Over Easy in Tavernier - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

Great find on our way home from Key Colony Bay. Food, fresh squeezed OJ and coffee were great! Service was amazing! Ladies who helped us were attentive, attended to several tasks while not losing sight of their customers' needs including ours. It was a team effort to see how they managed the many responsibilities to incude cleaning up and setting tables. Impressive! Will definitely be back and refer friends!

My dining table was unsteady. They do not have cappuccino. My friend had two hairs on his plate. He loved his omelette until I pointed the hairs out. He pointed out that the cooks were not wearing hair nets. I don’t have any solid proof, but I think I got salmonella here from the eggs Benedict and I have now been sick for eight miserable days as is my whole family. I will now think twice about eating eggs Benedict anywhere else which is very sad because it’s my favorite. I did not finish my plate and I wish I hadn’t ordered anything raw, the egg yolk was the only raw item I had during my vacation. And Yes I’m aware that it could’ve been from other things, I took Infection Control in college.

Good food. A little overpriced. $6.50 for a fruit cup that consisted of half a banana and 2 strawberries is a bit much

First time today, and it was great. My pops had an omelet, I had the Carlos special and my daughter the yogurt bowl. Everything was absolutely delicious. I'm sure they are absorbing all of the buisness from made to order since it closed.

Highly expensive and did 20% gratuity with telling us

Amazing service, great atmosphere, fun staff! I really like food and people!

Absolutely adorable atmosphere & the most amazing food! Fantastic service! Not to be missed.

Super bright, simple and classic decor. The yellow chairs were so fun and cheerful. Our food was delicious and they had REAL maple syrup. Hash browns were amazing and my brioche French toast was done perfectly. My husband got the egg sandwich which was done exactly as he wanted. Juri was our server and was quick to take care of us and meals came out super quickly. A+++++ highly recommend.

Best food we have had down here! Juri was our server and she was awesome. Breakfast sandwich and hashbrowns with some sausage links and the homemade strawberry jelly was fantastic.

The food was amazing. Very healthy options. Quantity and Quality is definitely there. Great service as well.

Great diner for breakfast. Portions are HUGE! I was only able to eat half of the Country Steak. But it was delicious. We also had French toast and pancakes. Beware of the kids ones... they are the size of a dinner plate! 😆 Judy was great as our server and Tony was rocking it in the kitchen. Thanks for a great meal.

The food is spectacular and the service is amazing 100 pts

Food was pretty good but I waited foreverrrrr for my take out order. I had called them when online ordering wasn't working well. Got charged more than if I had done it online...weird. But people were nice inside. I just had to stand there forever like a weirdo waiting for my food. And they are not locals they come from homestead

The food is great, the girls are very friendly. The place is a little small and there are a lot of people, but the service is fast.

Amazing restaurant, very good food service. The food is deli.

I went to eat at over easy today and it was espectacular!!!!! And very delicious 👍🏼 the atmosphere was amazing as well awe the service! I would recommend this place! I am for sure coming to eat here again!

I have never left a review for anywhere but this was terrible. The food looked good online but the service was AWFUL which ruined the whole experience. Tried to cut the waitress some slack since it was a little busy but it took 15 mins for us to get our drinks. We ordered our drinks and food all together and that was the last time we saw our waitress. After that, two other staff members waited on us while our waitress disappeared. Food came out cold, didn’t even get napkins or silverware, never got refills, people who came in after us got everything before we did (only 2 of us) and it was WAY overpriced. We spent $11 on one cranberry juice and one orange juice. Never again.

Service was lacking a lot only time we saw waitress was when we ordered after that she disappeared behind bar for most of the time ended up getting our check from another waitress food is sub par would not recommend idk when tripple D was here but it def isn’t worthy of it, it was also very overpriced

The food is delicious. Would absolutely go back.

I want to say it’s worth it.. but it’s not. The food was great, however the whole experience was awful. We had to wait; which is not uncommon for a Sunday morning. To check in to put your name down was not the norm nor coordinated right. You had to walk in and find the notebook by the bar to put your name down & your party size. No body even greeted us or told us to do so. Another guest told me to write our name down on the paper. The waitress who was also acting as the hostess came out a few times to call parties in. She skipped us not once but twice to seat people that arrived after us. One of the parties were bigger than us, a party of 4 and we were only a party of 2.. their time management is not executed properly. It’s a shame because the food is actually good, but they seem to be understaffed and don’t know how to manage their tables. We ordered our drinks & food together, and that was the last we saw our waitress. It took over 40 minutes to get our food, which she brought out the wrong thing at first. No body checked on us after they brought us our food and our check was placed on our table 10 minutes later - as if we were now being rushed out.

