Coney Island in Crestview - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

One of the oldest, if not the oldest, restaurants in Okaloosa County. Definitely a try if you’ve never experienced a Coney Island burger!! A true gem for Crestview!

Been on Main Street for years. It has had about three owners during its existence. They are known for their unique burgers and hotdogs. They only put a special sauce on their burgers and dogs. It's that that makes customers keep coming back again and again. They do not offer lettuce and tomato. Only their sauce and cheese and onions. That's their only options. You just have to try them. Like no other on the market. I truly think you will be a repeat customer!

It's one of the best places to eat. There are no other burgers lime it and the staff is so friendly and kind. You gotta try I'd you never have.

It's exactly what you are looking for.

I had a coney dog, and it was soggy with very little coney style sauce on it.

The food was EXACTLY as I remembered it from growing up in Crestview! It was a delicious trip down memory lane with good food, great service and welcoming regulars who make the wait wonderful fun. The food and the friendly faces remind me of my favorite childhood memories in this great place.

I love that we can now go inside!! This is my son's #1 pick in crestview ..... we are from small town Kansas, and we love how it feels like home every time we come! The girls are AMAZE-BALLS as well. If you haven't stopped in, trust me, do it!!

This is my go-to place here in town The food is like an Aroma Therapy session for me.

I love their food and everything

Best hotdogs I have been able to find that are anywhere close to coney Island, N.Y. hotdogs!!!

Absolutely love it just wish they had inside open again

Always love this place. I've been coming here since I was a kid.

That was the worst hamburger / hot dog spot I've ever eaten at I don't know what the hell anybody in that place is reviewing it was horrible but if this place loves it they could have it I do not like it at all a group of guys we're out of town and that was horrible it was wet smushy sloppy I'm not a fan of eating hot dogs and hamburgers with wet bread I don't know what kind of chili that was but it was horrible but to each his own won't be doing that again😞🤢

If you haven't had Coney Island? You have gotta go by and get some

Casual place with great hot dogs!

Very good food. Always made fresh.

Nothing like it used to be. Pricey.

The hot dogs are normal 6 inch run-of-the-mill hotdogs... NOT Coney Island 9 inch dogs. I am a world traveler, and this place is worse than SONIC ™ ... I would prefer a hot dog from the guy on the corner. However, the employees are wonderful and they are very kind and attentive. Aside from the fact that these are in NO WAY "Coney Island" hotdogs, the place is wonderful. Good location, fast service and friendly atmosphere.

A popular place but no dining in. Call ahead to order or u will be standing on the hot street corner for awhile. Pick up is a window on the side of the building.

It's a true heavenly Hometown experience.

Absolutely fantastic nostalgic best burgers in crestvew

Unbelievable... How good this place makes a hamburgers and hot dogs...

These are by far the best hamburgers and hotdogs in the world. I live in Andalusia AL and drive sometimes through Crestview on many occasions but Coney Island is my first stop... always.

Decent food and intriguing atmosphere and great service

AMAZING chili burgers and dogs! They're a bit small though so keep that in mind. Reasonably priced as well.

It was OK, it was a small hot dog with their standard recipe of mustard and melted cheese. It's good that you get two because one probably won't fill up a child. But, for $7, you can buy hotdogs yourself and put mustard on it. I thought they were chili cheese dogs not mustard and cheese. Also, I thought I could order what I wanted but, guess not. Will try again another day and hope for better results.

I have enjoyed going to this restaurant for many years. I live in Fort Walton and am not able to make it by there very often due to their operating hours and my work schedule. I made the special trip today and while the food was as I remembered and expected, they only had the walk up window open and the front door locked. I understand why that would have been done during COVID-19, but those days are over. I am very disappointed and hope that they open back up for regular business. I won't go back until then. They don't even have any tables set up outside. I had to take it my car to eat.

My dad had been wanting to go for a few months so I finally took him and he passed away 3 days later. So thankful I took him. Always good food!

Delicious burgers and hot dogs. The pickles with mustard and onion taste awesome on the burgers or hotdogs.

I really love the double cheeseburger with almost half a bottle of hot sauce on them.

Just a cute little shack with delicious chili burgers 🍔 I always add jalapeños. My dad used to buy th for me as a kid and they are still so good.

Been going here since the early 80s have always liked their food just wish still had 80s prices lol

Great food. Takes me back to my childhood.

Ever since I was a child I always enjoyed these burgers and hotdogs. Delicious! A nice treat. Employees are awesome!

Food is always great, never miss stopping by when we visit. Wish we could sit inside though.

Food was good but no inside service.

What can you say "if you know Coney Island you just know" nothing else taste like Coney Island a Crestview landmark for over 40 year!!

Still as good as I remember it being when I was a little girl!

The best hamburgers and hotdogs, melt in your mouth good

This place has been open for 75 years for a reason. Just eat here already.

Customer service is just awful these days. You stand there while they talk and look surprised when you tell them you haven’t ordered. Used to be my favorite place to visit. Now the quality is just not there. Won’t be back.

Still Delicious, as always! This place is consistently good! Long time favorite.

Hot Dogs 2.60$ Hamburgers 2.60 Awesome

Hometown heaven in a bun. Double cheeseburger all the way. Belly beware, not for a sensitive stomach. But the risk is worth the reward. Dripping with chilli sauce and more calories than you can count but good for the soul.

Unbelievable Chilli dogs and chilli burgers! Quick service and never disappoints!

Good ol' fashion food and fair price

Mustard onions and chili double burger was the best one I've had in Crestview almost as good as tops fort Walton

I LOVE IT MY FAVORITE PLACE TO GO ME AN MY SISTER GO ON A REGULAR BASIS LOVE LOVE IT

Fun destination. Chili dogs were awesome.

