Fenney Grill in Wildwood - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

Onion rings were great, disappointed with their wings. Bartender seemed uninformed on food. They do have a gluten free dessert, which is a big plus for me.

This is a nice place to get a sandwich or salad and relax by a pool. Beautiful setting. The service was wonderful.

Stopped for a drink. Got chicken tenders as well. Very good

Brought out the wrong meal which was quickly corrected.

My wife and I dined at here yesterday with another couple. The service was disappointingly slow, and the overall atmosphere was quite noisy due to the lively bar area. I ordered the pot roast, which was tough and didn’t resemble the dish I expected. The rest of our party’s meals were merely average at best. To top it off, the waiter made two errors when presenting the bill.

Absolutely amazing staff. My wife has multiple food allergies. She only eats about 15 foods. They went above and beyond making sure her foods were allergen free, which is not easy to do. Phenomenal waiter Eric and the back of the house manger spent a lot of time going over how they could cook her food correctly. This will be our new place a few times a week. Our food was awesome. Thank you again for making a pleasureable dining experience. We truly appreciate the effort you went into making her meal tailored to her dietary needs.

Went during a "storm" and appreciated the fact that they were open. Four of us ate and four of us cleaned our plate. The prices were reasonable and the service was on point. Chicken dishes were all very good with good portions. Good burger, cooked just like it was ordered and a good salad. Bruschetta appetizer was excellent also. Definitely worth a visit.

Really enjoy eating here, it's a great environment in the food is pretty good

A really great place for lunch!! Hubby and I split the reuben sandwich with the home made chips... Perfect portion for 2 of us. Lobster bisque was excellent!

This has become our Sunday breakfast and reflection and our many blessings.

Food is just ok.....sitting at bar, service is horrible, bartenders are usually inattentive at best

We went to Fenney's Grill to celebrate my husband's 72 birthday. The service and food was excellent! We will certainly be back.

Great location with a spectacular porch. Food is pretty hit or miss. They are better at executing the lunch menu. Really like the loaded chili and chicken strips. Front of house staff can be a little rude but servers are good.

The food is okay, but it is in a beautiful setting. Our server had a bit of an attitude though, which put a damper on enjoying our meal. The French dip was tasty, but it was on the dry side - my thinking was because the steak was overcooked.

I enjoyed the meal, the service, and the closeness to Fenney Rec Center. I'll be back many times!

Staff is incredibly rude, starting with the hostess. Food quality is dependent on what you order. Burgers are good. French dip was horrible…dry with a salty brown dip. Service is slow.

Not sharing any names but I think the female bartender is bipolar, or Schizophrenic (not criticizing, just meditate). The first time we went, she waited on everyone else first and yelled at us when we questioned her. The next time she was so obnoxiously chipper. It was very sickening. I wish they would hire me.

Recently had lunch at Fenneys. Simple Cheeseburger w/fries. Cheeseburger was delicious. It was juicy, good flavor, bun was toasted, you could take the grill on the burger. The fries were salt & pepper seasoned but nicely done. I did not have to add any additional salt, as I normally do. Ella, our server was terrific. Friendly, attentive, kept our drinks full and did not keep us waiting. They were not busy on a Wed afternoon so it was nice to side on the screened porch and have a quiet lunch. Beautiful landscaping. Lots of mature trees and shade. I would recommend going for lunch or dinner. Great place. I'll be back to try more!

Wonderful food...beautiful location. Don't eat inside if you want a quiet table and conversation. It's loud inside. Choose the porch if it's not too hot outside. The chicken tenders salad is really good! The

Very friendly staff and food was delicious.

We gave it a 3 for food as it is slipping. Our party ordered the spinach salad 2 days in a row. NOTICEABLE difference in (lack) of ingredients. Menu choices need an update. Love its convenient location. Staff are always very friendly.

Beautiful restaurant. Relaxing setting. Unfortunately the complements stops here. We ordered meatloaf and beaf stew. I can say with great certainty that, that was the worst we had in all the restaurants we have ever been, anywhere.

Love this place! Indoor and outdoor dining. Food is consistently good. So relaxing to sip mimosas while enjoying the pool view on the shaded patio under a fan. Very clean. Reasonable prices.