Came in for Mother’s Day. Server looked upset about us not ordering enough food, then continued to forget to bring half of what we ordered . When the food came up, it did sit in the window while she sat on her phone for a few minutes. (In front of us) then server scratched her head in a manor which should have been done In private , wiped her hand on her shirt , whatever bodily substance was on it . Then touched the top of the place that my food had been sitting on . Do better. Orange juice was 10/10

Best breakfast I’ve ever had. The hatch 505 with smothered hash is the way to here!

Over Easy is the epitome of breakfast perfection! The ambiance is cozy and welcoming, and the service is top-notch. Whether you're craving classic eggs benedict or something more adventurous like the OG Wolf, Over Easy delivers excellence with every dish. A must-visit for breakfast lovers!

This was a perfect little breakfast spot! The food was delicious, and came quickly. The staff was kind and professional. We definitely recommend it!

Delicious food, large portions. Friendly service. Be prepared to wait a little bit for your food, but that's okay because you know it's made fresh and executed well. Perfect eggs cooked 3 different ways. Their biscuit is not to be missed.

This place is over rated and over priced just because Guy Fieri visited it. Only 2 other people in there when we were, and the cooks were just talking up a storm. You had to keep asking for coffee or water because the person didn't seem to want to go around and ask if you'd like more. My suggestion is go to Harriet's restaurant or Made to order restaurant. They both had great food and service. Lots of people too because it's good!

This is one of those never again places.

Excellent breakfast food. Florintine eggs Benedict outstanding

I love eating outside and have been back a second time. Go hungry. They have ample portions. My favorite so far is the Florentine Omelet. They have crab cake benedict, which was pretty good too. Caution, birds may drop on you while you wait for your table at the benches. They are attracted to the bus bins for the tables, though they empty them often.

The breakfast was normal, nothing extraordinary, however the service stood out for being very poor and in very bad taste, all the waitresses were very apathetic and had a negative attitude towards the customer.

Cute “diner vibe” with great food. Eggs were cooked perfectly. Delicious iced coffee.

Country fried steak was WAY, overdone, and not edible. The server was missing for most of the meal. We had heard great reviews. Maybe they were just having a bad day...

Good selection, but very pricey for a strip mall diner (over $60 for two people for breakfast!!!). Plus, order was wrong and all our food came out cold. Super disappointing

Excelente desayuno, excelente atenciones y precios razonable. Me encantó el ambiente, la higiene, las atenciones, los precios, la ubicación. Amplio parqueo.

Food was fine. Service was good.

I only took a star off for pricing. The food was great! It’s a tad expensive for breakfast food. Especially when I can get chilaquiles for half the price at any taqueria in Maryland.

The breakfast is the best in town.

We went in with 5 adults and a baby, the server was very accommodating, EXTREMELY nice, and helpful when ordering. The restaurant is spotless and has a very refreshing atmosphere. The menu has just the right amount of options for all diets. Our order was made PERFECTLY and everything came out at the same time. We were able to tell the oil they use to fry the food is also very clean. Our server checked in on us multiple times but wasn’t overly attentive. Thank you we will be back and recommend to anyone looking for a great place to eat.

Excelente atención y servicio, la comida deliciosa. Gracias a Jurenny por su excelente atención y a todo el personal. Nos vemos pronto.

Great food. Yum, stop in here and feast.

You can skip this place. I would give this place a rating of “Meh” for the food. The food didn’t have much flavor, the hash browns were totally flavorless, the pepper grits were just so so, the ham steak and avocado with poached eggs were mediocre. So overall, everything was just so so other than the service which was fantastic. The staff was amazing, the food was not.

Wonderful spot to grab breakfast/brunch.

Beautiful restaurant good food.

Overall, the place was good. The food was pretty bland, but the service was good.

Nice diner with huge pancakes and good coffee 👍🏼

Amazing food and positive vibes! The Avocado Eggs Benedict is ABSOLUTELY THE BEST breakfast I have ever eaten! Perfectly poached eggs, sliced avocado, diced tomatoes and onions, and homemade Hollindase! FRESH SQUEEZED OJ is awesome, too!