Not what I was expecting they used to be really really good it was good but not great like they used to be

Beautiful British people and they can cook the hell out of a hamburger. Plus they are located at places I frequently visited. Main street Hooterville I mean Crestview.

Ladies always on point .. DELICIOUS 🤤🤤🤤🤤

It’s been around for years my dad loved it when he was alive my favorite place

It's the best!!!! Staff work hard to put out your food in a timely order ..

Food was good. Employees were personable. Wasn't a bad price either. This is a place for quick counter hotdogs and hamburgers.

Great service...greater dog!! Their hotdogs sauce is sure good. I will be back.

Nice place for a quick bite little bland a higher quality hot dog could make a big difference

Delicious and everything you want from a corner burger place.

Been a long time favorite of mine since I was a little girl.

Haven't been here in 8 years and it was amazing just how I remembered

Love the food but there hours are weird never know when they will be open or closed

Better than expected. Very good food. It's always good to support small family businesses.

Delicious food at a great price!

Friendly service and they are famous for their burgers and chilli sauce. For the price you pay which isnt much at all it is awesome food. I have visited this place numerous times and plan to continue to do so

Sooooo yummy! Made just like they would have made them a long time ago at the old diners. The only downfall is the seating.. there are 2 full booths and 2 half booths to sit at and 4 counter seats split up by the register. To the guy that was by himself I hope you enjoyed your full booth, you could have made room for my party of 3!! We wound up eating in the car, which was not a pleasant experience. Even though they were busy, they still had nice workers. I will return again just because they have good food.. just need more places to sit down to eat. Maybe invest in a bigger location. UPDATE: No indoor seating available, They have a window that you walk up to for service. I wish the window was a little bigger and maybe an outdoor speaker for your order to be called. The food at this establishment reminds me a lot of Chris's Hot Dogs in Montgomery, AL. I'm so glad we have a local place like that!

The food was great however they were only open for take out because they were not allowing indoor dining which was a little disappointing.

Love in It. Take me out only at side window.

I've loved this place since I was a little boy, and I remember Mabel going "What fer ya" to her customers.

They have the best burgers and hot dogs in town

The burgers are way overpriced!

My wife and I favorite junk food in Okaloosa County!

Very best burgers around. Came all the way from kansas just to get some.

Been traveling from Boston to Crestview for 22 years and Coney Island is my first stop when I come to town and my last stop when I leave!! Usually take some home with me too!! Love Coney Island!!

This has been a favorite of mine for years. I remember when I was growing up being so excited when my Dad would bring home burgers from Coney Island! I am still just as excited when I stop in now to have one!

Preserving history one meal at a time. This restaurant continues to serve classic foods to the next generation. Our family is eating at this restaurant for many years and I enjoy stopping to visit whenever I happen to be in town. They serve classic hot dogs and hamburgers straight off of the grill with some classic side items as well. This is one of the best Coney island restaurants I have ever visited.

Beautiful and such sweet Ladies!

Small town hole in the wall place serving basic burgers with a unique red sauce. No fountain drinks. Great quick lunch stop 2 burgers and yoohoo will not break the bank either.

Delicious as always, Fast and Friendly Service ❣️😁👍They have been here as a Restaurant the Longest in Our Town❣️🇺🇸

Very disappointed.. visited this establishment as a youngster..

Coney Island has been a favorite in this town longer than I have been around!! It is an icon in Crestview. If you've never had the pleasure of enjoying their chili dogs or (my favorite) their hamburgers, then you are missing something for sure!! There is no other burger or dog like it!! People actually come from everywhere (even as fast as Alaska & Hawaii) to have these!! Of course the locals are spoiled!!

Always have to stop by when I'm in town, awesome food and always fun!

Love it and have always since childhood.

Decent food and customer service. The hotdogs are small. The burger patties are thin. The chili sauce is really watery and makes the bun soggy. It has decent flavor. The restaurant was clean, but is really old fashioned. I understand the place is tiny, but it needs a serious upgrade to the 21st century. The restrooms are very tiny and have big hot water heaters that nearly block the sink. Decent experience. They really should think about investing in a larger building.

Unique chili sauce. Hot dogs and hamburgers are both good, but hotdogs are my favorite!

This place has been here for a long time. My paw paw went there when he was younger and it was still the same. It still here the people are so nice and fast

Love this place. Been going there all my life (over 70 years).

Been in business since 1948 and using the same recipe.

Easy to find and a great part of Crestview's downtown. The service was quick and easy while the food was delicious! I definitely recommend getting it how they serve it, with chili, mustard, and onions.

Love this place. Crestview is my hometown so I have to make a special trip every time I come to visit. Burgers are still as amazing as they were 35 years ago

Nice atmosphere, good selection, fair pricing and friendly customer service...

Good ole timy burger/dawg shop!!! Been eating there fer a couple decades!

Always stop by Coney Island when I am in town. Delicious, as per the usual

I liked it my the burgers were good hotdogs bun seemed old but I ate it anyway

Must try. Little pricey for a hamburger, but must have when you're in town

I'm a hometown Baker girl so I LOVE Coney Island! Best (different) hamburgers and hotdogs ever!

It was definitely delicious....

I've been going there since 1988 is always being family friendly always friendly always good food at a reasonable price

Never disappointing. Food is great staff are all rock stars.

I haven't had Coney Island in months. Yesterday the craving hit me. Im so glad I made it there before 2p.m. I love there Cheese Burgers and Hot Dogs. If you have never been I recommend making it a must try. It has thatal Old Town vibe.

My mom and I have came here for years. She just pass away in June. Best place ever for some great delicious burgers. You have not live till you try one!!!