Times Square Pizza Co in Bloomingdale - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

Always good pizza, flavor, ingredients and fresh tasting. Can't miss trying it out, you'll be impressed! And, always hot and ready!!

Best New York style pizza place in this area. I’ve tried all the pizza spots around here and Times Square is my favorite. I think Portnoy would score it somewhere around 7.4ish. The wings here are excellent! I’ve tried the meatball sub as well and it’s also great. Their white pizza is also ridiculously good. Overall I Definitely recommend this place.

I can't order from anywhere else. Every single order has been exceptional. This is the only pizza on the west side of Florida that I could present to a snobby ny-er

We order for delivery. Generally it's very good!

Been coming for years for the extra large thin crust. Not sure what’s happened but last few times it’s not been as good. They skimp on the toppings big time, and hardly any cheese or sauce it seems. I swear it’s smaller now too. Hope they go back to what they did before. Update: been better lately

Food and service are always good!

Great food, fast service, and easy to order with a phone call!

Never disappoints the pizzas always good

New York Times Square Co. Pizza in Bloomingdale is our favorite pizza place! Being we are from New Jersey, we are very picky too!! Their quality is off the charts!! Service is too!! Definitely recommend!!

Best NY style pizza around!!! Always on point and delicious.

Love this place. Pizza 🍕 is great.

Amazing place food is awesome and one of the best server is Kim she loves kids she has seven of them and if you look at the wall she has drawings kids made her

A neat place with excellent pizza for a heck of a price! The pizzas are huge and one slice would be enough to satisfy but it’s so good you’ll want to eat at least 2 slices!

Had delivery and wonderful delicious food!

The White Sauce Pizza and Veggie Pizza are both amazing. The staff are very nice and the food tastes amazing. The boneless wings are honestly better than other mainstream wing restaurants, especially the sweet chill.

Walked in for lunch, the staff was friendly, the pizza was delicious, and the atmosphere was very chill and laid back. Will definitely be returning, and recommending to others. Keep up the great work.

Born in Philly , lived in NY , this is by far my favorite pizza in the area! Friendly service, great food . Why go anywhere else

Garlic knots were tiny but otherwise normal tasting. Pizza was as expected.

Some of the best pizza in the Tampa area comes from this very unassuming store front. They have just the right blend of sauce and cheese. Prices are good. Their dough is fantastic and very bread-like, not rubbery like some of the mega-chain pizza places. The menu has a wide variety of items like salad, wings, sandwiches, and gourmet pizza. Their staff is courteous and friendly. I also heard if you wear a Sandlot t-shirt in the store they give you 10% off (conditions subject to change) :-) You're killing me smalls.

Just a nice local pizza place with excellent pizza, employees are super friendly, it’s clean and laid back.

Best pizza in Valrico! No others are even close. Friendly service.

I Just want to say. This may not sit well with some that said Being from New York I read a lot of people saying "NewYork Style " pizza. New York style pizza 🍕 is long not short extremely greezy and mostly cheesy and Not doughy also foldable and slim This is not New York Pizza and does not taste like it , maybe people say "NewYork style" for shape? Idk. Maybe Looks like NY style? But not NY. Style .That said. I am in NO way saying it's not good food. Just speaking on pizza, closest to actual NY style pizza was Eddie's and Sam's downtown Tampa and throughout the years they've changed

I love the pizza. I've tried every pizza joint in Brandon area. Great pizza, great price! Give it a try.

I’m in Times Square at least 3x a week! The food is amazing and I’ve got 2 cashiers that are just like my BFF’s! I’m forever hooked not only to the amazing food but the girls that make my experience that much better-I’m the sweet tea lover of the world and these girls do everything they can to give me a great day! Thank you for being SO kind to me no matter what kind of day you’re having 💗

Food is great, and prices are reasonable! So hard to find really good pizza that’s consistent. I’ve tried a lot of places in this area and it’s hit or miss, but so far every order I’ve had from here has been spot-on! On top of that, the staff is friendly and my order is always ready on time. Highly recommend!

It's my go to for Friday pizza. Hot and tasty.

The pizza I was served was super tough and cold. I don’t know what happened here, but I don’t think it was a freshly made pizza at all. It was so dry the pepperonis fell off as I attempted to eat it.

