Sweet Times Bakery - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

My sister and I drove all the way there from Waterloo last Monday to find them closed- there was some type of renovation going on. There was nothing on their Facebook page when we checked last Monday about them being closed and google showed that they were open. We wasted over an hour round-trip drive for nothing. We have always enjoyed their food, but agree with other reviewers that some of the staff is far from friendly.

Very sub par. All the items look wonderful but as for taste...not impressed. Spent alot on a variety of goodies and a loaf of italian bread. Bread is crazy dense and just awful. Cheesecake tasted like they used margarine in crust and just not very cheese cakey. Other items were disappointing as well. I will stick to Wegmans, they are far better.

Fine establishment that handles our lunch needs in Victor.

The memories of their delicious breads never fades! Love any sandwich, of any kind on their wheat bread. Such a lovely bakery and restaurant!

Stopped in for lunch and enjoyed my salad. Ordered the chefs salad and wheat bread. The homemade bread was delicious. The salad and balsamic was tasty. Very friendly staff. So happy to see the small business being so busy on a Thursday afternoon. I didn’t try the desserts but they looked divine.

Sweet Time Bakery is great place to eat chocolate chip cookies. It's there number one seller. 25 years later, we still love it, same Owners.

I love this little bakery! I was so nervous to go in and ask for a personal reveal cake for my baby. They did such a great job and the cake was so good! We also picked up some other goodies that were delicious. My hubby got a sandwich which he ate in 2 minutes. Absolutely would recommend if you're in the area.

Great bakery/lunch spot with great people!!!

Ordered a gender reveal cake as well as two slices of strawberry cheesecake, a slice of what I call Hersey pie, two cannoli, and a BLT. Everything was pretty darn good. The cake turned out great and I'm eating some right now. Not just some superficial cake with pink or blue 🤌. Staff was friendly and didn't feel rushed despite it being busy at the time. Straight shooters.

So disappointed at sweet times yesterday…. Wow every employee was miserable … grouchy…. Rude….. won’t be going back……

Great service, good food. Tried this place because we were looking for a nice sandwich place. This checks the box good options. Had a turkey, pear, and gouda sandwich it was excellent. The whole group was pleased with their food.

Meant to check this place out for ages and I'm so glad I finally did. For $20 I got a HUGE, super delicious and fresh sandwich with chips, a pretty big serving of equally awesome soup, a drink, and the best lemon bar and cream puff I've ever had. Plus the ladies up front were friendly and helpful. Will definitely be back for lunch again! For $20 anywhere else it would be half the food and worse quality.

OH...this place IS..."wonderful.."...the owners and small staff....make Sweet Times...our favorite stop. They offer a nice assortment of soups and sandwiches daily. Everything is home style made. AND...the main attraction..are the fresh bakery items...wedding cakes made to order..and a complete COOKIE CASE...for the young in everybody's heart! .. with an old school atmosphere!

I've been a customer for 30yrs.

Everything is good, everything. Best bakery for miles! Cookies are fabulous and their carrot cake is hands down the best. My husband loves to go for lunch.

Just stopped in for the first time in years, just as excellent as i recalled.

Amazing flavor in all the baked goods!! The staff was friendly, explain the option of day old goods if available. They did not rush you nor did they push anything upon you. It felt like being in a warm family kitchen!!!!

Always excellent! The panda brownies are the best! So are the eclairs!!

My former work place. I love this place because of the homemade food. I went on a day off from my current job to see past co workers. I got the Bacon Tomato and Cheese it usually has Swiss and cheddar I switched the Swiss for provolone. They had their chili with cheese. I paired that with their homemade Italian bread. I would highly recommend this place to anyone who wants to try this for the first time. They also have cakes and cupcakes, cream puffs and cookies there is so many things for everyone to try. My favorite is the chocolate cake with peanut butter filling and peanut butter frosting with crumbled peanut butter cookies and chocolate Ganache drips.

Such friendly staff and amazing food. Try their chocolate peanut butter cups cakes. They're to die for.

Wonderful baked goods and coffee served in a friendly, welcoming environment. The sweets tray looks like it would be great for a party.

We ordered several dozen chocolate chip cookies and they were delicious!! Next order will be a personal order

Delicious turkey and bacon sandwiches!!

Home made food. Real food and well worth the trip

Fantastic sandwiches and treats!

Chicken salad is great. Homemade soups. Good cookies

Great staff, sweet, pleasant, helpful and courteous. Great food 😉

Love the chocolate oatmealcookies

My graduation cake from Sweet Times was wonderful!

Excellent food. Always fresh and homemade. 5 stars.

Chicken salad on their fresh baked bread yummy

Always great food and service!! It's comforting to know that you can still get a descent home cooked meal, and delish desserts without having to do all the work yourself!

Good Southwestern Chicken salad.

Nice bakery. Had a BLT for lunch. Excellent bread used for Sandwich.

Our first visit ever, the staff was very friendly. We bought a loaf of bread it was very heavy and it tasted awful the birds liked it . As for the cupcake the buttercream if that’s what you want to call it was made very poorly you don’t use oil that is gross. I will drive to Wegmans or Leo’s bakery before I go back there.

Eclair was like huge crusted bread, pumpkin bread was dry, cheesecake was marshmallowy, the peanut butter bar berally tasted like peanut butter ( which the lady preferred ). Just very underwhelming for 4.9 on 50 reviews. Maybe you don't go there for the pastries?

Great place here to eat! 100% fresh and great food I go in there for salads everyday !