Timoti's Seafood Shak in Fernandina Beach - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

The food is tremendous. Never disappoints.

My family and I visited this place on August 22, 2024. We ordered the Shrimp Basket - Grilled, Poke Bowl, Rice Box - with Fried Fish, and Chicken Strips Basket. The food was excellent, the Ahi Tuna being my favorite as it was very buttery in texture and fresh. The service was also terrific! And it didn't take more than maybe 6 minutes for the food to come out. Really enjoyed this restaurant and would love to come back in the future!

Always a must stop when we visit Amelia Island, & never disappoints. Awesome fresh seafood!

Timoti’s has great seafood with fair prices. Our family eats here every time we visit Amelia Island and the last time we came we ate there 3 out of the 4 days and tried something new each night and was pleased with taste as well as the service…Thanks Timoti’s for making our vacation awesome!!!!

We love this place! The shrimp is great. The outdoor seating is very nice and breezy. There's a small playground for kids.

My family and I live a few blocks down the road and Timotis is our go-to restaurant because our 5 year old loves the fish basket, and it’s less than $7, which is a deal around here. Most of the time, when we come in, Mr, Christian is at the front counter and I just want to say that he, and all the staff who I interact with, are so kind and friendly. They’re personal and they get the job done. Depending on the season, there is sometimes a line out the door (because the food is so good, so fresh and their service is so efficient that the lines never take long and you always get to build community with your neighbors and tourists alike. And, they have an awesome playground that’s contained and safe, which I know us parents very much appreciate.

In town for work. Stopped here based on reviews and was NOT disappointed. I had the Blackened Corbin basket to try something I’ve never had before and I can only say it was amazing. The entire staff was very friendly and professional. I would recommend 💯

Always awesome! The young lady taking orders was incredibly quick, efficient, and knowledgeable while still being friendly and making you feel at home.

I heard great reviews about this place , so I went to go try it . And it was all true 👍 5 stars all around

Amazing atmosphere, amazing food, amazing service. Good place to bring the family with kids.

Only outdoor seating. Other than that it's great.

this is a great spot for families, and they have a great menu selection. the only disappointment was no indoor seating and limited outdoor seating. there is a playground for kids. would reccomened the poke bowl. definitely and must try restaurant!

Delicious seafood with large portions. Recommend shrimp and fried clams. Coleslaw is yummy - creamy and tangy.

Great food....casual seating ... loved the friendliness of the staff

We got stuck in a thunderstorm right when we arrived. Food and thunder came fast and both were yummy and exciting as we sat under the covered seating area! The fried green tomatoes were divine!

Great food, not huge portions, and limited seating, especially after a rain. Our food was great, just could have a little more shrimp in the baskets. The side salad was diced iceberg, tomatoes, and cucumber. Very simple. The fried green tomatoes were a very nice upgraded version with a sweet relish and feta. Very good. Overall good and will return, but try to get there early. They got very busy and we had a rude family just start sitting in our seats and forced us out before we were finished eating.

Very good seafood I've been here many times each time very good some of the best fish and chips I've had there other stuff is good too like their fish tacos poké bowl even if you don't like seafood their chicken is also amazing would definitely recommend to anyone in the area

Great little place. Delicious food.

This place is a must. Food was delicious

Always good food in a relaxed, picnic table atmosphere. Very popular for a good reason! Everything from fried to blackened seafood to tuna poke bowl was delicious. No white linen tablecloth, but good food at a reasonable price! The locals love it!

Four Words. DO NOT MISS THIS! Fourth day of our vacation. Spent a lot more $$$ on other restaurants. Best food by far our entire trip. LOVE THIS PLACE. Great food, great people, great Vibe.

I look forward to visiting this place on every vacation. It is a great spot for kids as they have a playground(heads up the old wooden ship is gone and they upgraded to a new playground set) and it is easily viewable from picnic tables in the shade for parents.

Everything about this spot was great. Vibe was excellent from the start, service was absolutely excellent as well. We couldn’t decide what we wanted and ordered a little of everything (crab burger, shrimp tacos, lobster rolls, poke bowl, cucumber salad and fried green tomatoes). Everything was wonderful, fresh and fast. So glad we wondered into this place!

Great little seafood stand. Very fresh!

One of our favorite places to eat when we visit the Island. Always good, always fresh.