Ordered pizza for pickup. The wait time was an hour. We had the Times Square Special, the Philly Bomb, and the Sweet Aloha. We really liked all of them. It was the best pizza that we have tried in this area.

Awesome pizza, great lunch specials! Friendly service and if you're able to stay and eat, you might even enjoy a beer-

Not sure why but it's not giving me the option to reply so I'll reply here, Owner... my last 2 orders were messed up. For the delivery order, I was brought the wrong food. I called, someone came, took the wrong and gave me the right food but it was cold by then. Second order was pickup. I ordered 3 extra sauces & was charged but didn't get them. I didn't call in about that. Your food is great. I'm only answering your question. No hate here.

the spicy buffalo chicken pizza will knock those socks right off your feet

My family and I regularly eat here and we always love the food here! Their pizza is always delicious and we love their wings! This is one of our go to spots. My son always enjoys it too. Hot buffalo chicken pizza with a side of blue cheese is one of our favorites. Employees have always been very kind.

Favorite place to eat pizza and wings no joke one of if not the best pizza i have in my life and pricing is amazing too for the quality of the food and service!!!!!!

Owner... is really nice and works hard right along with his employees

Pizza is the best in town!! Def ny taste pizza!! Yum

It's quaint but the food is hot, the service is great and they have a great menu with specials running all throughout the week. Extra seating outside for those that have pets and want to enjoy the weather.

Been a loyal customer for about a year now, saddened to say the owners have ruined the experience. They have been consistently rude and disrespectful to us nearly every time we have been. We decided to try out their Wednesday trivia nights and watched them turn away a group of teenage girls who apparently have been going there for years because they were out of chairs even after the girls brought their own chairs. The food is also mediocre and the pizza always has an odd layer of grease on top. The bathroom is also disgusting, and is always covered in a warm potent feces smell. The girl who answers the phone and is typically at the counter, Kim, is very sweet though and has never let me down.

Order pizza for dinner. Fresh out of the oven upon pickup. Very good

My whole extended family from NY loves this place. Those of us local get takeout here regularly, and whenever my folks visit they ask for Times Square Pizza. If you want NY style that's just right, for a good price and all the sides you expect to find at a NY pizzeria, this is the place.

After years away, I decided to revisit, opting for the lunch special: 2 slices and a drink. The price was just right, and the pizza exceeded expectations—hot, crispy, and delicious. The attentive and friendly employee checking on us added to the positive experience. I'll certainly be returning to explore more of their menu.

My wife and I came to try this place because of all the hype on the reviews. We are celebrating our 9 year anniversary and was in the area and made the stop. Everyone who reads this. This location pizza is amazing so great job to the staff🫡

The Thanksgiving Pizza is everything I imagined! Super delicious!!! If only there were also mashed potatoes on it! Either way, super yummy! 🦃 🍕

The Times Square Special pizza was awesome! Crust was crispy and toppings were fresh! Will be back! Came back today, 10/28/23, and it's still great! Keep up the good work!

Awesome pizza ! A 10 for the whole family!!

So delicious! I absolutely love this place!

Had a awesome meat pizza pie and a cold beer, great atmosphere and they're very friendly.

I’m from northeast PA very close to NYC & grew up in Italian restaurants. That said, I had this pizza for the first time tonight and it was delicious plus reminded me of home. I will be ordering from TS Pizza moving forward.

Absolutely the worst pizza I have had. Delivery was 1 1/2 hour wait, food was completely cold! Pizza was almost taste! Terrible - too many good pizza shops in our area to waste your money!

Excellent service, excellent pizza, like New York style

Everything was fine. The atmosphere is one of a take-out (come order and go home) than it is a dine-in

Our Go-To pizza place. Local, independent, and always excellent! Damn good pizza!

The pizza here is worse than any other so called “NY Pizza” in the Tampa area.

Great Pizza… order well done.. thank me later

I find the pizza here to be the most consistently good pizza. We have tried all the pizza places in the area, but this one stands out. We have gotten take out and eaten there.

Showed up at time specified by the website and my order hasn't even been started yet. And 15 min after that time still nothing.

La pizza es excelente. Es de la puedes coMer y no te cae mal al estomago, buen servicio y precios. Tienen ofertas entre la semana. También hacen delivery. Amamos la pizza de este lugar.

Love the pizza here. They have different daily specials to choose from, and the service is on time. Recommend.

