Jeremiah's Italian Ice in Lakeside - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

Great place for the whole family, especially the kids!!

My boys and I can't share Jeremiah's. We all must get our own. Love their favor.

They've added different toppings of cookies! This just adds to a perfect dessert!

Always delicious. The people working there are always patient.

Jeremiah's is a guilty pleasure. The orange with the vanilla is the best Creamsicle you will ever put your tongue on

This place was great! I visited this past weekend for the first (and second time) and I will continue to return every time I visit the area. The staff is great, all 5 things we ordered were delicious and it’s a great place to sit outside and enjoy some family time! There’s limited parking though, and no indoor seating. Drive through was a great option!

Delicious every time, but price hikes with smaller cup sizes is WILD. Haven't been since they increased the prices and changed their cup size. Good, but not that good.

Love them.. All ways good drinks.

One of our favorite places always really nice and the food is always great

Always excellent Italian ice and the soft serve ice cream they use is also incredible!

I have been a loyal patron of Jeremiah's for a long time. However, today at 12:00 PM, I was disheartened by the lack of friendliness and accuracy from the young woman at the drive-thru. I felt rushed and interrupted while trying to place my order for additional items. Experiencing a decline in customer service at a place I have always cherished was truly disappointing.

Red raspberry with cake batter is delish! July: Was very runny on our last visit and was more like a melted milkshake consistency. Outside tables were dirty and un-sturdy 😢

Awesome ice cream and Italian ice, the young workers are very nice. The service is too slow.

Their sugar free cherry flavor is so good! Only wish they had more than 1 sugar free option a day.

Best place in town to get a cool treat

Always the best service from the entire staff and the soft serve is to die for!!! Wish where was one in North Carolina near my cabin in the mountains but I’ll always visit when I come and visit my daughter Bree.

I got a cookie butter with vanilla ice-cream. After a few bites I started getting crunchy pieces //strings what looks like plastic out of my mouth. I tried to call multiple times to make them aware but nobody would answer the phone, just wanted to make them aware that the cookie butter was contaminated.

Great place to get tasty frozen treats! And the service is always excellent!

Love going here every week with the family

The best Italian ice cream they have so many flavors of ice and chocolate and vanilla icecream 🍦😋

Awesome place for those hot days. Gelato is great, soft serve is smooth.

Awesome place ... friendly and very efficient.. line moves fast and order accuracy is 100%

Love this place!! One of my all time favorites for sure!! Never have I been disappointed!!

I come here all the time. I just left here and I’m eating my birthday cake Italian ice cream and I get to my second layer and find a mosquito… almost threw up.

This was my first time stopping by Jeremiah's Italian Ice and all I can say is WOW! I absolutely highly recommend. You will not be disappointed.

Had a great time with my son there

The service is slow due to the large crowds. They should hire more help. The Italian ice and cream are great, hence the long lines. Great flavors.

Cashier was friendly, it’s very delicious!!!!

This is a great little place I've been going to for a couple of years. It offers reasonably priced Gelato. It has been quite busy every time I visit. They have a drive-thru that can be used or you can park and walk up to a service window. They offer free samples to try if you're uncertain about a product. They have a wonderful app that offers deals and discounts from time to time with the ability to earn rewards. I highly recommend this place.

So delicious all my kids loved this place !!

The ices were amazing and so was the ice cream. The staff is terrific.

Just stood in line for 8 minutes with four people in front of me and the girl at the register was so inexperience that it was taking forever for her to handle the guest she was taken care of to the point I had to leave without getting anything when there's more than 5 war six people standing in line open up the damn second window

Nothing like the girl telling the girl making be ice cream “no tip” and getting our stuff shorted. Evidently this is the entitlement working here now

Stopped by to cash a Valentine gift card my granddaughter got. Staff were very professional and very helpful.

This place is a great cold treats shop. There sre many. This is one of the best. Super flavors. Great staff. Short waits. You guys are awesome. Treats are delish

Lovely staff. Explained the menu and gave wonderful suggestions

Jeremiah 's cooler than a fan I get that sea salt caramel sometimes with the swirl of vanilla and the staff is always excellent get you some

This is a nice place to spend time with friends and the attention of the employees is great. In addition to its incredible variety and exquisite ice creams.

