Maybe Baby Burgers - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

Best food ever! Loved the decor as well. One of the highlights of the Finger Lakes experience.

We first came across this place a few years ago since we were staying nearby to attend the Watkins Glen nascar race. We are from PA and we return each year and very much look forward to this staple. We no longer go to the race but still return for wine, waterfalls, and Maybe Baby Burgers. Keep up the great work, you def have fans in PA! John

The place has good food but doesn't update hours causing it hard to plan to go out and eat there.

Staff is always friendly. The food is consistently amazing. The Aloha burger is my personal favorite. Fantastic Ice cream. Great place! Warning, it’s gonna be a big tasty burger.

It's quite expensive to eat there but is so worth it.!! Hubby loves their foot longs with chili and cheese. All burgers I have tried, have been great!! Staff is friendly and make you feel welcome.

This is such a charming retro place to eat. The pictures I took tell more than my words. I had the tastier burger ever! Stop by and have the experience.

Great experience here, staff were so friendly and checked in to see if we were enjoying our food. The highlight was the burger, super super juicy! Chicken sandwich was good too, came with a lot of ranch which we liked.

Outstanding burgers friendly staff!

50's style diner. Huge portions. Shakes were excellent with a wide selection of flavors. 1/2 Pound burgers. Fresh hot fries.

Every visit has been pleasant, staff is friendly. The food is fantastic! We thoroughly enjoyed our burgers, fries, and milkshakes!

Great burgers and ice cream, and the staff was very friendly!

Legit burger with a ton of bacon, you won't be hungry

What an amazing magickal little place in the heart of beauty. Food was delicious and massive!! Was a great place to check out on vacation. Loved the decor! A one of a kind gem.

Very good food. A little on the pricy side, but very good!

Maybe Baby Burgers food was very good the service was excellent and friendly I will go back soon

Best burger it was cooked to perfection! Great service! Cool atmosphere. I highly recommend. Wish I would of taken pics.

Very tasty burgers and sides. Salad and vegetables were very fresh.

Cool 50's diner with tasty food & great menu.

Always an enjoyable meal and great food.

Best burger I have had in a long long time . Wish I had taken pictures . The 1/2 burger was to big for me but I brought home leftovers . My boyfriend ate all of his chili burger ! It was hard to choose which burger to have

Very good food. The first day That I had went It was amazing. My second time going there My daughter ordered Something and it was. Not What she thought it was going to be or taste like. So I asked the cashier if I could possibly get something different. She said That's why you should read it better before you order.Basically saying no I couldn't switch her order. Other than that I would have given it a five star review

Great local burger place with a '50s diner theme. Yummy malts. Friday fish fry is also good.

Pleasantly surprised how awesome this place is. Yes the food is amazing but the staff is super attentive and upbeat. I can't say enough good things about this place!

2.5* - I really wish I could be as enthusiastic as other reviewers. The place is adorable, though starting to look runned down with torn seats and stained ceiling tiles. Their intent is great though and it may be the best bathroom in the county. Staff has always been friendly to me but they don't have service. You order, they cook, you get your own drinks and pick up food in the window. When done, wrap it up yourself. I understand the menu presentation, I worked at a place that did it the same way, but they also had regular menus on the counter. Staring up at a brightly lit screen feels awkward and like you're on the spot. There is so much up there. I wish I could have just grabbed a paper menu and sat down until I was ready instead of feeling pressured. I am a poor person, I live in Bath afterall haha. There is this attempt to turn this rural slums into a high scale area with pricing like here or Chat. I guess if they didn't having willing customers they'd be closed but it really appeals more to wealthier crowds but then has a beat up venue. Kind of odd. For just me and my child it is over $40 for lunch. That is a bit crazy to me. But I Am crazy and I have tried to come here several times now. First time food was okayish, 2nd time everything was overcooked or burned, 3rd time was again just okay. The fountain drink was the best part and for their price point, I just have to pass from now on. I wanted to love it so bad, I love a sloppy burger but it is always just slop and no melt in the mouth I gotta have more feeling. I can't even force myself to finish it. I've tried beef, tried chicken. Just meh. Also, like much of the area, their driveway/parking lot is crap. Traffic can be a pain and in the summer they had tall foliage and signs and I didn't feel safe trying to exit because I couldn't see and it's a 55mph road. Not all of us drive big trucks.

