Peppi's Pizzeria in Naples - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

Good pizza, even measured by German standards. For it to be very good, the dough would have to have risen better at the edges and be crispier overall... just a matter of taste. We can certainly recommend the white pizza, with garlic better than the one with sausage (“Cadillac”). Inside, lovingly trimmed in Italian style, original Italian hits are humming and Rai UNO is playing in the flicker box. Lots of regulars, you can also get pizza by the slice for lunch. Price: Well, $25 for a medium is proud for European wallets, but probably normal in Naples. Toilets: tip top, service very nice and quick.

The pizza has little to do with (good) Italian pizza. At least the dough should be local and freshly made. That is not the case. The dough is not freshly made on site. This has nothing to do with good pizza.

This is a late post. My family and I can’t wait to come back as soon as they re-open from a well deserved vacation! The White pizza was amazing! We think is probably the best in town! The lady who serve all tables in the restaurant was super energetic, friendly, and kind! She is a super woman! And the atmosphere makes you feel you are in a small place of Italy! Pizza is my love language! 🍕🫶🏻😁

Love the pizza. Drive 30 minutes for it. Get the white slice and a sausage slice! Delish

Peppi’s is great! As far as New York style pizza goes, this is the closest I’ve had outside of NY and CT. Really great. It has a cozy interior, usually busy with dine in and a robust take out business. I usually dine in and the food comes out fast enough despite their busyness. Photo added - large sausage with extra pepperoni. Delicious! If you’re looking for a new pizza place and like NY Style, this is the place.

Great atmosphere, great tasting pizza. The gluten free crust was great and the guy in our party (a notable Columbian pizza connoisseur) said he will come back next time he's in Naples. If it's busy, stick around and you'll understand why - it's worth the wait.

Service and food was excellent. I ordered a gluten free pizza and it did not disappoint. As a Colombian connoisseur of pizza I approve of this establishment.

Absolutely excellent. Coming from an Italian-Brazilian family, we can confidently say this is one of the closest Italian food in Naples, FL.

Always excellent pizza and make sure to visit when I'm in Naples

I heard that Peppi’s sold pizza by the slice at lunchtime and thought I would try it. There were a few selections available and once I chose what I wanted, the slices were put in the pizza oven for a short time. When heated, the two pizza slices were put on two paper plates and placed in a bag. Once I got home I had to reheat the slices. The pizza had a thin crust. There was ample pepperoni and sausage on one slice and ricotta and spinach on the other slice. Both slices are just ok.

This is a true gem in the corner of a strip mall that serves good quality authentic Italian cuisine, it's not fancy bit the food is of a high standard.

Best pizza and best wait staff ever.

Ordered a double cheese double pepperoni pizza. Was cooked almost to perfection. Will go back

We tried a half pepperio and mushrooms pizza. It was a good pizza had lots of flavor and tasted great

I Moved from N.Y 2 years ago and luckily enough just discovered what is most similar to having Pizza in at a top place in New York. Impossible to duplicate the artisan Pizza and the quality of the Sauce and fresh ingredients they use. I understand that it's season now and all restaurants have a long wait especially due to the holidays but now that's over and this is simply the best real Italian Food in Naples, for the money! Enjoy delicious food at a very fair price and I hope you agree with this review once experiencing a meal there. Amazing Pizza 🍕 thin crispy crust perfect sauce and yummy Homemade Sausage and Meatballs. Excellent Salads and Hot Food specialties. Simple but excellent Menu!! 😋

I have been to this place before and I remember I enjoyed food and pretty fast service. Today I took my friend for dinner to the restaurant. My friend is Italian so I was promising her delicious food and excellent pizza. We got table and ordered one salad and pizza. The waitress served us drinks and salad pretty fast. Well that’s where magic was over. We were waiting for pizza around one hour. At some point the restaurant was almost empty while I and my friend were still patiently waiting for our pizza 😆 We were watching people getting take out one by one but not us unfortunately sitting right at the restaurant and waiting. Finally the pizza has arrived to our table, it was pretty good. Unfortunately our experience will not make us to come back. I loved the place before. It is obvious that restaurant prioritize take out service over customers eating at the restaurant.

I can only share our experience regarding the PIZZA. It was excellent all around, can’t believe this place doesn’t have a higher star rating. We choose to drive here and it is our go-to pizzeria in Naples. Top notch!!

The pepperoni and mushroom pizza was good

Take out order. I have been going here a long time. The 🍕 pizza and everything is outstanding. So glad you are in the neighborhood.

Excellent thin crust pizza. Great service, we go back again and again!