Okay y'all so this ice cream is so creamy and delicious I'm quite sure my words will not do it justice! I'm gonna try though..absolutely amazing. I got a pint of vanilla & chocolate and my family loved it. Chloe was extremely friendly and knowledgeable. She recommended cookie butter gelati and I plan to try it when I go back.

Food is great , but they always turn the point of sale around and say " it is going to ask a few questions." Like tip of 20 % get real boss pay your employees minimum wage .

My family and our dog always enjoy. They offer a pup cup.

I recommend the Gelato it's amazing

I live in Chicago I was visiting my daughter this place was beautiful and the service was remarkable the ice cream was delicious great idea a wonderful place to sit down Fourth number remarkable ice cream thank you

My 1st visit yummy . I got small but couldn't finish it. So. Good ,My Grandchildren love it to .

Love this place, I prefer it's ice cream over anywhere else, the smoothness of the ice cream is unmatched, gelato's are good, I brought my dog and she got a doggy cup, p.s. the sizes are worth the money everytime i get bigger than medium, I can't finish it

Awesome every single time. The staff are great hard working, they greet me by name which is a testament to how often I go. Love jeremiahs

Our favorite family treat!! Love the flavors!! We like to walk up and sit outside on a cool evening.

Jeremiah's Italian Ice 🍿 is a delightful gem. Their array of flavors is impressive, and the quality of ice cream is top-notch. The charming atmosphere and friendly staff make it a perfect spot for a sweet treat any day

Taste ok, but seriously over priced in my opinion... But I guess everything else is 😂

Love the Italian ice cream, good variety of flavor!❤️

We take the kids here weekly! Highly recommend the strawberry shortcake shaved ice

The only thing I can say here is OH MY GOD, these are so delicious! Highly recommend the mango tango!

The italain ice is soo good. I always get the lemon strawberry. Such a great flavor.

Best gelottis ever fast friendly and convenient

Jeremiah's Italian Ice near Middleburg, Florida, is a delightful oasis for ice cream enthusiasts, and its standout S'mores ice cream is an absolute showstopper. Nestled in the heart of Middleburg, Jeremiah's Italian Ice is a haven for those seeking respite from the Florida sun with delectable frozen treats. Among its many offerings, the S'mores ice cream stands tall as a mouthwatering marvel that promises to satisfy every sweet tooth. From the first spoonful, one is transported to a fireside camping adventure, as the S'mores ice cream masterfully captures the essence of the beloved campfire treat. The velvety smooth texture delights the palate, while the decadent chocolate and marshmallow swirls evoke a sense of gooey nostalgia. Tantalizing bits of graham cracker pieces add a delightful crunch, completing the symphony of flavors that dance harmoniously on the taste buds. The brilliance of the S'mores ice cream lies in its artful balance of sweetness, recreating the classic campfire treat with finesse and creativity. It is a treat that both young and old will cherish, evoking memories of cozy gatherings under the starlit sky. The ambiance at Jeremiah's Italian Ice further enhances the ice cream experience, with a welcoming and friendly atmosphere that beckons visitors to linger and indulge in their sweet fantasies. The staff's warm smiles and prompt service contribute to a delightful outing, leaving patrons eager to return for more. As an indulgence amidst the balmy Florida weather, Jeremiah's S'mores ice cream proves to be a captivating highlight, drawing ice cream enthusiasts from far and wide to savor its delightful charm. Whether you're relishing a leisurely evening stroll or seeking a refreshing treat after a day of exploration, Jeremiah's Italian Ice and its irresistible S'mores ice cream are sure to leave a lasting impression and ignite a newfound passion for frozen delights. Don't miss the opportunity to embark on this delightful ice cream adventure, a delightful journey that will surely leave you with a smile on your face and a heart filled with pure delight.

If you want awesome gelato ice and ice cream combos this is the only place to go. And the App rewards are very good.

They have italian icys, soft serve and mixtures of both. Everyone liked their snack. Excellent for a hot day

Yummy Perfecf Gelati Ice Cream in town..

Everyone loved their drinks. Thank you.

Highly recommended by the grandchildren

The water ice actually tastes like the flavor it says

First time here, very delicious gelati and reasonable prices

It was delicious, and the line moved quickly. What more could you ask? 🙂

Best Italian ice wrapped around your choice of vanilla, chocolate, or twist! Salted Carmel awesome but the Grasshopper is the best!