and appeared to only have 1 table or 2 table spoons of icing if that! per layer, making it even more dry. The 3rd cake red velvet was better, but nothing like previous Smith Island Cake experiences. Won't go back. Buyer beware the cupcakes were very good & didn't cost $35ea sometimes paying more isn't better & their Smith Island cakes are a good example of pure disappointment

I ordered Bourbon infused cupcakes and they were delicious!

Amazing smith island cake!! Everything was perfect!

Best Smith Island cakes around.

This is the first time in all these years I have gotten my birthday cake from you.that the taste was not there. The cake was course and not that much of a banna cake taste.kind of dry too.

Ordered a Smith Island cake for my husband’s birthday, had it shipped early and when it arrived was packed perfectly. Put it in the freezer until it was time to serve it and it was delicious, our 92 year old Grandmother wouldn’t stop raving about it!!! Thank you so much!

Best smith island cakes at such a great price.

Loved the cakes!! I purchased the strawberry and also got on the side, a slice of banana cake and slice of strawberry short cake.

Always since they opened "BEST CAKES AROUND"

Beyond disappointing this is the second time they have failed me I purchased 2 red velvet cupcakes and they were super super dry on the inside how can you sell this only thing good was the icing

Absolutely love these cakes! I place my order a day in advance and its ready for pick up the next day. They have slices and cupcakes also. They taste delicious and the staff is very pleasant. 100% recommend this business.

My wedding cake was absolutely amazing! Thank you Classic Cakes!

Always get my Smith Island birthday cakes here every year . Stephanie and the staff are top notch . Great service and quality .

I was so happy with the baked goods and service. They even delivered to my Mom's senior living facility. I live out of town and I so appreciated it.

I ordered 2 strawberry Smith Island cakes for grandson’s birthday party today. They were delicious and enjoyed by all. The frosting was awesome, cake was so moist and the layers were packed with sliced strawberries!!! SorryI didn’t take a picture !!!

Oh my goodness, one of my best friends got me the chocolate peanut butter Smith Island cake. It was amazing. I highly recommend this place. I’ve had their Red Velvet Smith Island cake and that was amazing as well. You can’t go wrong.

Great cakes. Cdj, richmond, va

Great bakery Especially Smith Island cakes

awesome and pecan sandies They are wonderful... I bought 2 dozen great even when you freeze them.. Only one thing you really need to order ahead. They sell out really really fast... You can't buy them anywhere else these are one of a kind..... Off the Salisbury just for these cookies...😋😋😋😋

Consistent with quality Smith island cakes, quickly became a family birthday staple

Very good Quality. Everybody is very friendly. Everything is YUMMY 😋 😊

Got 3 cakes for our wedding. Great service

Sounds good can't wait til our wedding to try some of the best rated cakes on the easternshore!!

Very busy because of SU graduation.

Excelente producto y muy amables

Deal island banana was delicious. Moist.

Delicious, fresh, and always a big hit at parties. They've also been able to bake a cake for me same day order and pick up (not recommended lol). I saw someone posted a bad review, because of the lack of layers. Personally, I've never cared to count the layers. Bottom line, their cakes taste good.

The cakes and desserts are always fresh and delicious & ready on time for pick up. The staff are friendly.

Very nice employees great service

The most amazing place to get custom Smith island cakes in the area.

Love you're cakes and desserts 😋

We were totally bummed that both of our Smith Island cakes did not include all 9 layers! We ordered the Mandarin Orange which only had 5 layers and the Strawberry which only had 6 layers. After reaching out to the shop, their response was that Smith Island cakes vary from 5-9 layers, however this is not stated anywhere on their website, and was also not communicated to us at the time we purchased over the phone. In my opinion these are not true Smith Island cakes and we were very disappointed :(

BEST chocolate birthday cake ever! Moist and soooo chocolate-y. Thanks to my beautiful grand daughter who choose Classic Cakes for my birthday!