Incredibly good food, especially the blackened fish meal. I could have done without the sweet relish on the fried green tomatoes as it just made them soggy. We couldn’t eat the majority of them because they fell apart when removed from the dish. There is no indoor seating, but the communal patio is covered and equipped with large fans. I’m sure this is just fine during milder weather, but good to know on particularly hot or humid days. Still totally worth the stop, especially if you’re not local!

Really great food. We got the poke bowl and the Baja bowl and both were delicious! We came in at 11:45am and there was no line! Thank you for the great experience!

This place is charming with its outdoor picnic tables and playground. Unfortunately, my poke bowl was quite spare aside from the heaps of raw spinach. The cucumber salad was ok, but felt like it sat in a vat of dressing all day so it also tasted like a big helping of pickes. My wife liked her Baja bowl, but wished the rice and beans were warm.

We really liked it here.Lobster rolls were great.

The food was excellent! Atmosphere, is a no. Do not go on a rainy day. The outdoor seating consists of a few picnic tables under a leaky, poorly designed roof. We were miserable in the rain. But again the food was fantastic, so just don't go on a rainy day, and/or take the food to go. We will be going back on a sunny day.

Great food makes up for the lack of seating. Get there early to avoid the line. Has a home town local owned restaurant feel to it. Good food with lower than expected prices.

LOVE this place! AMAZING blackened mahi. And the prices are unbeatable!

Off hours are best if you don't like lines. There's a reason they're busy, though. Not just with tourists.

Lobster rolls are the best and they always have quick service. Tacos and French fries are also delicious!

Everything was excellent, O wish I could eat it again instantly. Rice box felt like a bit of a gamble at first but it was perfect. Sweet soy sauce was exactly what I wanted on a perfectly blackened fish. Hush puppies, chicken tacos, all excellent. If you have kids, a place w a fenced in playground is a dream. Can’t wait to return

Lobster rolls were delicious. Their hushpuppies are very good! Bacon on the BLT’s could be cooked a little more. Service was amazing as well, very friendly and quick staff. The tables outside are kind of gross, and very worn down. Hopefully they put some money into getting better seating outside. But overall it was amazing and we are definitely coming back here in the future.

Be prepared for a long wait. Maybe do a mobile order? No indoor seating so be cognizant of the weather.

Great place to eat with good food and good prices! You order at the counter and we sat outside on picnic tables. I had the chopped salad box with added salmon and it was so delicious! Kids had fish or shrimp which was good. We liked their hush puppies better than Salt Life. Would recommend!

Awesome restaurant! The only bad part is they have very limited seating. I don't recommend it with a party larger then 5. Food is always great and employees are always ready to help

Great place for a meal with the family! The blackened shrimp was excellent and the cucumber salad was a nice fresh treat! I would love to come back and try all of the menus items! Also my husband said he would eat vats of the red chowder!

My family loves visiting Timoti’s. The staff is always friendly, the service is fast, and the food is fresh and delicious. I will visit them any time I’m in town. They also have a great beer selection including one brewed in Tampa just for the restaurant! Was a perfect pairing with the fish.

Tasty food here! I had the catch of the day basket (fish was cobia snd I ordered it grilled) and also had the lobster rolls. Both were flavorful. The place has outdoor seating only, but it’s well shaded. Food is ready very quickly.

Great place for lunch/dinner before going out to the bars

Best Fish basket ever! We had ours blackened. Their seasoning is perfectly spunkly, not hot but plenty of spice for a mouthful of flavor.

My family has eaten here for years, now, and we have yet to experience a less-than-stellar meal. Fresh ingredients prepared to order, and for the money it is a pretty decent value.

T’s is always good. Fried, grilled or blackened. Local seafood Old Florida style! Eat there often and never had a bad meal.

We absolutely loved the food here!! This is a must place to eat in Fernandina. We wish we had one in California. Best Lobster Roll ever. The Fish Basket was so good and so was the Cucumber Salad, so so good. We also loved the atmosphere and meeting people who were sitting at the other end of our table.

This place has tasty good food coleslaw had a fresh 😋 taste, calamari was soft and crispy really good, and my wife had the fresh catch she was really happy with her choice and for dessert we had key lime pie & Oreo pie, employees were friendly and amazing people 😊 definitely coming back soon

The food here is to DIE FOR. The service is also pretty good! They do use a self-serving system; they make, and you pick it up at a window. But honestly, it's not that bad. The window is right next to the seat's making easy to announce your food and to pick it up. Personally, I felt that the clam chowder was kind of lacking clam. But it was still delicious.

We ordered everything and it was all great. Kids had fun playing with other kids on the playground.

