Rita's Italian Ice & Frozen Custard - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

Really, really great. First time having custard and it was tremendous..

This was our first trip to a Rita's in over 15 years. There are more choices but the quality has remained consistent! We're loving the Unicorn sprinkles! We miss you Rita's! Please come to New England!

The girl behind the counter was so sweet! Will definitely be a repeat customer bc of that!

Very good custard and very good service

Definitely our new ice cream spot! The strawberry shortcake ice cream was awesome!! Kids loved their selections as well. We'll be back soon!

Indoor ritas with a gazillion flavors of custard!

Friendly and helpful staff. Ices/custards are great, albeit a little pricey. Don't like their rewards program but that's not the store's fault.

Friendly staff, and great choices, love this place

What a treat to share at our townwide Ho-Ho-Kus day! So many compliments and positive comments on our delicious giveaway! Mango was the winner!! But lemon and cotton candy were big hits too. Rita’s staff was wonderful to work with and did a great job helping us prepare for 300 hungry customers looking for a refreshing treat!! Thank you so much!!!

Great service Ice cream was delicious

Love going to Rita's, always delicious

Rita’s is by far my favorite, EXCELLENT customer service, workers are wonderful!!!

Great place and awesome custard!

Who doesn't love Rita's? Staff were very personable and helpful.

Amazing customer service very good ice cream 🍦 plus their slushes and smoothies are really good.

Love this place! Wonderful employees with attention to detail

Rita’s in Mahwah has my heart! Clean, quick service and the kindest employees ☺️

Great customer service, always greeted with a smile! The ices are great, they have a ton of different flavors!! Awesome selection of custards and toppings too!! Clean restaurant with plenty of seating and the park next door! We love Rita's in Mahwah! ❤️🍦

Oh wow...frozen custard!!! Yummy! The ladies were very friendly and welcoming

Absolutely delicious and tasty. They have a good variety of custard, gelato, shakes and Italian ices. They have numerous flavors to choose from. The establishment is clean, very nice to see. The employees are friendly and seem ready to wait on you and do their jobs. Great spot for a cool treat.

Great stuff I recommend the orange creamsickle

Have not as a southerner had this delicious treat. Had a hard time choosing a flavor. Decided on banana ice with vanilla custard. YUM

The best Ice cream I’ve ever had

Great ice flavor selection and wonderful custard. Super nice staff! Love to come here w my family

So good! Love the wild black cherry ice but also the creamy smooth coffee custard topped with hot fudge! Everyone is so nice and accomodating too! Great ice cream place!

Great staff and great iceeeeee 🧊

It's a Rita's, very clean and good customer service.

Great staff, clean establishment with a fun and friendly vibe, and a great place to grab some ice cream or Italian ice (or both!) year after year. Lots and lots of flavours of both Italian ice and custard to the point it's hard to choose. There are plenty of choices for those who have dietary restrictions, like lactose intolerance, low sugar diets, and those who can only eat Kosher foods.

Service is great, always a large variety of flavors.

Rita's in Mahwah is the best! Customer service beyond compare. It is the cleanest most well run ice cream shop I have ever been to. I always walk out with a smile because of the staff and the treats!

Was always a fan of Rita's but the woman (franchise owner?) was pretty rude in explaining they didn't have two things I asked for. When I said, I see on the screen you have the selections, she was curt and said, "That's everything Rita's advertises. We don't have it." She was annoyed. Maybe she was having a bad day, I dunno, but all I was doing was asking a question. It costs nothing to be nice.

Great ices and custard, very generous servings. Not too crowded!

Great Rita’s! Delicious iced, friendly staff, and neat store!

Service is always great and Rita's is simply the best.. I love the quart specials they run..I've only seen that at this location, great job guys

This place is very clean and they have a good selection of ices and custard flavors available. The staff follows COVID protocols (masks, gloves, partition at counter, masks & social distancing reuired). Friendly & fast service. I recommend this location!

Very popular. The family all love the options: ices, cone, sundae, fresh whipped custard. Only available for storefront window ordering, takeout and pickup.

A very well run Rita's. The owners are super helpful and they do a great job!