Pizza made quickly & served hot Lots of toppings requested.

I have eaten here 3 times in 3 weeks. Excellent food and service. Pizza by the slice for lunch. The meatball sub was amazing, too. I want to try their pasta dishes next. I would say this: the pizza is best in-store, fresh from the oven. It did not reheat well for me.

Great pizza and a friendly service.

This is based on the calzone, which should have been hot inside

One of the best pizza In town, Delicius sandwiches are great I dis the chicken parmigiana and is great service is pretty fast place is immaculate clean

Best pizza you can get down here. It's the closest thing you can get to real New York pizza. My father was the first ever customer there when they had opened and I've been going there with him for the past 13 years

My husband and I were visiting Naples and we had Peppi’s 2X. The pizza was amazing. Must try

We went to Peppi's Pizza for the first time and had their pizza. We have finally found a good pizza near us! We loved the food and service so much we went back the next night and ordered dinner entrees. Everything was delicious.

Awful pizza They don’t listed to your order.

Ok Pizza place. Thin crust with little flavor. Cheese and pepperoni could be upgraded. Service was great. Our server worked very efficiently. Music was loud.

I have to be fair,2 of their ovens broke down when there. It was slow at a busy time,but overall,you will like the food . They could have put a little more sauce at the time,but it was fresh and good.

Our carry out pizza was not what it was stated to be. Not enough cheese or toppings. Disappointed!

Excellent pizza! I put it on par with pizza I've had in Italy.

Don’t let the strip mall location fool you. This place is a great restaurant. The bruschetta and pizza were excellent and prices were very reasonable by Naples standards. Service was very good.

Among the worst margarita pizzas I ever ordered. I recommended staying away from that pizza and try something else.

Way overpriced for what you get. $28 for a large (16") pizza - crust was chewy, very little sauce and toppings. Literally counted 8 pieces of pepperoni on a large pizza. In addition I think the mushrooms were canned. I like to support local shops but I think this one lost my business.

Great place to eat, friendly environment, and inexpensive. Definitely recommend. I’ve had pizza in Rome, and their Margherita Pizza tasted very similar. Only downside is the wait time is a bit longer than most places, so I’d recommend getting takeout if you don’t want to wait.

Sat outside, quick friendly service. Food was good. Will go back to try something different.

Peppi's Pizza is one of my favorite pizza places ever! They make amazing pizza and their sauce is to die for. I will always recommend this place for pizza.

I live in NE FL but am originally from Brooklyn and I wish this pizzeria was by me! On par with Brooklyn pizza and the best I’ve ever had in FL!

If I could give this Pizzeria 1000 stars I would!! EXCELLENT pizza!! SUPERB service!! GREAT music!! DELICIOUS cannoli!! The fresh, hot bread was FABULOUS with the TASTY salad...soooo happy to discover the BEST PIZZA IN NAPLES!! Will definitely return to eat as much of this menu as possible! Thank you Peppi's Pizzeria for a FIRST CLASS experience!!

The most authentic Italian pizza. Absolutely amazing!

Delicious, fresh pizza. Salad had fantastic blue cheese dressing. Highly recommend. Very clean place.

Great Calzone, very good service!

I love Peppi's Pizza and would eat it every single day, it's that good. The first bite is too much and if you're standing you will drop to your knees, so I strongly recommend sitting down before you take a bite. The sauce is so good you'll want to drink it. From the beginning to the end, Peppi's has perfected the pizza pie. The sauce seems to infuse with the cheese and crust sending your taste buds to the moon. I believe they just have all the right conditions, the quality ingredients, the build quality, and the cooking time and temp somehow are al dialed in to perfection. There is no denying this is a special place. It's either Peppi's Pizza or forget about it!

Quick summary: very good pizza in a variety of styles. Also has an assortment of mains in the traditional Italian style. Reasonable prices for the area. We were tired and jut wanted a take-out pizza to have at home. We were pleased that they had a variety of sizes (medium and large) and crust types (thin and thick.) We ordered one medium-size pizza as vegetarian - green peppers, onions, and mushrooms - and one large of our usual combo of mushroom and pepperoni. The ingredients and quality were very good. We took our pizza home, but it looks like a number of diners in the restaurant were pleased with their food. The room is casual but nice. Outside tables line the parking lot, as with many places located in strip malls in Naples. So why not 5 dots? The pizza is very good in general, but a wood-fired pizza oven would make it perfect. There are a lot of good pizza places, but our favorites are in other parts of the country, not Naples. IMHO, many pizzas in Naples rank only 3-4 dots, so put my rating in that context.

