Fancy Yancey's Coney on the Island in Midway - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

Do not go expecting the lunch special @ 3:30pm. I had no idea they had a lunch special until I got to the establishment and looked at the menu. The menu states lunch special ends at 3:30 so I decided I’d order that. Was told they stop the lunch special at 3 🙃 even though the menu states 3:30 & I was in the restaurant even before 3 but was undecided because it was my first time. DO NOT EXPECT CHILI FLAVOR OR MEAT WITH THE CHILI CHEESE FRIES the taste was more of watered down tomato sauce and beans & cheese sauce. Culver’s or Wendy’s has better chili for less. The wings were good but not spectacular but definitely better than most places around. The owners seem very nice if I go back it would be for convo with them & wings only.

Best wings around by far!! Amazing owners and super friendly atmosphere.

Love this place but the only thing that keeps me from going here more often is the hours of operation sometimes are inconsistent. Other then that you'll never get better wings then this place! SO GOOD!!!!

Great food at even lower prices than posted online. Will definitely be a regular !

If you are anywhere in the area, or just passing thru, you need to stop here!! Food is delicious, beer is cold, and Byron and Audrey are the best!!

Decor needed just a bit of work but his wings are amazing

Top notch wings nice sports bar theme inside.great service as well.will be a repeat customer again and again

Made a quick stop for something to eat. Couldn't be more pleased with the wings and service. Affordable, good company and I'm Definitely becoming a regular.

Super laid back environment and awesome staff with solidly good food. Just don't underestimate the spiciness of the wing sauces

Awesome chicken wings and great flavors. They were slow and about to close when we stopped. They stayed open for us to eat amazing customer service

Driving West bound on 98 just past the Zoo is this hidden gem. An independently owned and operated eatery specializing in burgers, dogs. Wings and brew. 19 different beers on tap. I had the 15 count wings with Angry Audrey sauce. It is BBQ base integrated with spice.(Audrey would not tell me the secret) Much different than what you find at the national and regional chain. Audrey recommended I stay at that level of heat and she was right. They were good size (bigger than BW3) and tasted great. Also for those like me with peanut allergy, they use canola oil. If you are driving fast you will miss the whole strip mall. Highly recommend trying Fancy Yancey's.

So consistent! I’ve been enjoying wings at Fancy Yancy’s for four years as of this month, and the meat and sauces are always delicious! You also won’t find friendlier folks than the owner-operaters, Byron and Audrey.

Food was awesome! I love how friendly and open they were to welcome us in straight off of the beach! Even had an actual high chair for my youngest! Would definitely recommend this place!

This is a nice whole in the wall place that will blow your mind. Fancy Yancey's atmosphere feels like you're in mom's kitchen. Has a real high chair for the kids. Great food. Hot dogs cooked like you've never had and that bun alone will change your world. As for the philly goes it comes on a delightfully toasted bun with finely chopped meat, crunchy lettuce, and a grander fresh tomato. You think that's all good you should try the wings. The wings were large,crispy, and very flavorful.so good I even bought some of her sauce to take with me.

Amazing food! Byron and Audrey are the absolute best! Great hole in the wall spot! You will not be disappointed in the wings

They are so friendly, & sooo delicious, mmmmm!!

best wings in Gulf Breeze/Navarre not to mention a great beer selection

LITERALLY THE BEST PLACE AROUND IN ALL ASPECTS!

I gotta tell ya that Fancy Yancey's restored some of my desire to eat local. After who knows how long of ordering out I am sick of it, but I wanted to share what a treat my food was when I ordered from Fancy Yancy and I was a treat because it seemed real and that someone cared enough to hand make a Hamburger patty and knew not to work it too much. Very good Burger plus it stayed together, I love it when the burger will stay together and the bun remain until the end. I ordered kind of late and they still took the time to do it right, which means a lot to me. Food lately,and I hear it from lots of people just doesn't seem to taste as good, but I highly recommend Fancy Yancey's I hate to admit I have not had a "Coney" or the Chilli but I think it is a great idea and chilli parlors in the Midwest are great places to eat so I look forward to tasting more of the menu. Good Chilli served with multiple topping and over spaghetti 🍝 hard to beat the taste. You can tell they care and that goes a long way toward great food. ✌️👏👏👏

Best burgers, Fries and Onion rings. So reasonable can’t beat it. The owners went out of their way for us. Highly recommended. Try it out, You won’t be disppointed.

Our favorite place for wings! Love the 3way spaghetti too! It's nice to have an old favorite from home. The owners are so nice too. This is our favorite place

Awesome place, great atmosphere and the owners are real down to earth people . Highly recommend anyone to stop in and enjoy the family style atmosphere.

BEST hot dog and wings I've had in a long time! Friendly atmosphere and owner; Byron is both funny and nice.

Get wingz ! Awsome owners! Great Beer!

Really friendly staff and atmosphere. The Chilli is thick and hearty, just the way it should be. Thank you Audrey and Byron, your food is fantastic.

nicest people and the nicest wings I've tried. only trouble is I live to close and want wings everytime I pass 😂

Awesome place to grab some tasty food and Cold beer! Audrey and Byron are The Best!!

Food was great, staff/Management were kind and prompt.

Stopped by after the zoo today and were very impressed. All of our food was really good, thoroughly enjoyed the Angry Audrey wings. The service was attentive, friendly, and personable, all around good place to grab a bite or beer!

First off, Byron and Audrey customer service is the biggest reason to come here. They will hold a conversation with you or leave you to your personal space. But never will you go without beer/a refreshment by your side. And if in the mood, they'll cook you up some fresh off their menu. They serve up the typical bar foods with their own little twist to them. My last go I had a coney chilli hotdog and chilli fries. I don't know what the secret ingredient is in the chilli but it kept me wanting another bite. Down home friendly bar with cold beer and good food definitely make this place a must stop by if in the area.

Great food and the coldest beer!

Delicious. That's the best way to describe the coney dog! My first time eating there👌