Smitty's Homemade Ice Cream - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

Not only do they have a variety of great,delicious, homemade flavors and a friendly staff , but they elated us with the safety measures they took for our daughter , who has a peanut and tree nut allergy. They washed their hands, got a new scoop and opened a new tub of ice cream. It’s so nice to be able to let our kids enjoy vacation and get ice cream with peace of mind. You guys are training your staff right and it doesn’t go unnoticed.

Not a bad place to get ice cream, if you're a mouse. Portion sizes are ridiculously small for the $6 price of their smallest size. I got coffee heath and there was almost no heath in it.

So yummy!!! All 3 of our cones were really good and the price was right.

Delicious Ice Cream Warm Waffle Cones tonight😊

I'm all about homemade ice cream and homemade whipped cream, both excellent here.

Delicious and real home made ice cream. Will always go back. Great service too.

Sundae School ice cream without the typical Sundae School lines. Small, cute and relaxing place to enjoy a scoop!

Awesome Ice Cream!!! We visit Cape Cod for a week annually and get ice cream from here every day. Definitely the best on the cape ❤️🍦

Best ice-cream on the planet!!!

Use to be known as Sunday school, but now smittys. An annual visit to this small ice cream shack is a must. A flavor I hadn’t seen before: banana Oreo. 3/5 people in our family ended up getting this! It was a fan favorite

Great place, small lines, quality ice-cream, friendly employees.

Great homemade ice cream in walking distance of the family home

No longer the Sundae School, but still has the charm and helpful young college kids working there. The ice cream is as good as before. It's worth the trip.

Really good ice cream for a hot humid day. Cash only! Service was good also. Enjoyed my Banana Oreo ice cream and my wife enjoyed her ginger ice cream.

Amazing ice cream and friendly service

Best Banana boat every hands down

Great homemade ice cream with tons of different flavors.

DELICIOUS! Their ice cream is decadent with all their fun flavors! Pricing is great as well!

Pros: Great location and the teenage staff seems to try hard. Cons: Pricey for what you get and ice cream is "ok".

Ice cream is delicious! They move through a long line pretty quickly. NOTE : Cash Only!

Got the black raspberry chip , fast service!

Now this is good ice cream! Tried the Nauset mud and added crushed heath bar. Small was just enough and the outside seating is an added bonus.

Really good ice cream in a quaint, old location that used to be Sundae School (the current owner was a Sundae School employee).

It's not bad. Basically run by teens - maybe avg age of 16 or 17? But they have enough of them that they can basically attend to the amount of people who may come through. It's pricey also, so be prepared - 4 smalls (@$5.50) and a sundae ($9.50) was over $36.... not sure how that's possible mathematically 🤔, but that was our total.🙄😕🥴

I ordered the Banana Oreo ice cream and it was so good that my group and I went back the following night.

Ice cream was delicious, we didn't have to wait long...

Excellent ice cream! Great variety of flavors to choose from. Big cones. A small cone is like a medium everywhere else. Highly recommend the mint oreo. Yum!!!

Its so good! I've loved this place for years, great service, and the ice cream is super good P.S the mini sundae is HUGE

Ice cream is average and that's being generous. Given 2 scoops of ice cream is $6 I expected a lot more. The flavors don't really taste that rich. They're just blah. They're missing that WOW factor. Also found some of the young kids scooping it, none wearing masks, put different amounts of ice cream in based on who was scooping. This place was a letdown. Had Ben and Jerry's earlier in the week and it blew this place away. Based on the other reviews on here I don't think these people have had really good ice cream before. That's too bad.

their homemade hot fudge and whipped cream is to die for. definitely check this place out if you’re in the area.

Love Smitty's ice cream (even though I really miss the old name)! Visited multiple times over my week at the Cape.

Great place for ice cream and a nice little area to sit while you eat, it is cash only, so bring some or you will pay a 3 dollar fee from the atm provided. Staff was super friendly and very fast.

ice cream was good. it costed $21 for three smalls tho.

Very good ice cream; lots of interesting flavors to choose from. Usually crowded but the staff is very efficient. Lots of parking; cash only

friendly staff very busy ice cream was so good

Delicious homemade icecream quick service and outstanding homemade whip cream 😋 a staple to our cape cod yearly trip

I remember coming here when it was Sundae School - this iteration is just as good, and perhaps even a little more efficient. A staple of my cape cod summers with my family.

Some of the best ice cream I’ve ever had! Crew is friendly and service is fast!

There is a pretty long line on some nights, but it's worth the wait.

This was the former awesome famous "Sundae School" ice cream parlor. So they have big shoes to fill.😊 Ice cream quality still very good. However the process needs to be tweaked a bit. I asked for hot fudge sundae to go and it was given to me with ice cream overflowing and the cap loosely applied. Needless to say by time I got back to my hotel my front seat in my car was wearing must of my sundae.🙃 The staff still very friendly. I think once they tweak there process it will still live up to the high expectation and name of the "Sundae School"! 😊