Katie's Korner Homemade Ice Cream - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

Katie’s ice cream is so delicious & I especially love the Spumoni. Now, I’m not trying to have an ice cream fight with anyone but I do favor Katie’s over our other well known ice cream shops we have in the area. It’s not by much & really just a texture preference for me. As far as flavor is concerned, they have outstanding choices & so many great flavors to choose from.

Best Iced Cream on the PLANET! Came all the way from Florida to enjoy the best ice cream money can buy!

Apple dumpling and ice cream were very good.

Delicious butter pecan ice cream. It's rich and creamy

Always reasonable and good service

Haven't been to Katie's Korner since I graduated college about 30 years ago. I was thrilled to see it was still open and shocked that the ice cream was even better than I remembered. There are a lot of places in the area to get ice cream, but none compares to Katie's Korner. I'm looking forward to the next trip to Ohio just to go back.

Wonderful ice cream and wide variety of choices in flavors. Great place to stop and get a delicious treat!

Great ice cream for years we go there summer.

It pains me to make this review but I hope ownership will see this and make some changes. Ive been going to Katies Korner for 30+ years because I love HARD packed homemade ice cream. The last few years the ice cream quality has been extremely inconsistent. The majority of times I place an order the ice cream has been soupy and melted (basically soft serve). I went today and again, the ice cream was melted as soon as I opened it. I am switching to Jesy’s as I recently discovered them and their ice cream has not disappointed me so far. It is the quality that I used to expect from Katie’s. If Katie’s can get their quality under control I will gladly return as they have phenomenal ice cream when it is actually frozen.

Don't waste your time or money! Was lied to about an allergen and had to throw it away and flavors were misleading, never again.

Melted ice cream and we asked toppings on banana split (allergic to strawberry) and they said no strawberries and we get home and it has strawberry. Superman ice cream tasted like vanilla. Do not waste your time or money. Never going back.

This is my absolute go-to for good ice cream. It’s definitely a carry out place. There is a few picnic tables in front of the store & a few in the rear of the business. If the weather is nice, you can enjoy your ice cream there. I usually get my double scoop mint chip waffle cone in my car. There is a very ample parking lot why you can park & enjoy your Ice Cream. The staff is always super friendly & polite, I’ve never had a bad interaction here. They seem to have at least 50 flavors of some amazing ice cream flavors. I’m a huge fan of mint chip, dark chocolate peanut butter & German chocolate cake. I’m also a massive fan of the waffle cone, which they make here. I really love this place during the summer months and will make many stops to get a waffle cone and enjoy all of yag ice cream goodness. If you love great ice cream, this is your place.

It's the best Ice cream, the employees are very polite and friendly. Stop in anytime for a treat highly recommend them

Very special place to take your family and have a nice little picnic eating ice cream.They also have nice milkshakes and just about any flavor you want.

Some of the best ice cream in the country. Workers are always very nice and friendly.

One of the few places that has sugar free ice cream. Always good service.

Love the Oreo ice cream, so good!

Been going here since I was a kid... 20 years later and it hasn't changed a bit. My favorite!

Old fashioned ice cream stand using real ingredients and lots of flavors to chose from. I would definitely recommend this place to anyone looking for an ice cream treat. The shake I ordered was not overly sweet and nothing artificial. I was worried about the flavor being overly sweet but that did not happen. I’m impressed.

Ten, ten, ten!!!!!!!!!! I love everything about this place! Sunday's just how you want them ( Hot fudge with coffee ice cream ) By far, the best ice cream in town. My daughter lives next to Handel's and drives religiously to this location about 15 minutes away!

Good quality ice cream, recommended.

Their ice cream is delicious, the girls that wait on the customers are so delightful and courteous.

Can't go past without stopping for a double chocolate peanut butter swirl waffle cone 😋 😋 😋

Superior service and selection.

Butter Pecan in a waffle cone is amazing!

Absolutly love Katie's Ice Cream been going for years .

Some of the best ice cream in this area. Open year round!! Soo many flavors to try

Every flavor ive had has been great. A plus plus

Found by accident, but was great!

My boyfriend gets a vanilla cone daily from here lol

Love going to this location! The staff is so friendly and very reasonable prices. They use real Oreos in their Oreo Ice cream. My favorite ice cream us the Play dough, which only comes out every so often. All the ice cream is homemade. They even have some picnic tables outside to sit at in the back that have shade.

I would say that I personally would rate it a little lower for myself but I feel like other people would really like it. So we stopped by because I was getting a ride & while I don't particularly like sweets but it was like yeah I'll take a little cup. I got an amount of ice cream that was three times the amount what the cup could hold somehow. So there is a lot of bang for your buck as it wasn't pricey, but I did not want that much, personally...

Straight up, love this place. Also where else in America can you buy ice cream for a family, for under $20? There is definitely quality in every cone, cup and sandwich they make. The staff is obviously high school kids, but they are super friendly and take their jobs seriously. Which to be fair, at that age, I was no where near as professional as these kids are. I hope this place continues to thrive. The ice cream is real ice cream, with high quality candy inclusions and fruit.

They know how to make ice cream. Try 2 scoops in a waffle cone.

One of the best ice cream shops many different flavors of ice cream, delicious.

I had a turtle Sunday with whipped cream, my daughter had chocochip cookie dough in a waffle cone. It was delicious.

Amazing Ice cream, I have trouble seeing from a distance and my host was extremely patient and helped me look through the flavors and decide. Best milkshakes around, will definitely be back soon for the amazing service!!

2 milkshakes once. Month for a lifetime. It's like clockwork for me.

Amazing ice cream and treats, great and friendly service. Many different flavors

nice large parking lot. I appreciate the Large selection of flavors that I can't find everywhere. Very creamy

Apple dumplings are great icecream is great

Almost as good as ALMOST HEAVEN ICE CREAM.

Great as usual. Got a chocolate cone and a guart each of butter pecan and black raspberry for home. Yummy yummy.

Very quick service. Great tasting.

Hands down the best ice cream around!! I used to love Handel's, and DQ, and other ice cream places but Katie's is hands DOWN the best!!!!