Went for father's day. Kitchen was swamped, so it took long to get food. Service was excellent and food was good as always.

Wings were very good, but seafood dishes are lame. Should have known better, stick to basics (hamburgers, French dip, etc).

It wasn't bad. It was just ok. The food was was edible nothing to Rave about but nothing to complain about. Server was nice but we were the only table filled on the patio and it took more than 8 minutes before we were greeted at the table. The dinner special was tasty but don't come hungry because if you get that you're going to leave that way also, very small portions for the "special" price.

I have had lunch here twice in the last month. Both meals were good, not great but good. The Ceasar salad with chicken had way too much dressing on it, it was good, but get the dressing on the side so you can control how much you want. On the second visit the waitress was ok but not real helpful. All that said we will go back.

Very beautiful place to meet with friends and enjoy good food. Wonderful path to walk among the trees afterward. Think this might be one of my top 3 picks for restaurants in the Villages.

Food was bla. Hardly any meat in the cheese steak over 40.00 for 3 and meat was little to none it was good but none

not the best dining experience but not the worst.

Food is good. The service can be a little slow as it tends to be crowded.

Super food and the waitress was super nice

Good food and reasonable prices.

We like to eat outside in the covered screened area. Always great food and service.

Great atmosphere and great food

Beautiful atmosphere and great service. This place is worth the golf car ride. Make sure to check out the nature walkway.

Ate inside. It was loud! Waitress was great! I would give her 10 stars if I could. I got the chili. It was very good.

I had a business luncheon here today with an old workmate from the ATL. Service and food were both very good. If I'm back in the Villagees, I would eat here again.

Excellent service, delicious food, perfectly cooked. I had ordered couple of times Chicken wings grilled they are tasty and delicious. Also tourkey melt sandwich and grilled chicken sandwich with Swiss cheese and mushrooms 🍄‍🟫 delicious! Enjoy have a good time. That’s what life is about.

The menu doesn't change. The food is good/okay. Nothing I would keep going back for.

We used to enjoy going to lunch at Fenney Grill, so we brought family there yesterday and what a disappointment! The food was mediocre and the service was poor. It has been a while, so the change was rather stark. Do not recommend.

Food is great. Service was good too. Nice atmosphere as well

The food was excellent and reasonable. The wait staff was very attentive to every need. I will be going there again, when I visit Florida.

What a shame. Fenney Grill really missed the service boat. The young hostess was not a good fit. She was snotty and short when we asked questions about seating. Appeared as if we were seriously inconveniencing her. We left so no stars on food. We did sit outside and enjoyed the music and a drink. We were already there so what the hell.

Stopped in for lunch. After waiting 10 minutes for someone to seat us. We were told 15 min wait to sit out on porch. Opted for seat at the bar. Upon arriving the bartender rolled his eyes when we took a seat. Clearly he had no interest in serving us. The food was very good and arrived in a timely manner. The bartender should be terminated for his rude behavior. If fenney grill can’t do better than this just close the doors.

4 of us got seated about 3:30pm and ordered drinks and 2 appetizers. We all ordered that days dinner special that began at 4pm. Two tables of 6 and 4 people got seated close to 4pm and both tables got there dinner before us. We got served ours about 4:45pm and the scallop potatoes were not even close to being cooked and the asparagus was more like string beans. We asked for the manager after the meal to discuss this along with a couple other issues. She comes over in shorts and a T-shirt looking like she just came from the kitchen. She didn't introduce herself and went straight into asking us what the issues where. She was very rude and unprofessional during the conversation to say the least. Needless to say we will never eat there again. I normally do not post reviews but this was a very bad experience which forced me to leave a 5 percent tip on a $150 bill.

Ordered Philly cheesesteak sandwich which was very good quality and reasonably priced. Service was excellent and food was brought promptly even though they were pretty busy.

In a very beautiful and relaxing setting overlooking pool if you eat in the screened lanai. Egg salad sandwich and onion rings were outstanding. Bruchetta was disappointing, so not sure of consistency of kitchen. Fish sandwich good. Menu very limited. Service was a bit casual for my liking. (Left dirty plates in front of us for extended periods and asked I keep my used fork for the main course) Otherwise, it was still a nice meal for Florida standards.

