Molly’s Pizza - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

Great slice! Perfect seasoning loads of flavor

Great pizza, most toppings, The cheese is not greasy, the flavor is amazing. When we get pizza in Oneonta we go here most of the time.

Continually do not keep thier hours and have trued to visit 3 times. Each time we'll within thier posted hours and still closed.

Omg the pizza is so consistent and absolutely amazing here! Never ever had a bad experience! Love the Sicilian and any white pizza from here, also the ranch is soo amazing!

I place a large order of pizzas once a year for an event at NYST and this pizza place knocks it out of the park everytime. I give him 24 hours notice and the 15 plus pizzas are hot and ready right during lunch time. Every special pizza is awesome (Meat lovers is easily a days worth of protein in one slice). Everyone loves the pizza and looks forward to it. Please give this place a try and order an entire specialty pizza and have 4 friends help you eat it! 🫡

The level of customer service is above and beyond! I was picking up a large order for a work lunch and he actually carried all of the 5 boxes out for me and he was the only one there! The pizza was AMAZING!!! LOVE THE CRUST! Thanks for the great service 😁

Absolutely love the pizza! Best crust ever!

So glad we found Molly’s! We tried 4 different slices and each was better than the last! Will definitely be returning!

Stumbled upon Molly's while working in the area. I was a little hesitant at first but once I tried the pizza I knew it wouldn't be my last time. The sauce is homemade and there is no shortage of toppings on the slices. I have had the mushroom, pepperoni mushroom, pepperoni, cheese, and chicken bacon ranch and each of those were amazing. 100% would recommend.

Every single time I go to this place it's closed. Update your hours so people don't waste time.

Food is bad. Cheese slice sauce taste like spaghetti-os and one slice is $3. The owner is rude and doesn't even acknowledge you exist. Sicilian is so watery it might as well float down the river. Atmosphere is whatever, in a mall and former subway but sheesh. Haven't had pizza this bad in a long time. Like how do you mess up a cheese slice?

The fat guy behind the counter tells us they are either closed or out of pizza. We have been there 3 times trying to get pizza. Will never go there again.

When if comes to Pizza in Oneonta, you better bring your A-Game, and as I can tell you, after trying Molly's for the first time this past week, they certainly have! When we picked up the pizzas, the owner smiled at the boxes and said "Hope you guys are hungry, there is a lot of food here." and boy, he wasn't kidding. Lifting the boxes I felt them strain; these pies were LOADED. Spotlight on the Meat Lovers Pizza, which was HEAPED with meat. Bacon, rolled ham, I'm pretty sure there were clusters of ground sausage... I do not exaggerate when I say a single slice weighed in at close to 2 lbs! It was like eating an entire calzone on one slice. I tried to put it on a couple paper plates and they would not hold it! The next day I had a veggis slice which was piled high with broccoli, onions, whole cheery tomatoes, peppers and a killer sauce! It had nearly as much heft as the meat lovers! I have had every pizza in Oneonta and None have come close to the amount of topping we received on all the pizzas we ordered! This pizza hasn't come to play, it came to win, and after my first helping I can say that when it comes to product value for your buck, when if comes to specialty pizzas, this may have just stepped into the top spot. Note: Owner has taken a stance; no pineapple on the menu.

I love this place. My favorite pizza place between schoharie, Delaware and Otsego county. Idk what this guy does but the pizza is so consistently delicious and the cheese is so cheesy and everything is divine. Good job my friend 🧡

i don’t even like pizza and i keep coming back here so that says a lot. big fan

Some of the best pizza ive ever had. And i do alot of traveling! Only downside is size of restaurant,but it is in a mall so i understand having a smaller location.

The pizza is the best! We showed up at 11 like the ad says and he very rudely slam the door and locked it! This is the second time so we won't 't be back.

Best pizza anywhere! My husband and I won’t go anywhere else!

The garlic knots are to die for. The pizza is amazing. I'm not in oneonta that often but when I am this is the first place I go.

The pizza here is terrific! Talk about not skimping on toppings - these pies are heavily laden with toppings. The sauce is good and so is the crust. Excellent! We think it's the best pizza in the area and we tell everyone we know that it is!

Molly's pizza has to be the best pizza in the area. This is the best pizza I've had since Renna's in the Olean NY mall. Renna's pizza has been a legend in Olean NY for 40+ years. I've never had pizza even remotely as good over the past 40 years until today. Molly's is just as incredible. I can't believe I ever found another pizza shop as good.