Get yourself an Aloha Hawaii Burger and go home stuffed!

Great little burger place. Median price range. Food is very good, also have good quality ice cream. Worth the trip, very good fish fry on Fridays

Awesome burgers. Highly recommend if you're in the area

staff was very friendly. they all seemed like locals. some of them when they weren't busy they'd sit down with you and have a conversation with you which was very nice

Great atmosphere and the burgers are really good. You definitely get your money’s worth. We’ll definitely be coming back

What a great little hidden gem.. Guy Fieri worthy!! Best biggest burgers I think we have ever had. Wasn't sure there was going to be enough napkins ... awsome messy. 50s atmosphere.. fun.

Probably one of the best hamburgers if not the best I've ever had. It was damn near perfect. The staff were very friendly and courteous. I'd definitely go back. I recommend stopping this restaurant to anyone.

Great food, great service. Highly recommend. The chicken sandwich was delicious. Hot and crispy. Absolutely delicious.

Delicious fresh homemade food in a cozy fifties environment! Everybody seems happy to work there and like their job and the entire place is very clean like they take a lot of pride in it. Definitely should try it if you're in the area! The owner is very nice and works hard. He swept and mopped and cleaned the grill when they closed and doesn't leave the all of the hard work to everybody else. I had one of the 12-inch Nathan's Hot Dogs and some ice cream after. Everything was delicious!

Food was soo good !! Definitely will be back

Usually good food, but expensive. The milkshakes are tasty and the French Fries are excellent. The sandwiches are okay. The ham & cheese is a bit salty for my taste. The Buffalo Bills Chicken Wrap was so-so. The Burgers have always been cooked just right. The Coney Island Chili Dog was not good. The Chili was overcooked - I took one bite and could not finish - it just did not taste right. The hours are a bit odd. Not opened Mondays (and Sunday) and close at 6:45 pm. (On Fridays they are open until 7:45.) My friend and I were there for dinner. We were chatting and realized that the gal behind the counter had ventured out to the restaurant side and started mopping the floor. You should not start mopping the floor with customers present - just take the time to ask if we were aware of the closing time. Most restaurants are open until 8, so we were completely surprised.

We stopped in on a whim on our way home from Watkins Glenn and are so glad we did! Service was friendly and fast, and the food was incredible - with generous portions. We had a fish fry and the Radioactive Chicken Sandwich. Unfortunately I don't know if we will be back due to distance - but you should definitely stop to have a bite if you're in the area!

I wasn't impressed with this place at all. You order, sit, then when food is ready you go pick up get your own sides and utensils and drinks. Then you clean up and leave. What's the point of going out of your doing most of the work . Just my opinion. Food was ok. I understand it's a small town but experience is all part of eating out.

Everything was outstanding. Food was perfect. Ice cream well worth it. Experiance overall was nostalgic. Decor really makes you feel like you step back in time.

great burgers with a generous amount of toppings

Wonderful atmosphere. Very clean inside. Food was fantastic. Love this place. We drive an hour to eat here.

Cute place with retro decor. Staff was friendly and service was quick. The price is high for burgers but you get your money's worth. The burgers are huge and juicy and the amount of fries/onion rings is generous. I have a big appetite but I couldn't even finish my burger and fries! I got the burger with mushrooms and they loaded it up with tons of shrooms. The sweet potato fries and onion rings were fried to perfection, so crispy and tasty! Definitly check this place out!

Everything was great.Excellent food. Blue cheese and bacon burger was amazing and the sweet potato fries were excellent. 50s atmosphere.

My hamburger was done the right way, just right like I like it!!! So good 👍

The staff was exceptionally nice. The burgers were so, so good!! The fries were scrumptious. All in all, it was well worth the money!!! When we were done, I think I waddled, I was certainly full, refused to leave any of it!!!

Friendly staff, the food was fresh. The portions were huge the price was fair. Loved the decor even buddy Holly Air guitar was hanging on the wall they promised it real. Everything was clean.