Of all the pools in The Villages to go to this one is the worst. Not only do they not have a lot of lounge chairs, their max occupancy is 50 and will cut off family members from entering even if they have chairs for them. The staff are rude and aggressive about the rules. The male bartender was the rudest of them all. He would not acknowledge us in line, when we asked about a drink, he rudely answered with his lack of knowledge and then accused us for being from Wisconsin and when we corrected him that we were from Canada, he stated “well that is worse”. When we walked around the bar to leave due he blurts out “it’s not going to be faster on the other side everyone at the bar is waiting”. I said we’re leaving because you can’t be nice! If you want food and drink…go to Edna’s!

Always love this place! Food is great, staff are fun and professional.

The Fenney Grill is a Fantastic Place for Food and Cocktails and Swimming.But the Best time is on Thursday late afternoon when P-Will Brings his Magic to the Backyard at The Fenney for Music Mania !!! A Great Night for All involved. Bravo P-WILL ⭐⭐⭐⭐

Is great spot highly recommended

Hospitality is amazing, and great food!

First and foremost, I just wanna start by saying I NEVER leave reviews… so you know that 1 star is extraordinarily earned. I came in with a party of 9, when my wife walked in to tell them we were here, the hostess looked at her like she was stupid, said “I’ll see what I can do” & walked away… we sat for 45 minutes with MULTIPLE large tables available and finally got sat at what felt like a kids table at an adult event. 15 minutes later, our server shows up and rolls her eyes at us for asking for water. 5-6 minutes later she shows up with 3 out of the 9 waters that were in WARM classes smaller than the pint glasses the bar offers… 10-15 minutes after that, she asks what we want to eat.. I asked if I can upgrade my vegetable to the asparagus and she said sure, it’ll be $4, I said okay no problem assuming I was going to get a SIDE of asparagus.. the food comes out 50 minutes later WITH the appetizers at the same time, room temp & my side of $4 asparagus was 3 pieces of asparagus cut in half, after the entire party of 9 was disgusted with the food (chicken undercooked for one) we waited for another 15 minutes for her to come back with the checks…. (Nowhere to be found) so I had to get up out of the table and wave her down while she was just standing in the kitchen talking to a co worker. The service was absolutely AWFUL. The food was absolutely DREADFUL. The seating was absolutely TERRIBLE. Moral of the story, they definitely bring in the D team for dinner. Don’t do it.

One of my favorite local spots..

Hubs chicken quesadilla was great. I had cold plate with tuna, egg salad, and chicken. Looked great, but tuna and egg salad tasted odd, and I didn't eat it. Not good. Hubs tasted them both and said the same thing. The chicken salad was okay and I ate only half. I'm not a picky eater, but their cold salads just taste odd. I've had better cold plate food experience at Toojay's.

Very nice setting. We didn't have time to really see everything but it was very pretty. The food was all good but not amazing. it was a little pricey but not terrible

It's so convenient but our food was just OK and the service was poor. Maybe they were having an off day... Update, March 2024. This was fantastic. I had a burger that was delicious! Service was wonderful

Four of us went to eat and thought the place was great 😃

They didn't seat us, after an extended wait. They were seating residents as a priority.

The food was delicious. The Salmon with Mediterranean Orzo was perfectly presented with a balsamic glaze. The Shrimp and Scallops were cooked perfectly.

I went to Fenny Grill on March 10th around lunch time with my neighbors. We sat at the bar and ordered food and drinks. The male bar tender made some rude comments to his co-worker about my husband’s FL State shirt to which we just ignored. I ordered a side salad and poured the dressing on it only to realize it was all oil. We paid the bill and tipped him. I nicely asked about the dressing. I wanted to know if the dressing is typically mostly oil so that I know not to order it again. I wasn’t asking for anything or complaining; nor was I confrontational. He lectured me and got defensive that I should have said something. I told him he never came by and I was hungry and after drenching it in oil I didn’t need to add to it. All I wanted to know is for the next time. He just turned around and shook his head. After being treated so rudely, my neighbors all said he should “go to charm school “. I decided to call the manager when we got home 20 mins later. I was told “they were all in a meeting” and someone would call me back. I mentioned on the phone that I didn’t want anything but to provide feedback. Needless to say, it’s been 5 days and no phone call from a manager. I guess a negative review is well deserved for you and a lost customer for good! My neighbors feel the same way.