It was Great 10+ years ago & it still Stands as one of Neapolitan Favorites. It was a Pleasure to step back into this Great Family Owned Business that takes Great Joy with Smiles Welcoming Every Customer. Love the Cadillac Pizza & Best Canolis by far!

I had left a 1 star about a year ago. At that time, I had called to place an order and was greeted by someone who should not be allowed to take orders from a customer. The owner/manager did reach out to me, but the damage was done. Anyways, I had never eaten there and intentionally avoided this place until last night. Ordered a medium pizza. Person on the phone was fine. And you know what, it was the best pizza in Naples. In fact, it could compete with any pizza, anywhere! Felt it was my duty as a pizza lover to inform the public and change my review.

We went here for dinner as a family of 6. The food was incredible. My husband’s family is from Puglia and the food is like home cooked in Italy. We enjoyed everything we ordered. Calamari, bruschetta, Lasagna, Margherita Pizza , Beef Ravioli, Linguine with Clams, Braciole, and Meatballs they were all delicious. I would definitely go back here. Tastes just like home!

Went tonight for dinner service was terrible but in defense of the waitress she was the only one handling all the tables. The pizza we didn't eat so bad my husband told the owner when he went to pay the bill and they charged us in full we will never go back

Delicious meatball sandwiches except the meatballs were a little salty. The chicken parm sandwich tasted OK, but had much more bread than chicken.

White pizza dry no flavor overcooked, so busy no help long waits, , I guess you can't handle criticism check all your reviews they complain about the white pizza, fake mushrooms and canned spinach, and your responses back to people are rude, food not tasty is not good face facts

We did takeout and found the pizza to be mediocre at best. The pepperoni was okay but the white pizza was horrid. They use CANED MUSHROOMS which just shows the quality, or lack of quality of ingredients they use. Also, the girl who answers the phone was arrogant on the phone and in person. I expect she is an owner given no owner would ever hire someone like her.

Amazing crust, amazing sauce, amazing pizza

Looks like a small pizza joint. However we've been there three times already because they have a wide range of Italian food great choices in pizzas and a wonderful family atmosphere.

Visited Pepsi’s Pizzeria the first time tonight (1-28-21), excellent service and delicious pizza and salad! Priced very reasonably for the amount of food served. Family owned, mother and daughter, the daughter was our waitress and extremely pleasant and very prompt with our order. Will definitely be on our return trip list!

Its fair in a pinch, but honestly canned spinach on a PIZZA?? like just ewwww... really?

The best pizzeria in the area. The pizza is like getting one in Italy. The spaghetti and meatballs are also very good.

Pizza is absolutely delicious. As an Italian born in Rome, I can say is one of the best in Naples !! Good job guys !!!

I've b been going here since 2012 - best pizza in town. I also love their lasagna, but order it when u have time to eat in - better that way. The family that owns it is super nice (especially the Mom). I do wish they would bring back their old Italian vinaigrette dressing - I loved it. Simple and delicious. I don't get salad with my pizza now b/c of the change.

Horrible pizza and pricy we threw out the majority of it. Strange hours too. Very little cheese/ Burnt / had an after taste.

Best pizza ive ever ate in my life!

Great food, especially the pizza. This is a locals favorite. Nice service. Great prices for the quality of food.

You annot go wrong with any choice from the menu Bread makes the sandwiches this is my to go place when i want cheesteak I order cheese steak With lettuce tomato onions And jalapeno It's amazing

The BEST! You cannot go wrong with any choice from their menu. Their bread makes the sandwiches. This is my go to place when I want a Cheesesteak from like back home in Philly. I order a Cheesesteak with lettuce, tomato, raw onion & jalapeño! It’s cooked to perfection every time. Their pizza is AMAZING-nice thin crust, always fresh. White pizza is to die for. Their platters are just as good too. I cannot say enough about the waitresses that work extremely hard. They go above & beyond to make sure you are satisfied with everything. They always come & greet you with a smile, a pleasant conversation. I have enjoyed getting to know the girls and Mamma behind the register since coming to Naples a few years ago. I won’t go anywhere else for my cheesesteak or pizza. We have enjoyed plenty of family dinners in here as well. If you have never been here, do yourself a favor & put it on your MUST STOP list of places to go while you are in Naples. It’s a hidden gem, one I’m lucky to have discovered.

