Taste of Philly in Greeley - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

It's hard to find a sub shop that has a good Meatball sub, but Taste of Philly hits the mark when it comes to it.

Dylan and crew make the best sandwiches in Greeley!!!

Great food, good prices. But please turn up the AC. Hot last weekend.

Normally we love this food and place. But tonight the 12" sub was 1/2 the Normal meat size if not less. It was all bread. Paid 15.00 for bread. My total was 70.00. My family loves this place and will give them another try...

It was very good the service was brilliant the cashier was very sweet the Philly steak was top tier I love it

Clean restaurant, great staff, good food. The potato salad is great.

Awesome Philly and service is top notch! The owner is incredibly friendly and hires the same. Went twice in one week even and each time everything was phenomenal!

Ordered The Works… Fantastic Philly. It was Hot, fresh, lots of meat & smooth to eat. Best place in Northern Colorado. I will be a repeat customer. Many options in the Philly to your Stomach’s desire. Great food! Great Staff! Thank you for making a Wonderful Philly For me, I enjoyed every bite:) Kammi

Excellent mouth watering and delicious philly steak smothered in onions and cheese, I ordered mine large size and included an order of fry's done perfectly, honestly probably the best meal I've had in Greeley

Hot food. Hot fries. I'll be back

I had the Philly cheese steak with no bread...in a lettuce wrap..it was good

Yummy Philly , the Canoli was amazing The gal that waited on me was so nice. Definitely will eat here again

Bomb, delicious cheesesteaks a variety of different ways, a standout in the town without a doubt.

Every time we have been to Taste of Philly the food is amazing customer service is awesome quick and OnPoint every time what highly recommend.

Hey everyone. Food Guy here checking out Taste of Philly in Greeley Colorado. I think this restaurant could do a better job on atmosphere, it's very drab and dark. Needs to be much more uplifting. The location is not very good especially the parking situation. If it wasn't for MapQuest a person could easily pass this place by. Prices are a little high for this market area. $15.00 dollars is to high for a sandwich. The service was very good very attentive. Our food was delivered to the table within minutes. As for the food itself I was very happy to see a traditional Philly. The flavor hit the spot. If you looking to get a sandwich on the go this place will do just fine. Overall I give this restaurant a thumbs up, they just need to address a few things. Let me know your thoughts Atmosphere 1⭐ Location 1 ⭐ Price 1.5 ⭐ Service 5⭐ Food 4.5 ⭐

Cut to 5/29/24, meat found chunk of meat, very salty, gristle (never before), few mushrooms - had to dig to find. Very disappointed. See below Real Philly cheesesteak on fabulous rolls. Done to order, cheerful, efficient and great menu. We make this a regular in our fast food choices!

Food is really "Phillie". 👌 Try the original, you can order wit' wiz if you like. I like the meatball, and everyone loves the canoli! It's your typical college place, except the food is great! UPDATE I tried the cannolis and they were great!

Good delicious sandwiches and other excellent service and very nice, very clean place

Was perfect quick lunch! The guy that was taking order at counter was also running all around bring out food grabbing anything you needed was awesome vibe inside! Will always come here to get a Philly in Greeley!

Terrible just Terrible..one should always be able to identify the meat in a sandwich. The helping of meat stew placed on the bread was generous. Why bother asking if the onion "topping" is wanted when the onions have been long ago boiled into the stew disappearing from sight but overcooked flavor remains. I have a German Shepherd that would not pull this sandwich out of the trash even if she wouldn't be caught. Staff at register was very nice and obviously a hard worker. Consider renaming it Taste of Greely the exact opposite of Hawaii.

Very friendly , great food! Never disappointed in portions

The food is amazing! Delicious and filling. The service is fantastic! The woman who helped us was friendly and sweet, and knows what she's doing. So glad we came here! We'll be back for sure.

By far one of the best experiences out in a while. Came with my kiddos and the manager/owner? Was so fun and engaging with everyone in the store especially my kids. Amazing customer service. If we loved closer not just passing thru we would be here very often! We have been to many taste of Philly locations and although food is always consistent the service here is no comparison top tier.

Great food, service and pricing.

Cheesesteak was extremely bland no flavor to the meat what's so ever...and the chicken tenders was a bust as welll ..would of been better if the food had some sort of seasoning on it

Updating 2 to 4 stars! They do alright phillys. Definitely felt better about eating here the last few times.

The person behind the counter was extremely disrespectful when I used the restroom when I came in and then came up to the counter to order. I had violated some rule by not ordering first, and he was not interested in retaining me as a longtime, faithful customer. What a complete jerk with a horrible attitude toward customers.

The cheesesteaks here are sooo good! And I’m so happy this place has good cannolis!

Really good food and very friendly

It was good but it was a little dry. Took a while. They are completely understaffed for the amount of orders they have coming in. I watched them struggle to keep it together during a rush. All these things can be fixed. Will try again.

Stopped in to pick up two Rubens and two classic cheese steaks. Fries were made fresh and they were worth the wait. The whole family enjoyed the sandwiches. The staff was fantastic.