Timoti's Seafood Shack is a hidden gem! This no-frills spot packs a huge punch with incredibly fresh seafood dishes. The flavors are fantastic - whether you try the blackened catch of the day or their delicious fish tacos, you won't be disappointed. Plus, the outdoor patio with picnic tables makes for a perfect casual meal, especially if you have a family. Highly recommend for anyone seeking a taste of the sea!

Excellent, friendly staff….all food was fresh and prices were beyond surprisingly low compared to this day and age elsewhere. A must try for lunch. Super fish taco. And you must try the Key Lime in a cup as well.

Best place in town for fresh seafood lunch and a beer.

This is hands down my favorite place to eat on the while island. Every town needs one.

Great food and perfect place to go with the kids!!!

I like the food here, I would definitely try this spot again. Good prices. The only thing I didn’t really like was the poke bowl. It was lacking fish. Everything else I had was good. I liked the fried green tomatoes and I am happy to finally try some. I will be back soon.

Great outdoor atmosphere with amazing fresh sea food.

Everything was AWESOME! Lobster roll was overstuffed, fries hot, nice light breading on chicken tenders and the fritters were fried to perfection !!!

By far the best food on Amelia. Had to grab lunch on the way out of town because the day before was so good.

Great place to pop in for lunch! Fresh and delicious.

Great seafood at a reasonable price. Seating is outside which was fine. Fried shrimp basket was good.

This place is so good it’s affordable everyone is nice and funny makes me want to come back every single time which I do it has a nice playground suitable for kids ages probably 2-12 please come it’s the best downtown and maybe even on the island

Mediocre food and the playground had a dirty diaper in it

Went with family on Saturday before Mother's Day. We had attempted several times to eat here but always very busy! We all got different types of baskets. They were so so very good and worth the wait! I'm looking forward to getting back soon!

Great food for great price. The guy at the counter was really nice and helpful and was smiling the all time to each costumer ( and it was a long and never ending line…!). My wife got the fish sandwich with blackened flounder fish because they were out of Mahi but she didn’t care and said the seasoning was so good that she didn’t care and it was yummy. I got the fried fish basket and it was yummy too. Even if you see a long line, don’t give up! It’s worth it! We will definitely come back to try more from their great menu!

Definitely a stop if you’re in the area. Great hush puppies and shrimp tacos.

Very casual dining, good food, comparable prices. The staff goes above and beyond, very pleasant all round.

Wasn't very clean. There's only outdoor seating. Not accessible to people that can't walk.

Awesome little spot. Outside seating only. Has a cool little playground that stays mostly shaded. All of our food was excellent and the staff was laid back and friendly.

Excellent fresh seafood! We had the T wrap with fried shrimp. Choped Salad box with grilled Mahi, cucumber salad and key lime pie cup. Everything was fantastic. We arefrom Florida and thjs was some of the best quick casual seafood we've ever had. We even went back the next day. Great job Timoti's, we wish we lived closer!

I come here to dine in and escape the heat. Hands down the best fresh catch sandwich on the island. This week was drum. I got it blackened. It was phenomenal. I wish I came here for lunch everyday.

I am from New England, so when I saw lobster rolls on the menu, I was excited yet apprehensive since I have had less than great lobster experiences outside of New England and in Florida in particular. I ordered them regardless, and let me tell you . . . .I came back the next day and had them again! So buttery, yet light and refreshing and the price!!!! You couldn't beat it. I also ordered them with a side of calamari with fresh sqeezed lemon, and I felt complete 😀 I seriously considered moving to Fernandina beach after my 2 days there. Definitely try this place.

They always have a fresh catch, fried or grilled, Delicious. I have had there sandwiches and tacos and the fries are awesome .

I got a poke bowl and it was literally just rice, tuna and lettuce. Meh. My husband got blackened and grilled shrimp which was better. It’s basic, probably wouldn’t eat here again.

UPDATED 2ND TRIP MAY 7 2024: EVEN BETTER THAN BEFORE!! UPDATED 2024 MENU ATTACHED. Looking for Fresh Flounder fried just right? Timoti's has it, lightly breaded and so HOT you have to wait to take a bite. Flounder w/ cocktail sauce, French Fries, slaw and hush puppies will fill you up. I tried the Seafood Soup and it was chocked full of delicious morsels of shrimp, fish and vegetables in a light tomato sauce with a pack of oyster crackers. Hard to find fresh fried flounder and so gratifying when you you get exactly what you came for. Do check out the current MENU and Pricing photo taken AUGUST 2022 as inflation takes its TOLL. Order inside and $erve yourself at the pickup window and sit at SUPER SIZED Picnic Tables $aving money as No Server to Tip. Everything was good - Big serving of thick Flounder, Slaw, Hushpuppies, French Fries, cocktail sauce, Iced Tea. I was stuffed. Your turn. Larry

Absolutely delightful! The perfectly grilled shrimp had a succulent texture and a heavenly smoky flavor that was simply irresistible. Paired with the crisp, refreshing coleslaw, it created a harmonious balance of flavors and textures. A must-try for any shrimp lover!