A huge menu with a lot to pick from and a great atmosphere only with there was a menu that you could look at before you get there or something to sit down with. So hard to decide😂 I will be back. Hope to see boneless wings on their menu soon.

Loved this place! Food was awesome and the 50's decor was perfect!

Really great fast casual spot for burgers, chicken sandwiches, and ice cream. We had a huge array and everyone loved it.

This place is a real "gem". The old fashioned diner interior is like going back in time-it's absolutely wonderful❤ My first time I tried the porky burger-WOW- sure glad I was hungary. I love my burgers but that burger had just as much sliced ham on it as it did burger-I'M IN LOVE😍😍😍 Looking forward to returni g-there's a few other food items calling my name as well-the chicken cord on blu is next. Great food,great service and DEFINITELY worth the value for your money.

Update MBB salad! Amber, server from nextdoor at Casa Mescal told me about Maybe salads. Tried the Cobb she told me about. WOW! Just WOW! It's Friday and here we are at MBB! We went on a tangent since Fish sold out early. Porky's Burger and The Family Trickster hotdog! OMG! You are just going to have to try these for yourself! Pics included... Wow! Just keeps on serving great food. My wife discovered the Maybe Baby fish fry and loves it. Huge! I like to sneak some of her sweet potatoes fries. Me, I'm a burger guy all the way. Nothing like a giant big juicy burger that tastes like I remember meat tasting from decades ago. Blue burger rocks! So does everyone I've tried. Bacon burger has huge thick slices of bacon. Makes a giant burger look small.

Absolutely outstanding as always. It's a great trip back in time.

Friendly staff, delicious burger cooked perfectly. We got there around 6pm and they closed at 6:45, no pressure or feeling rushed. Just a fun, relaxed atmosphere, great for families with children and a get together with adults. Well worth a try when you are in the mood for a great burger.

It was one of the best burgers I have ever had at a restaurant.

Everything was delicious and the portions were huge. Highly recommended!

The food is always great, your food is always cooked exactly the way you want it. I highly recommend this restaurant.

Really great patty melt burger, but I wished they offered a kids size. Way to big for my daughter. It's very pricey to feed kids. They'd get more traffic if they'd offered meals. It's like 10.99 for 1/4 lbs and fries. Only a suggestion.

Awesome burger joint! Not only is the place clean with good vibes, the food was amazing. Burgers were cooked as requested, and actually quite large! Service was quick and friendly.

Great burgers and nostalgia of the 1950's burger restaurants. We will be back!

This is our FAVORITE place to eat in the Bath area! There are a ton of burger options ranging from unique to classic choices. All are delicious. The portions are good for the price. The milkshakes, fries, and fried mushrooms are delicious! Our dogs love the dog burger. The restaurant is relatively small but always well-kept and clean. The food is consistently prepared hot and fresh in a timely fashion, which I appreciate. My family and I ate dinner here the night before my due date last fall, and I went into labor only a few hours later! We affectionately call it "Definitely Baby Burgers"! We always look forward to chatting with the staff. They treat us like family and are always friendly. I recommend this place to anyone and everyone!

Happened to be in the area and thought I'd take a look inside it was Very beautiful. Food came out fast, looked for a minute and food was ready, hot, and delicious. The staff was very friendly. Will come back just for it.

The burgers were huge and had great flavor.

Everything is fresh and hot! What we ordered today Chicken cordon blue ✔️ Crispy chicken wrap✔️ It exceeds our expectations! Chicken was nice and juicy! Fries were at perfect crisp Staff was super friendly and quick! 10/10 recommend even to go out of your way it’s so good here

I was in town visiting family but I live in a region the has a plethora of high end burger restaurants as well as run of the mill burger joints. We stopped on a whim as the pictures of the food and atmosphere both looked great. I am glad we did! It is clear that the menu is well thought out and detailed. The burger, onion rings, hot dog, and Cesar salad were all nicely seasoned and dressed. The ingredients were fresh and well prepared. The hamburger bun was lovely. In a post COVID world where help is hard to find, especially in smaller rural areas, Maybe Baby Burgers maximizes all available resources and does a good job turning tables. The owner is friendly and approachable. Thanks for a great experience!!

Got to try the chocolate, Carmel bacon shake