Dylan (Mgr) took my delivery order over the phone the day before. We wanted a catered option for a group of 25. Food was delivered on time by Dylan himself, he was very cordial and polite. He gave us all the utensils, serving spoons and even new salt and pepper shakers. Employees loved the food and buffet option worked the best for everyone. Salad was delicious as well.

I will have to give this place another chance, but my first try was a bit disappointing. I wanted to like it, but my sandwich was very bland and flavorless. The meat looked good and the sandwich looked appetizing in my pepper Philly, but was a lot down. With prices as high as they are these days, I've got to like it to make me keep coming back, so I plan to give it another try and maybe I'll update you when I do.

Used to love this place but recently the quality is terrible!! The fries are horrible and the bread is thin and very scarce on meat. Also the cheese curds seemed about half full. Not worth the rising prices if quality is going down.

Seriously I tried the coslaw and that was the first thing I devoured! You should definitely have that on the menu!!!!! Best slaw I've had in a long time! ❤️😋 Next my sandwich. You guys are awesome 💯 Thank you so much!

Sandwiches are very good. Fries are great. Service was excellent

The absolute best cheesesteaks I've ever had!

Probably the best Philly I’ve ever had. Very similar taste as something like Penn Station out east, but better.

Upset that I just paid $6 for a grilled cheese sandwich on regular bread with cold cheese and NOT GRILLED!!!! If the place was open right now I would head back there to show the staff the elementary field trip brown bag lunch they made.

If you need a Cheesesteak fix this is the best around. The Fries are great as well. Friendly staff, too boot.

All around great experience, ordered online and picked it up, staff was very friendly, got home and the food looked amazing and tasted even better, the cheese steak was by far one of the best I've had, will definitely be a repeat customer

I love the philly cheese steaks here! Not dry, not soggy, just perfect. Staff is helpful and nice. Food is always hot and delicious.

Everything on their menu is delicious. They listen and ensure you are happy with your order.

Excellent Philly Cheesesteak! Absolutely awesome! 💯

This is as good as it gets for phillies from Colorado. Delicious!!

Since Phillys has updated their hours, I feel the need to update my review. I'm so happy they're open later now and fully support that change, much as I love this place, there's been a few times I didn't get an order in before closing. It's been about a year and a half since my review and many, many orders later and all I can say is, it just keeps getting better. You know that favorite spot you have, where you think they can't top themselves, until your next order; and they do? That's Phillys right there. Their food is beyond words good and they've always got deals going on for free delivery, 3 dollars off orders, etc, just check on your next take-out menu, they have 4 coupons in there! If you still haven't tried Taste of Philly, put in an order and join those of us who are customers for life! Thank you to all the fantastic crew there, keep up the great work and good on ya for being consistently amazing!

Great food and great customer service

The owner gave me a free sandwich because I was struggling financially. Good people.

Food is good and workers are nice as well

Oml so good! We got a pepper Philly and one with the works and they were awesome, next time we'll order extra cheese. The fries and onion rings are good but the rings seem over priced. But oh man, the cannolis are to die for!

We had the 8 inch Phillys were alright. My son made his a combo(drink & fries or onion rings)and that was about $17 total...so idk if that is normal for Philly steak sandwich. The wings were good & the onion rings were a favorite of mine. Overall it was alright...have had better though but definitely not the worse neither.

The GM is awesome!!! Great staff! Food is always hot and delicious!!

Ladies were very nice but after $50 for 3 subs that had basically no cheese on them we were more than disappointed.

My family needed to use the restroom and the cashier was super rude after we said we would buy something to use the restroom. He let us walk to the restroom to have to walk back because you need a code to get in and he refuse to give me the code until after we paid. I will never come here again I hope this helps you make your decision. ✌️❤️

It's definitely a nice sandwich shop. The philly i ordered was disappointing considering the competition around here.

Best cheesesteaks in Greeley! Little pricey but worth it.

1 star off for the roll, which is really good don't get me wrong. I would definitely return!!! Go Birds!!

We were craving a good Philly Steak & Cheese sandwich and the second I walked through the door I knew it would be good... and it was 👍🏻. Atvthe counter, I ordered an 8" Philly Steak with Cheese Wiz, onions, peppers and mushrooms sandwich (they forgot the mushrooms 😠). After ordering we sat down and the counter guy brought our sandwiches to us. He ever asked to make sure we had everything... excellent service. Very friendly. The sandwich was yummy yummy in my tummy good 👍🏻. Price was normal. I didn't check the restroom. 5 stars ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

Amazing food amazing customer service. Definitely will be returning!!!

From every black employee that’s worked at this place , they’ve been discriminated against . This is not a place you want to work at if you want to be treated fairly and given decent human rights.

Good Phillies but really expensive.

Very clean nice friendly service

Really good cheese steaks. Service was fast. Nice spot for a quick lunch.

Awesome Philly's!! We will be back!!

First time eating here. Everything was very good!