It’s old type pizzeria style pizza parlor. Nothing fancy southern Italian all way. Been big fan of Peppi’s for years can’t beat the food especially the pizza. Only few pizza selection types can get toppings but pizza was meant to be margarita or just red sauce cheese cooked well on bottom not loaded with everything you could thing of. Both lunch and dinner menus are not bank breaking in fact lunch specials you can’t beat them from pasta dishes hero’s pizza slices. Who do you know still serves slices of pizza most pizzerias only small or large pie sizes to stay or go. Thursday to Saturday nights lucky get in takeout has always been part of Peppi’s business nothing new. Friday Saturday nights door never stops opening pizza other foods to go. At present time, Peppi’s owner has closed for month of July not reopening till sometime in august in Pulgia, italy on holiday. Ciao ciao

Other pizza places makes my stomach upset, but I’ve never had that reaction with Pepis.

Best pizza in naples. Very authentic and great crust.

Really like their pizza, pasta good, but not homemade. Wish they were closer to North Naples.

Exceptional people, service and food, just wonderful.

Wife said to find her a good pizza for dinner. This place was perfect. Family operation. Made us feel welcomed. Immediate table service. Pizza was hot and jus what my wife wanted. We wold return.

They make the best cappuccino ever

The best pizza in Naples hands down.

Great small family business, definitely recommend them !!

Excellent pizza. Friendly staff will come back.

Great thin crust. We will be back to try the lunch specials.

1st time order. Ordered large Margherita pizza and Pepsi’s special. Both were excellent and nicely sized. Antipasto salad was great too. Been trying a bunch of pizza joints in Naples. I will order from here again!!

You can't get more Italian than Andrea Borceli and Italian tv. The pizza was good too.

Among the best pizza in NAPLES. Chicago people will really like it. NY folks will love it. Great people too.

Great food but staff don’t listen to your order. They have messed up the same exact meal every time and we have been going here for a very long time

Every time I am in Naples, I make sure to frequent Peppi's. It is a cozy, family business. The pizza is fantastic with a thin crust . There was ample space between tables, so I felt safe during Covid. You can also do take out for their menu.

Beautifully cooked from dough to sauce.excellent service. .recently went for dinner..wonderful food .

We had this pizza our last night in Naples, it’s New York style and was great the next day also!! Good options, a little more money than I would prefer but delicious.

We were happy to be able to dine in and were able to seat ourselves at a table. The waitress came quickly and service was good. My friend and I were splitting a pizza and the waitress was helpful in suggesting topping that would go together well. (Green AND black olives! Who knew?!) We were able to have 5 toppings on one half of the pizza and 5 different toppings on the other half. Both friends were happy with their half of the pizza. The crust is thin but you can order thick crust if you’d like. We had the cannolis and were very good too. It was my friends first time to try a cannoli and she really liked it. This was about a 10-15 minute drive from our accommodations on naples Bay but we would drive there again.

Love the pizza.Slice for is great and makes an affordable lunch! Definitely going back to try the dinner..soon!

One of the best pizzas in Naples!

Family owned. Great salad and spaghetti

Our first pizza at Peppi's and it was absolutely delicious. First the crust was perfect, baked evenly a nice flavor. The amount of sauce and cheese was just right and very fresh topping at that. I especially enjoyed the sausage and spicy cherry peppers. We ordered around 6:30 pm and was ready when we drove up for pickup at 7, just as they promised. Again we highly recommend Peppi's for a 👌 pizza. It's definitely been added to our "go to" for Naples pizza.

I went there once in 2011 and it was so good that me and the family came back to Naples in 2017 and went right back, staff super friendly and pizza is the best I’ve had, better than NY pizza, y’all get my 5 stars for sure!!!

Pizza like NY and NJ. The best 👍

Peppi’s is known for its pizza and pastas which are moderately priced. They also serve wine and beer .

Great food .. .. good pricing ... friendly staff ... not the biggest place but organized well. Freshly made pizza and home style Italian food.

The food was great and the people were very friendly.

This is the best pizza 🍕 in Naples. We love ❤️ this place The owners are so friendly and make you feel at home. 👍

Pizza by the slice has never been this good.

I stopped here for lunch on Wednesday and loved it! Our waitress was great and very attentive. The food was excellent and reasonably priced. We ordered the lasagna and a chicken cutlet hoagie. They have beer and wine as well if you're interested. Definitely recommend!

The ONLY pizza place to go to in Naples that knows how to make FANTASTIC FOOD!!

Simply Naples’ best sausage / pepperoni pizza.

Pizza was very good. All the dishes look good.

Ate at Peppi’s pizzeria while in town. Very busy on a Monday night. Pizza was good and the service was very friendly. Will eat there again.