Red Rooster Cookie Jar LLC in Lady Lake - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

First time customer and very impressed! Wide selection of fresh, well known baked goods along with unique local variations. Ordered “the kitchen” for a sampler selection and each was delicious. Also got free samples! Friendly service a great bonus to the food experience. Clean and pleasant store.

Amazing bakery. The overall feel of the shop is like what you imagine when you watch Hallmark movies. Between the decorations and the kind, friendly, and sweet lady at the counter, it feels like you stepped right into a movie. When we visited, we were even asked about our thoughts about an upcoming apple pie for fall which was delicious, which also showed how much they care about what they do and making sure their customers are happy. I can'twait to stop by again! (P.S. the mango/coconut clusters are beyond delicious)

The bakery is amazing! We were greeted by the" cookie lady" Yvonne and we were given samples to taste of her pumpkin pie and chocolate pie. They were both delicious. We thoroughly enjoyed our visit and of course bought a variety of pantries, cookies and an English muffin loaf( super tasty). We will definitely return. Bravo!!!

Excellent assortment of cookies. I bring them to clients and they love them

Everything we have tried has been delicious! The cookies, cinnamon rolls & butter cake are to die for. Definitely a must try.

First visit. It took a little work to find them since we aren't locals and the construction on 27/441 makes left turns going south a pita. Well worth the effort though. Cookies are very good. Lady who waited on us was great. A real credit to the business. Hard to ask for much more.

Good selection of sweets, etc. Friendly, helpful staff.

Man oh man we're these great cookies. I loved them all.

A very dear friend gave me a bag of your cookies for my birthday and I cannot remember when I have ever tasted such wonderful baking! I had never heard of your company, but rest assured, Red Rooster will be my go-to shop for special gifts for friends! Thank you so much!

Just found this place yesterday and will be back. The cookies are amazing, can't wait to try everything else!

Drove up from the bottom of the village’s today, based on reviews in TOTV. Well worth the trip. Met the owner, lovely lady that was ver proud of her many recipes. I surprised my wife with where we were going. Google maps took us right to the “house” her shop was located within. Great selection and we even were given a sample cookie. My wife sampled a Russian caramel and I had peanut butter cookies. Will definitely go back and highly recommend her business.

I went there as a delivery guy today, and was given a free choice of anything I wanted, which means a lot as a driver little things like that but I got the double fudge muffin and by far one of the best muffins I’ve ever had in my life thank you so so much!

Adorable little bakery with amazing baked goods...sweet owner and workers...👍❤️

I ordered a 12 variety pack of cookies & they were ALL delicious. I couldn't just pick 1. My family said they all tasted great, not too sweet, flavorful, moist, & most of all fresh. I also ordered some Benny Bites for my pitbull & she loved them. One sniff & comp! Thanks for having a gluten free variety 😉.

Deeeeelicious cookies and the best baking team and customer service! Highly recommend! :D

I’ve been a customer for several years and am delighted by almost every product in this bakery line. The flavor blends are unique and diverse. I have often brought them when I visit someone and they are always a hit and requested again.

I can't say enough about Red Rooster Cookie Jar. Their service and the quality of their goods is absolutely the best! The third time I ordered a selection of cookies for my mom in Florida, my sister was visiting her when the cookies arrived. Knowing what was in the box, my mother grabbed it and ran so that she could get to them first. It was absolutely hysterical! If you are looking for a sweet treat for a gift, a party or even just for yourself, look no further! This is where you want to be.

Absolutely, BEST cookies ever! prompt service/delivery and very fresh upon arrival. My Favorites.

Red Rooster Cookie Jar has the best cookies with the most variety of interesting flavor combinations. Each time I have purchased from the company, both cookies and other items (scones and breads), they are always fresh and delicious. They are my “go to” bakery when I want to treat myself or have company. Highly recommend.

Always gets orders out on time and the cookies and breads are delicious!

Best cookies around. If I’m going to cheat, that’s where I go!

Red Rooster Cookie Jar deserves a much higher rating, I'd give 10 stars if allowed!. We met Yvonne back in 2019 when she was selling at Brownwood's on Saturdays. We bought 2 bags (Chocolate Chip and Glazed Apple.) They were so good, we went back the following Sat and bought 4 more bags. Then Yvonne introduced us to her "Cookie of the Week" she offers. So we bought that, too. That's when I realized, as we got to know each other, that she makes a different "Cookie of the Week" every week of the year! We have been hooked ever since, ordering dozens at a time every few weeks. They freeze well for many months - just thaw a few at a time for 20 minutes and they taste just like fresh baked. I buy and stock pile my favorites in Zip-loc freezer bags, just so I have extras on hand when I need a gift for family, friends or neighbors that I might need to give a yummy gift to. I buy boxes and trays at the holidays for our gate house team, volunteers I work with, and anyone who deserves a sweet "pick-me-up" treat! EVERYONE I ever given Red Rooster cookies to has commented on how unique and delicious they are. Just try a bag or two. I promise, you will be happy you did. And the "Cookies of the Week?" It'll be an explosion of flavors like you've never had! Jan DeFranco Leesburg, FL

OMGSH! Where do I even begin ... YuMmY! yUMmmY!! YUMMY!!! I've never seen cookies sO mouth-watering delicious that I'd prefer not eat them but would rather gawk at them as screen savers on my phone! Guys, you gotta try them! Get their assorted box ... And try your best to eat just one! Trust me, it's impossible!

Yvonne, thank you so much for the yummy cookies!!! I love every different one. They are so delicious homemade cookies 🍪 every morning with my coffee & I’m ready to start my day😎

Red Rooster cookies are made by an angel who adds love to every batch! Great female owned business!

All of the cookies in my variety pack were fabulous!! I could taste all of the flavor and butter in every bite!!

Great cookies !!! If you need to send a thoughtful gift, this IS it. Who doesn’t like excellent home made cookies?? Thanks Yvonne!