Great food, great place. Portions are a bit on the smaller side though

We’ve had Timoti’s twice in different years. It’s good but not fantastic.. it’s not something I would eat often or crave if I lived in the area. The first time I had the blackened shrimp basket and liked it well enough. This last time I had blackened shrimp taco (wish it had less beans and more of the other toppings), New England chowder (I actually ordered seafood stew and was given the wrong thing but didn’t know until already left with to go order/ chowder was bland), and hushpuppies (tasted pretty good but borderline burnt). Both times we went there was no seating available and a line so other people must think it’s fantastic.

The gentleman taking orders was smiling and made each customer feel welcome. The food was delicious. We had a crab cake without the roll, a poke’ bowl, and vodka lemonade. Everything was perfect. The crab cake was loaded with tender crabmeat, and the tuna was very good. We shared a picnic table with a group. Everyone was eating, and enjoying their lunch.

Fried fish, seafood stew, poke. I would recommend this place for a good lunch spot.

Food was good. I don't like seafood so I had chicken that was good. Wife loved the seafood.

On N. 3rd St, Fernandina Beach, FL. Good seafood choices at fair prices, shaded outdoor seating only and some beer choices. Public parking across the street. Baja boxes with grilled shrimp/tuna (10.99 each) were very good.

Food was alright. Had the fried shrimp, fried oysters, and lobster rolls. Nothing special about the shrimp or oysters. The hush puppies were dry and tasteless. The lobster roll was massacred to the point it looked like it was tuna salad. Couldn’t tell if any chunks of lobster existed at all. The red onion completely overpowered the lobster to where you can’t taste it at all. On the positive side, the fries were well seasoned.

When your fried shrimp has a taste that is so good that it doesn't need tartar sauce nor cocktail sauce then you have hit that Mark of seafood perfection. And this place has it!

First time here based on recommendation. Did not disappoint. Excellent service, excellent atmosphere. Excellent food. Definitely will return!

Crab burger was killer. Low key. Picnic table outside siting.

Other than 2.99 for drinks not mentioned, everything is great. Like the squirrel mascot/floor cleaner.

The food selection is great and they honor military discounts! They could use more seating.

We loved the lobster rolls & clam chowder!!!

Great people and service and plenty of big shrimp in the shrimp basket meal. Hushpuppies and fries were really good too, and free drink refills. Will definitely be back!

Love this place. Seafood so fresh, sandwiches and baskets always fantastic. You might even met some new friends at the shared picnic tables.

Timoti’s is an outstanding local restaurant and has exceptional food & atmosphere. My favs are the tuna poke bowl & blacken catch of the day sandwich….along with locally caught fried shrimp (best fried shrimp on the island). Crazy good.

From the perspective of someone allergic to shellfish, the food was really good and fresh for land lovers. The chicken tacos were great. Everyone else really enjoyed their lobster rolls and wraps, shrimp po boys, and crab burger. Counter order and some picnic table seating outside. Kids playground onsite.

I had a lobster roll. The lobster had a squishy, unappetizing texture. If you want lobster go to Mason's instead.

Simple and unique dishes that hit the spot with robust flavors

The customer service was fantastic and the tacos were delicious!

Great service. Food was good, not great but I'd come back and try somethint new. Playground for the kids in nice. There is no indoor seating, bur plenty of benches outside.

We visit this place every time (multiple times!) we visit Amelia Island. Affordable food that is delicious, lovely staff, and a beautiful outdoor seating area. If weather is poor, take your food to go - there are no indoor seating options. Outdoor seating is protected from overhead sun. Playground for the kids adjacent to the seating so kids can play while parents eat. We recommend the fish sandwich, fish basket, and the impressively sizable caesar salad!

Recommend the flounder and cucumber salad. Deliciousness. Only outside seating. Service was quick and efficient. The day was a little chilly, so I would have preferred eating inside - not Available.

Rubin was very as was the pottaba. I consider myself a potato salad snob Timoti's is excellent.