Only bad thing I can say about this place is that it’s not bigger for more ppl to sit & enjoy the ONLY GOOD (GREAT PIZZA!!) in the area!!! This is a hidden gold mine!!!! Been around here for years visiting and this is the ONLY PLACE THAT KNOWS HOW TO MAKE A GREAT TASTING PIZZA!! All the places that have popped up or been around for a while either can’t get the ingredients right or the way they cook it but this guy is on point! Finally a spot worth having a pizza coming from the city (Downstate). My family has lived up here since the 80’s and not one pizza place hit it out of the park except this one…. Would definitely eat here again. Fresh pie out of the oven, whew!! Again, can’t go wrong here. Hope this guy realizes what he has here!!

Been there a few times but it's good

Omg!!!!!! Some of the BEST pizza I've ever had. 10 out of 10 Will go back.

I love going there food is great owner is always nice if I can give more than five stars I would.

I'm from LI. Best Pizza by far. Everything is fresh. Owner is a really nice and great guy. Give him your support..

Had this pizza delivered and what a treat. I travel the whole country and will say this is in my top ten places I have ever had pizza at. Thank you for the experience, quantity and quality of an amazing pizza.

There is a very good chance that this is the best pizza in Oneonta UPDATE: This is the best pizza in Oneonta

Best pizza in Oneonta! Reasonable prices excellent food

We stopped in this shopping area on our way through town and needed a quick dinner. I'm so glad we chose Molly's Pizza! The owner was kind and helpful. The pizza was divine. Service was quick, the food was a great price, and I would absolutely eat here again.

The pizza here is fantastic. Can't get enough of that crust which is reminiscent of Brooklyn style pizza from NYC. We had their large mushroom pie with fresh mushrooms and a Schweppes and Canada Dry soda flavors we haven't had before. The owner was friendly and it wasn't very busy until after we left. Had the rest of the pie to go.

I am a random road trip customer who saw this on google maps. I stopped for gas and and had the good fortune to find this place at the nearby mall for a quick & tasty slice of pepperoni pizza. Enjoyed it so much I went back after using the mall restroom to buy a slice to snack on later. Thanks, Molly’s!

He put tons of sausage on our sausage pizza. Margherita pizza was Amazing!! The house salad was the topper!! Thanks for a great dinner!!

Excellent pizza! Delicious crust, amazing sauce and wonderful toppings. Definitely one of the best pizzas I've had.

I always get take out. So very good!

Amazing pizza all the way around!!! Great salads too...

Great pizza! Wish they had beer.

There were only 2 good pizza shops in Oneonta, now there are 3. Excellent, pizza, great crust, heavy on the toppings. I got it delivered and the crust was still crisp. Best prices it town too. I'll be back for more.

Really loved the pizza 🍕! I had white sauce pizza with broccoli and chicken. I also had a slice of pepperoni 🍕. Both were cooked perfectly. The down side the soda machine was down,but they had canned soda so, I gave them a solid 4 stars ⭐️.

Great pizza..Gets it right everytime..pizza sauce amazing

Was not acknowledged while server was making pizza. Should've atleast said I'll be right with you instead of ignoring us.

Great service, amazing pizza. Probably my favorite crust.

We heard about this pizza place recently and decided we had to try it (our granddaughter's name is Molly). It was excellent, had plenty of pepperoni, and the crust was flavorful and had that slight chewiness we love. Excellent price! I did ask if they had gluten free crust, but they do not. Please like this review if you found it helpful.

Was there for a good while. Sandwich was delicious.

We are from out of town, ordered 4 pies to share with family. Absolutely the best pizza I have ever had! The meat lovers is loaded with toppings. The price is more than fair. We will order again when we are back in the area!

We wanted NY style pizza in Oneonta and I was surprised how close this comes. Toppings were fresh, and the crust was thin and crispy. I definitely recommend Molly’s.

My favorite pizza place close to home! Owner is kind and friendly, price is right, and the food is top knotch! Highly recommend trying this place if you havent!

Best pizza by far in oney!! And best priced!!

Very good, crispy crust, flavorful sauce. Will be back.

Excellent pizza. Best crust in the tri-county area-by far.

Great pizza! Thin, crispy crust, no chewy! So good!

Some of the best pizza in Oneonta!!

Delicious pizza, see and taste the fresh basil!

Stopped here with my family while we were at the mall…the pizza is BUSSIN. I didn’t expect it to be so good.