Love Boat Ice Cream in Sanibel - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

I love this shop and always stop here when on Sanibel but they are all closed up right now.

Had their Salty Jack ice cream at the Sanibel Island location in 2021. All there flavors are great. But hooked on Salty Jack. Hoping the store is reopened after hurricane Ian. Google shows store is temporarily closed.

My wife prefers The Shack for custard but this is my fav ice cream stop in Sanibel. There is a huge selection and the give huge portions.

Delicious ice cream, very well made, impossible to try just one, you have to add all 6 flavors and remember what was ordered, service was good, full of tourists and sometimes there are seasonal flavors, so it's worth visiting more than one time

A very nice Ice Cream Shop, has tons of Flavors, and even 3 Low Fat Sugar Free Options! I had the Smores Ice Cream and my wife had the Blueberry Cheesecake Ice Cream. I tried both and while of course both were very different, they were both delicious! A gem of a Mom & Pop Ice Cream Place on Sanibel, give it a try when you are on the Island!

Amazing ice cream and they give you sooooo much for the price!! My 7 year old Granddaughter couldn't finish the kids size and she's an ice cream fanatic. Lol Highly recommend!!

By FAR the best ice cream we have ever had!! There is nothing that even compares. There has to be close to 50 flavors to choose from, and it’s so hard to decide, because everything this far has been amazing and we usually want the same thing next time - ha! Highly, highly recommend!!

We stop by this place after dinner, and we’re shocked at how awesome this place is. They have quite a large selection of ice cream, and make everything themselves. We ended up getting the turtle sundae with coffee Oreo, dirty turtle and gator tracks. All of those scoops were absolutely delicious. Some of the best ice cream we’ve ever had. We do recommend this place. For some reason there are school banners all over the place inside for their decor. I was happy to find a banner for Texas A&M, my alma mater, as well as the Dallas Cowboys.

Got the sugar free butter pecan. It was delicious!

Tons of flavors. Small waffle cone is enough for two.

Was not great ice cream. They were out of the flavors I wanted. Service was good.

I’ve been here for a week and have come every. single. day. The best ice cream I’ve ever had in my whole life hands down

Really good and a ton of flavors

Ice cream is always great, just took forever to be served because they only had 2 kids working and they were swamped.

Friendly staff and great ice cream

Friendly staff, a ton of flavors, and the ones I tried were delicious.

Delicious as in every Love Boat🧡

Amazing ice cream! Definitely a must when visiting Sanibel Island!

Delicious Icecream Awesome Service Cool Folks

Fabulous Ice Cream, friendly staff and great location.

Don't get the bacon carmel ice cream. Get the cherry.....much better.

WOW!!! Amazing 👏 I read reviews of this place and many others, and decided that this was the place to try. I am sooo glad that I did. The ice cream was spectacular 😋. It was in a shopping plaza on Sanibel Island 🏝 and it was constantly busy. We thoroughly enjoyed the taste and experience. Wonderful dessert 🍨, you will NOT be disappointed. It was a little pricey, until we saw the amount that they dished out for us. We highly recommend 👌

Really good ice cream, large portions.

Unmotivierte Mitarbeiter, Eis teilweise geschmacklos und häufig bereits sehr stark angetaut- nicht empfehlenswert

So many ice cream flavors! Such good ice cream too!

This is an awesome place to stop for ice cream in Sanibel! A great variety of flavors. Hope I return often!

Best tasting Ice cream anywhere and so many flavors!

Our Family's favorite dessert,, The shops are open later than most on the island. After we have dinner we wander over to Jerry's Plaza and walk around until we are ready for the delicious small batch ice cream. Maple Walnut is my favorite 😋

Excellent ice cream flavors and the service is always great

Must go..huge scoops, great flavor..greatest ice cream prices EVER..our go to in Sanibel