Saw that Guy Fierri liked the place so we went for breakfast. I had the two egg breakfast. My wife ordered chicken fried steak. My eggs were overcooked and my wife’s steak was tough as shoe leather. We would have complained, but the waitress never came to check on us.

Food was pricey, but fresh and good. Service was subpar and basic. They just took our order and brought food, didnt ask for refills, if we needed anything else for the food like jelly/condiments, didnt make sure we all had utensils and napkins. Had to call the servers multiple times as they kept talking among themselves.

Visiting from out of town. I heard they had great breakfast, especially since it was on DDD. I got the chicken fried steak, with hashbrowns and toast. The steak was terrible!! It was dry, overcooked and the gravy had no seasoning. 🤢 The hashbrowns had no season either. Waffle house tastes better. My husband had the platter with eggs, hashbrowns, sausage, bacon, and a waffle. He said everything was fine. The sausage being the highlight. I had a piece and by far this was the best thing about the meals. If we visit again, we may come back since my husband's favorite meal is breakfast but I would stick to just eating the sausage and maybe a pancake. I don't trust anything here that has to be seasoned. For the money we spent everything have been excellent!

Grits were delicious, but the pulled pork and chili sauce on top was extremely spicy. Could have used less sauce to help with the spiciness.

Awesome spot for breakfast. Great good and great vibes. Also, they have some signature dishes you can't find anywhere else.

Awesome place! Great food. Outstanding service. I had the Chicken Fried Steak. It was home made and a real steak, the english muffins that came with it were homemade and the best I ever had. My wife got the Chilaquiles. She thought they were really good too. Could do without sour cream on them though. All in all, highly recommended and I will be back.

Healthy foods and excellent ingredients

I love Vanessa And Jure, my two servers! The food is amazing, tasty and all clean!

Four of us went after a couple of dives around 12p amd the wait was about 20min amd place is super small-but clean. Just a few ladies running the front so service is slow bit they are very friendly. We ordered Breakfast burrito-it was massive and sharable. Banana Nut French toast was really good. On the chalkboard menu I ordered Vanessa's Benedict with Grits and the Benedict was good but the girls we not your usual southern Grits, these were made with cream or something 🤷🏼‍♀️ Noone at the table cared for them. Biscuits and gravy were ok and Cornbeef hash with over medium eggs were both oer cooked. Husband likes cripsy Cornbeef but these seemed to taste scorched and carried that flavor over to the well done eggs. Would the 4 of us eat here again, yes. Because there are other things on the menu that sound very promising 😁

Food was pretty great not a fan of the way they make grits with cream. Staff was fabulous.

TV-famous breakfast diner with very good brunch offerings. A little off the beaten path but well worth a try. The protein bowl and the pancakes were delicious.

Great breakfast food and atmosphere

Very chill and I loved the eggs benedict. 🥚 everything was fresh and the service is nice.

Over Easy is a great choice for breakfast. Having been here several times, service is always good, coffee is great, food is phenomenal. Biscuits are unique with jalapeño in them. Gravy is definitely one of the better ones I’ve had. Not pictured is the Breakfast Burrito, it is so tasty and filling. The Ham Steak (also not pictured) is incredibly good with the red eye gravy! If you’re in the Tavernier, FL area or upper keys, make sure you get to try their fabulous breakfast… Lunch… I still haven’t tried! But there’s always tomorrow! 😉 It is also Bright and well lit space, that is always clean! Give them a try!

A little on the pricer side but truly delicious, not packed, and quite quick!

Great selection, good quality, friendly staff. Good little spot for breakfast, large menu that spanned across breakfast, brunch and lunch. Slightly expensive, the food was good but not great, probably down to the restaurant being quite busy. It quietened down a bit from 10:30am so aim to avoid the rush. Not a bad stop off if looking for a more luxurious breakfast in the keys!

Food is always good and service is friendly. Usually we like breakfast if out shopping in the area . Loaded pancakes are great. Good selection of dishes .

I love the retro diner chairs and tables! This is what brought me in!

We had the best breakfast here! I wish we had one back home. Wverything was delicious! The omelets were massive! The handmade jelly should be sold! It's yummy! We had so much food left over we were able to eat it again the next morning. I highly recommend them! It has made our 'return' list!

Food had incredible taste and the portions are huge. This will be a must on our annual trip from now on!

Great breakfast food, food is tasty, presentation is good. The atmosphere is not fancy but just right and local.