Taste of Philly has had my favorite steak since I can remember. To keep it positive Greeley location has always been worth the wait. It's not in my nature to give 5 stars, but today during lunch rush I received THE BEST service by Taylor and received the best cheesesteak from Zack (h?) faster than ever. Even got to take some rolls home. Thank y'all very much.

Have yet to be disappointed with their sandwiches. I have eaten here 4 times and I have ordered different item, it's good. My adult kids love it too.

What an incredible experience, by far the most authentic tasting Philly I have had in a very longtime, also if you enjoy onion rings, they did an amazing job! 110 recommended coming here! Not to mention Dylan, Dylan was phenomenal and absolutely did an amazing job at welcoming me for the first ever being there! His energy and positivity is very welcoming! I will 100% be coming here very often and frequently! Thank you guys for the awesome service today! GO HERE TO EAT AND YOU WILL NOT BE DISAPPOINTED!

Great food as always service was excellent cannolis are to die for. We forgot our cannolis and went back gave them to us no questions love this place.

It was my first time there and the food was amazing, and the lady behind the counter was wonderful.

Food was ok. Nothing special. Thing that turned me off was the ketchup and mustard in the squeeze bottles was old. Tasted very bad. Luckily I didn't put them all over my fries but it left a very bad taste in my mouth. Serving time eating here.

I know this place has been here for sometime, but "the works" with a touch of mayo (self choice) It was just an immense flavor. Awesome place that i will most definitely and highly likely to recommend to others and come back to.

Cashier was very polite helped us with are order also the cook took the time to come out and ask if everything was good. very good service will recommend to other people.

Philly Steak is number 1 They know how to make it it great

VERY DISAPPOINTED IN TASTE OF PHILLY TONIGHT!!! MY PHILLY IS LITERALLY SOAKED!! SO SOGGY I CAN'T EVEN FINISH HALF OF IT I TOOK A VIDEO BUT IT'S NOT LETTING ME POST IT YET.... IDK WHY

Good cheese steak, close to a real Philly. Food overall was good but onion rings were over cooked.

Awesome fries, phillys arent really my thing but when I go here the Phillys they serve makes me more of a fan! Great food, awesome service!

Fresh and delicious definitely going back for more

They’re back!! Dillon (manager) left for a short time. It was never the same when he was gone so I quit coming in. Well he is back and everything is great again. Best food, best service, restaurant is clean again. The atmosphere is back to being friendly and welcoming.

Love the cheesesteaks every time. But every time I walk in a super foul odor hits me? Been twice now, with a good length of time in between and the smell was still there. Always get to go for this reason. Am I the only one smelling this ?

HORRIBLE. Got a BLT delivered and it was SOAKED in Mayo and had almost a whole tomato in it. Like 3 strips of burnt bacon. But again couldn’t even taste anything but Mayo.

Try thr Canolis for dessert! Awesome!!

Fantastic food and service in the manager was extremely helpful

We love this place. The food is ALWAYS FRESH! THE STAFF IS AWESOME and it is always very clean. Definitely our favorite place for a Philly sandwich. 💯

Be careful. When busy the food may be very hot.

If you want the best Philly cheese steak in town you need to come to Taste of Philly. The staff and the service there are great. Thank you

Food is delicious. Customer service is awesome. Could use a little lift on the inside. Is still our go to for greaat food..

Classic Philly taste with the owner often working the front. A small business that i will continue to support due to top notch service and consistent food!

Very friendly and helpful owner

So stinking delicious Amazing customer service with a smile 😃 Every time!!!!

For colorado, this was a tasty cheese steak! The bread was soft, the meat was nicely seasoned, and there was a ton of it stuffed into our sandwiches! It was deffinatley a great value for the money! The cheese steaks is the best part of the place. We ordered a side of fries...that were just ok...under salted and not very crispy. We also ordered onion rings....I thought they were good.. my boyfriend didnt like them...very mixed opinions! When the moode for a good cheesesteak arises, we will return!

I eat here regulary and they never failed me...

One of the best places in town to get a meatball sub. Fries are pretty good. Personally I like them better then Fat Shacks. ❤️

What a treat for lunch! Delicious!!

It's a good cheesesteak. They now have cheesecurds with your choice of marinara, ranch or blue cheese. But apparently they charge for sauces. It's almost $5 for a regular for ~10 curds and no sauce...

Placed an order over the phone. Over an hour later the order was still sitting on their counter. Their response was that I could drive out to them and pick it up. If I had been able to go out there, I wouldn't have ordered delivery in the first place. Moreover, expecting me to accept a cheese steak order that has been sitting around for over an hour old is ridiculous. Especially after paying $30 for it.

Best sandwich I've had period! Amazing food!

Amazing place had the club and the ratios were spot on. These guys car about tye product they put infornt of there customers. Will eat here often

Great food, made fresh right there. The guy acting as cashier made me laugh. His staff called in sick, too much partying the night before. 😆 Life in a college town. We'll be back.

Very good, great value for what you get. Nice staff and a clean restaurant.