Lovely place to have lunch with your friends! Beautiful surroundings, great club house! Beautiful path to walk after a meal

Attitudes by workers. Just not friendly. They talk down to you. They have to step it up. Use a little class.

Great place to eat, visit with friends and great service.

Beautiful grounds, had a delicious sangria with lots of fresh fruit. Ordered Mahi mahii with pineapple salsa. Fish was average with odd seasonings, white rice ok, pieapple salsa was nothing more than under ripe pieapole diced, but the mixed seasonal vegetables were inedible! Broccoli, cauliflower and carrots cooked to mush. Who cooked like that? I saw other people who also left it untouched on their plate. This was not a cheap meal, and very disappointing.

Delicious chicken tenders and fish tenders! Complimentary home-cooked chips were just delish!!!! Staff was kind and friendly. Really enjoyed our meal!!!!!!! 👍

Meh...Ruben would have been awesome but the bread was barely toasted on the bottom soggy on top had it been grilled it would have been good. 10 minute wait . Prices seemed very reasonable and server was friendly.

Our server Veronica was fantastic

Just had drinks by the pool. Very relaxing. The food we saw while walking thru the restaurant looked amazing!

The food was good. No one in our group had any complaints. The drinks were pricey small and mixed very weak. The outside is impressive. The inside is well decorated as well. The dining area has very poor acoustics. Trying to hold a conversation is hard. Service was good but not great. Parking is ok. The place is clean. A miserable dining experience. Not a place I want to return to.

Nice place, a little bit slow but they were busy. Great setting.

Food was OK, drinks were a bit on the weak side but the service was great! A little pricey for the quality

Food and drinks were good Entertainment was very good. Outdoor bartender like it was a bother to serve people.

Good atmosphere and excellent food

Great chili onion rings good Hamburger average wouldn't order again

Horrible service. Wait over 30 mins after placing order. Also they need poolside service

Great place to eat & enjoy the friendly staff. Food was awesome & priced right!!

Favorite breakfast! And servers.

Outstanding service in a relaxed setting with great food. We had a fun evening and really appreciated the hospitality.

Food is basic, service is great.

Always a great place to eat. Everything is always the way it should be.

First time here, the servers were very nice. The fried and broiled fish was good. Chicken Picatta was good but came with no lemon sauce....that's the best part of that dish. I was disappounted. We had 1 complaint as my husband received about 1/2 ice cream scoop of mashed potatoes. But another waitress brought him out more, plenty more potatoes.

We have been there 4 times. Never very busy. Each time the service was sooooo slow from hostess seating you to the waiter service. They should have more then 1 hostess and a few more waitresses

Great food, service, and music on the outdoor stage!

Way better than the higher rated options

Our waitress was outstanding and the restaurant was clean. The omelet and sausage links were great.

This beautiful restaurant with a nice cozy cabin-feel was such a delight for lunch with me and my mom! The Pesto Chicken Flatbread was soooo good we scarfed it down in less than a minute! My goodness!! I was so impressed! You can tell they use fresh ingredients! I also had the Italian Sub and tried my mom's Salmon BLT (a lunch special only on Saturday's) and it continued to be absolutely amazing! So very happy I picked the best spot in The Villages to eat!

Had a great dinner tonight! The food was wonderful! Our server Laurie was excellent & took fantastic care of us!! We will go back!!

Dined in for cheeseburger and side salad, great choice. Great service left in time to hear some music.

Enjoy the atmosphere, service & food

We rallied around the fire pit with The Austin Family for holiday season pre game was amazing.

Great service, good menu, nice presentation, good portions, very fair prices - a great meal, thank you!

Wonderful atmosphere and the food was amazing. Will definitely return!

The food and service was excellent

Fantastic food, service and atmosphere 5-star experience.

My favorite place to go get lunch at on break.

After 3 visits, I conclude that the food is of poor quality and you don't need to know how to cook to get a job as a cook here. Maybe have a drink 🍸 instead.

Fantastic restaurant in the villages

I was enjoying the swimming pool.