Pizza was pretty good. We drove about an hour because we found out Shane owned it and my 5 and 8 year old are huge fans and wanted to meet him. Sadly even though it was mid day on a Sunday and they where very slow Shane wouldn't come out to say hi...

Nice fairly cheap giving inflation in 2022-23 Stromboli taste pretty good decent portion

We drive out of the way to order pizza from here. Genuinely the best pizza in the area. Unlike other local places their pizza is not full of olive oil. Every time we got the pizza , it has been consistent. Their sausage pizza is a must try. Great job keeping it authentic and not compromising on quality.

Their pizza is very good and the service is pretty decent as well. Def worth a try

INCREDIBLE FOOD!!! Went today with my husband, kids and twin grand-babies…the food was incredible and the young lady at the front who took our order was SO SWEET AND ACCOMMODATING! Love this place so much we’re making it a weekly outing! And can we talk about the Cannoli chips?!?!?!! My God!!!

Awful !! - We ordered only 2 times- The first time they got our order wrong- Corrected it no problem- - Pizza was OK - Nothing to write home about ..... 2nd time- Lady at the desk, was RUDE- Like I interrupted her from doing something to pick up MY order which I paid for... if it wasn't for me BUYING pizza, She wouldn't have a job, But onto the next issue- The pizza was BURNT- DRY- TASTED LIKE CARDBOARD- It was AWFUL !!!! Never again, We will stick with Bloomingdale Pizza and other surrounding small businesses!!

Best place you never knew about lol Tucked away between Publix and Bealls is a small pizzeria. New York style pizza with all the fixings. Some great lunch specials. A slice of this, with a little bit of that... And a drink too! We had two different lunch specials, a small calzone, order of curly fries and.... Fried pepperoni !! My lunch special came with garlic knots. My son's calzone was fairly big (for a small!) He only ate half. Stuffed with cheese and toppings, coated in butter and garlic YUM! It is definitely a spot to try out. You should enjoy it.

They have the best party pizza. Delicious.

From a pizza guy, Flat out Great pizza

This is my favorite go to for pizza. The pizza is good and the prices are fair as well.

Still the best New York style pizza in Brandon. Eat-in or delivery and also have outside seating if social distancing is desired...

The staff was very welcoming and helpful. I hate saying this but to be truthful the atmosphere was something to desire. I ordered pepperoni pizza and recieved a thin triangle pepperoni cheesy bread. If you're in the mood for pizza there's better options on Bloomingdale. I saw a small bar in the place, next time I'll have a few drinks before ordering.... Or just drink.

So it's been 9 months since moving from NY to FL and we have been looking for decent pizza the entire time. Stopped in on a whim and were really impressed. Pizza was so good we ordered more. Salad was perfect as well. Happy to find out they deliver to our house as well. Highly recommend!

I love love love love this pizza.

Was delicious. I think I got the Monday or Tuesday special, the pizza was only $12 and fresh.

I have been a repeat customer for a few months but after the terrible experience I will not return. I was sold food that was not edible, I called to speak to a manager was told that one wasn't available then I called back and was told by the cashier that the manager AJ said that there was nothing that he could do nothing but offer a 30% discount lol after I paid $41 plus and I just wanted my food remade. Then to insult me further he refused to to come to the phone and talk to me. I called today and the cashier told me that the manager named Shane was to busy to come and speak to me and would call me back but I still have not heard from Anyone. There customer service sucks

My wife had to be stuck at the plaza waiting for me .She came inside this pizzeria where it says 2 slices and a drink for $4.99 My wife went inside to order and was told by Kim with a very unwelcoming demeanor, that the deal finishes at 5 pm. My wife said the sign outside doesn't say it finishes at 5 and since it was only 30 minutes later can she still honor the deal? Nowhere does it give a specific time. Kim with a cold attitude responds N.O. My wife asked for a manager, she responded that he just left. My wife did say she will leave a review about her unfriendly and impolite attitude which did not faze her. She said have a good day. It is very misleading to put out a deal without time limit and tell costumers that there is a time limit after entering.

Being from New York it’s always a struggle to find acceptable pizza. Tonight my family ordered from Times Square Pizza and i was so pleasantly surprised! The pizza was fresh and delicious and the veggies were also fresh and not canned which was the cherry on top of the pie…no pun intended. I’d have had a photo but we ate the whole thing!

