Jay Gee's Ice Cream - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

We had ice cream and sat outside. We really enjoyed it

I love this place. All their flavors and the ice creams are fabulous and portion sizes are impressive! Highly recommend to anyone with sweet tooth.

Service was very good. The ice cream was great. The prices were also good.

Absolutely delicious ice cream. Location off a busy road could be better but that ain't why you go here

Kiddie portion all day. Amazing spot with some great flavors. I dont eat a ton of ice cream but you can def share a kiddie portion. Enjoy the pistachio or the blackberry.

I ordered I rum raisin cone and after waiting for my order, the girl came with my cone I tried and definitely it wasn’t what I ordered, it was Maple Walnut, I asked her if rum raisin has walnut because this doesn’t taste like what I ordered Then she acts like she didn’t know what the Ice cream have and she couldn’t even go to check if the one that she got me was the right one!! And if I had allergies to walnuts, JESUS! We are paying our money, so they should be more careful about thing. I payed for an Ice cream that I didn’t like and didn’t ordered.

Service was great. I wish the servings were a bit bigger.

Great ice cream, and not the same brand most local shops sell. They were out of the flavor I wanted, guess I just have to go back again!

Beautiful little spot, the team that runs the store does very well. Always very friendly and welcoming ! Portions are big too ! Bring the family ! They will love it

First time checking this place out. I really enjoyed the homemade ice cream, selection of flavors and options. The flavors were enjoyable and the ice cream was both rich and creamy. The prices were very reasonable.

Great ice cream anytime of year.

I went and got 4 ice creams and paid with a $50 and I didn't get the right amount of money back. I got shorted $10

Un helado 🍦 de pistacho sin azúcar riquísimo que comí ahí excelente 😋👏👏👏

Our experience at Jay Gee’s Homemade Ice Cream was OUT OF THIS WORLD! The staff at the window was so friendly, helpful and patient as we asked about flavors. Decided on the seasonal pumpkin and chocolate peanut butter for one sundae and pumpkin Oreo with maple walnut for the other. Both with homemade hot fudge and whipped cream with nuts and a cherry on top! 🍒 Perfect size for me, too big and take home for her. Definitely recommend Jay Gee’s!

Happy staff. Best flavors in town.

The process for ordering a custom ice cream cake is super easy, the cake was adorable, just what we wanted, and the birthday girl loved it! Thank you Jay Gee's !!!

We love coming here every summer with the family to have fun and eat yummy ice cream

Ice cream was delicious, portion was generous

Ice Cream & other desserts were tasty, but Overcrowding caused Long, Slow Lines for service. Sticky, sugar-coated service bar and seating areas attracted too many flying 🪰 pests, including mosquitoes. 🦟

Love being able to order ahead on website and using separate pickup window when I arrive.

Love the variety of ice cream here

A good amount of flavors and generous portions.

My granddaughters softball team went there, they enjoyed it!

We absolutely love their ice cream! This week, it was a sundae with butter crunch and caramel 🙂

Place was alright but the girl gave me the wrong icecream and when i told them they took her into the back and shot her in the head. A little extreme but otherwise the icecream is great!

Good ice cream comparable prices

Love the ice cream here very good service

This has to be some of the best ice cream in Salem. People are so nice and work quickly. I’ve cream is so valid. I recommend this blue Cookie Monster ice cream. So good and the portions are massive. Overall 12/10 would recommend!

Yummy sundae, served quickly and with a smile.

It was awesome highly recommend

Very slow service. The ice cream tasted very good. Serving sizes are smaller than other places in Salem.

really solid homemade ice cream, nice and light consistency and good overall flavor

Everything there is delicious and the servings are very generous. Service was super quick and they have an outside sitting area.

Lovely place to have ice cream 🍦. The quantity they give is very very much . Nice place to take your kids 😉. Really best place for kids. If you're a ice cream 🍨 lover you enjoy a lot.

The gals at the pickup window are always so nice and complimentary when I pick up our online orders! We love to order their website and skip the line. Also love they have dairy free options!

Great ice cream I love the purple cow frozen yogurt

Great place to go for ice cream the only downside extremely noisy on route 28 why

Great ice cream with a good variety

Very wide selection of flavors including several specialties. Great stop for the kids or the kid in you.

Best ice cream place in the area. I love their milk shakes!! Update 2022: Still our favorite ice cream place!

Kinda bland. Gave big portions for price.