Excellent pizza. This is my new favorite pizza restaurant. This was our 3rd time and our orders have been perfect and SO delicious. 🍕❤️

Even better the next day. Great pizza.

First time eating pizza from here. Crust was flavorful! Pizza tasted great! Toppings were flavorful! We will order from here again!

F*cking phenomenal! I don’t know what it is, if it’s the robust sauce, taste like it’s flown straight from Italy. Is it the mozzarella, Wings so fresh they must have their own buffaloes in the back. Better Ingredients, better pizza. Times Square Pizza!

Great experience ordering for a luncheon at work today. Pizza was delicious. Great service. I would definitely recommend and order again!

I loved the pizza it was good. Wings perfect, garlic knots epic 🔥🔥 best pizza spot in atleast 3 tampa bay area counties.! Will be eating here again!! Must try. 5 out of 5 !! 🤤🤤

I never take the time to do a review unless I'm really really upset being a business owner I know how it affects you.. I've been your customer for over 7 years my orders are usually very big. But as of last week it will be the last time I order I am tired of begging the person who's taking the order not to burn the top or the bottom of my pizza.. Made an order last week of one meat lovers and a side of cheesy bread it was the smallest order I have ever made as a customer to you and I specifically ask her not to burn the top or the bottom of the pizza after receiving my order order and tipping the driver and not driver a $9 tip I felt robbed I opened the pizza and it was burnt on top it was unedible.. So moving forward I will never order from you again even though your food is delicious.. But if I can't eat it then there's a problem. Mrs MD Hassan valrico fl ..

Customer service is friendly, professional and fast.

We were looking for a good pizza place while visiting on vacation and ended up trying the wings too. The pizza crust is FABULOUS and i would give anything to have that terriyaki sauce recipe here in VA. 😩 So good! And love the fact they’re not a ‘chain’. Everyone was super nice. We will definitely go back next year!

We love Times Square Pizza! They never disappoint. Obsessed with their Buffalo chicken fries (appetizer) and love their Monday $9 large cheese pizza deal. Highly recommend!

Charlie runs this place like a smooth machine. GREAT pizza .

Pizzas are good, 4-5 stars. All orders for fries are super overpriced for the amount you get. $7 Buffalo cheese fries with $2 added chicken. Got maybe 4 slivers are thinly sliced chicken and about 20 fries total. Come on.

Ordered a pizza light cooked and it was hard as a rock and burned. Meatball parm sandwich extra sauce extra and nothing. Never going there again

The pizza itself is decent, but the website has issues & customer service over the phone is lacking.

If you like that New York/Jersey style pizza then you have to come get you some of theirs!

Great food and affordable pricing! Not to mention delicious. Delivery beat the estimated time

Stopped in for a salad and a beer. Both were great and reasonably priced. The staff is also very friendly. I definitely recommend them.

I've been in Florida since November 2021, and Time Square Pizza is the best I've had since moving here. We ordered the extra large plain pizza. It was delicious and not overcooked. I'll definitely be eating there again. 😊

Great place to have lunch , we even get take home on weekends. The lunch special was perfect and the price for two slices and a drink can't be beat. Staff are awesome people , we will be back.

I come from Pinellas county for this Pizza. Amazing. Love love love

After I left a review of your pizza it was very nice of you to offer a free pizza. The pizza we are use to being from Iowa they load the pizzas up with meat. You have a good product and one of the best we have had down here in Florida. We spend 6 months here and then back to the Iowa Quad Cities. We are getting ready to head North and didn't want you to think we didn't like your pizza and I give reviews to let know how pleased we were. You have a good product and we had picked up orders from tour store a couple of times. Again thank you for the offer of a free pizza, that in itself shows you care about your products quality. Thanks again

Great tasting pizza great staff and environment

Pizza had a good crust and good taste. Could use more meat. Cheese and sauce was the right amount.

If your looking for a pizza with a thin crust with sauce just about to the edge and loaded with toppings and incredible cheese , this is the place to get it! I went there a couple times a couple of years ago and it was great! We stopped in yesterday because we were in the area. We were blown away with this pizza! Apparently we didn't get enough because we drove out of our way today to get another. Once again it's was awesome. So I would say they are consistent. Prices are right! Don't understand the negative reviews. Same quality for the past 2 years! Yum!

My favorite pizza place in the area.