Amish Creamery Co in Madeira Beach - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

Clint the owner is the sweetest. The ice cream is about 5x better than any other ice cream in this area… it’s DELICIOUS. We Re locals and are newly obsessed. I wouldn’t go anywhere else for ice cream. Highly recommend.

Sadly have to rate this establishment two stars after multiple years of visiting with family on yearly beach trips due to the ridiculous price increases. Over $8 for a single scoop of ice cream is far too much. Perhaps some of the most expensive ice cream I’ve purchased and I can’t say that it tastes like it. Service is still good and it’s fine ice cream but cannot recommend with its current prices.

Might be the best ice cream I’ve ever had in my life - the banana flavour was life changing 😍

Do your self a favor and head to candy kitchen. This place is far from Amish. 12 dollars for two scoops of melted ice cream. All the ice cream looked melted and refrozen.

All the ice cream is freshly made. The staff was cheerful and we talked a lot while he offered us samples and then made our treats. The blueberry cheesecake ice cream was out of this world. I’ve always hated cheesecake ice cream but this one is amazing. The butterscotch explosion ice cream is very unique too. I’ve never had butterscotch ice cream & this one was loaded with all sorts of yummy mix-ins. The store doesn’t have a place to sit down or dine inside though which is a shame. They offer plenty of their ice cream flavors to go by the pint and quart. They sell a few other Amish offerings too like jams & cookies.

Delicious ice cream, one of the best milk shakes I’ve had and super friendly service. Definitely must try if in the area.

No place to sit inside just FYI, but SO WORTH stopping on the way to/from the beach. It was so good!

We have tried every ice cream place in Madeira - nothing compares to this!!! Absolutely incredible homemade ice cream !!

Great ice cream!! Looks closed from the outside but its not.

The ice cream is exceptional - and super friendly service.

Every flavor was so delicious! We got a total of 8 flavors. The owner served us and he was very friendly, shared the history of the store and the ice cream.

everything was amazing PLEASE TRY THIS PLACE!!!! instead of going to some of this more seen ice cream places u absolutely have to try this one!! the service was amazing, everyone was very friendly. the building was clean and neat and the ice cream… man.. the ice cream was OUTSTANDING. very rich and creamy, tons of flavors as well to choose from. give this place a try

Great place! Super nice people!

Best homemade ice cream compared to the other top rated places we went in the area.

Great flavors of ice cream, highly recommend! The consistency and creaminess is hard to beat in my opinion. If you're looking for super cheap and low quality ingredients, you'll want to skip this place.

Elite ice cream and great service

Deliciously creamy and a wide variety of flavors They serve Yoder's homemade out of Sarasota and regularly refresh the supply. The only downside could be the price - not the MOST expensive around, but high quality demands top dollar.

Love this place!! We go back every year that we’re in the area for spring break. Our whole family looks forward to it. Best ice cream in the country! (And we’ve tried A LOT) Excellent service too, the owner of frequently there scooping.

I recently had the pleasure of visiting Amish Creamery Co., and I must say, it was an unforgettable experience. From the moment we stepped in, Clint's customer service was nothing short of exceptional – a solid 10 out of 10. Not only did he make us feel incredibly welcome, but he also took the time to share insights into his culture and the art of crafting their delicious ice cream. Clint's warmth and kindness truly shone through, making us feel like part of the family. Learning about the Amish culture added a unique and enriching layer to our visit, making it more than just a stop for ice cream. Speaking of ice cream, let me tell you, it was phenomenal. Finding both delicious and genuinely healthy treats can be challenging, but Amish Creamery Co. nailed it. Every scoop was a perfect balance of flavor and quality ingredients. But what truly sets this place apart is Clint himself. His genuine care for his customers and passion for his craft make Amish Creamery Co. a true hidden gem. I left with a full heart and an even fuller belly, eager to spread the word and support this wonderful business. Thank you, Clint, for an unforgettable experience. Your kindness and attention to detail truly made our visit special. I wholeheartedly recommend everyone to support Amish Creamery Co. – not just for the incredible ice cream, but for the outstanding service and warm hospitality.

Ice cream is the best I've ever had. Ask for a receipt when paying with a credit card, the guy that works there is not the best with charging the correct amount.

Best ice cream ive ever had. The chocolate fudge brownie and peanut butter and jelly are so good

Ice cream is one thousand percent the best ice cream I’ve ever had (banana pudding flavor is TO DIE FOR). You can taste the authenticity in every bite. My husband and I love running into the owner Clint during our visits, he’s the nicest guy and really cares about every customer’s experience! One of a kind place for sure

Very busy but the girl working handled it well

Wonderful real ice cream. Very friendly staff.

What a hidden gem this place is. The blueberry cheese cake ice cream in a waffle cone was the best part of my day. They use fresh blueberries and big chucks of actual cheesecake. Truly fresh homemade ice cream. I’ll be returning many more times. Thank you!!

100/10 definitely recommend to anyone in the area!! me & my fiancé stopped in after the beach and was amazed by the many options you have in everything, the sodas are delicious as well! great quality 🩷

The egg sandwich was amazing and a great price. Thank you for the meal!

Awesome friendly staff! Biggest perk is I can get real Amish butter.

I absolutely love this place!! One of the best ice cream that I have ever had. A must visit when traveling to Clearwater.

Incredible selection of ice cream flavors. Really friendly staff, and a pretty great location! Was so tempted to grab some Cinnamon Buns, Cookies and other delicious items in stock! Can’t wait to come back here.

Delicious! Nothing else to add! Come here and enjoy your icecream!

The best ice cream in the area. Great staff too!

This is THE BEST ice cream I have ever had! I had mocha almond fudge and a vanillin ice cream with peanut butter and peanut butter cups in it. Fantastic. I would have given it 10 stars if I could. You would probably miss this place if you didn’t know it existed. Just a little hole in the wall place but it’s about .4 miles away from the Madeira beach parking lot. The only negative was that it doesn’t have any indoor seating but it did have two benches nearby. In the evening time, the benches area shaded.

Really great ice cream. The man there was super friendly and nice to talk to. We will definitely be back. Try the Blueberry Cheesecake Ice Cream!!!

Best ice cream I’ve had in my life! I dream about the praline pecan

The ice cream was very good. Very rich. They have a lot of different flavors. I think I was the only one in our group that didn't get a good one. I don't recommend the pistachio... It was melty and the nuts were soggy. The fudge brownie was incredible and so we're all the other flavors my group got. We would definitely go again! Be aware, this may be a local thing, but what they call a Double is what most places I've been call a Single. There is also nowhere inside to sit and eat so you'll be standing around in the parking lot or in your car.

Hands down best ice cream in town. You don't want to miss this place when visiting.

Yumm. Great place for ice cream! I had Banana Crunch and Razzle Dazzle (raspberry ice cream with chocolate pieces and cups). They were delicious. Locally made in Sarasota at Yoders creamery. The service was great and they happily gave us multiple samples! Don’t skip this place if you want ice cream on your St Pete vacation!

Fantastic selection. 1st class service (thanks to Clint) and very good prices. One of the highlights of our holiday so for.......

The ice cream was out of this world! The prices are reasonable, and the shop contains items that are authentic amish from our local state of pennsylvania. The owner was very kind and engaging, and the shop was clean and well organized. It's definitely worth a visit! 😎👍🇺🇲

Literally the best ice cream i have ever had. Not exaggerating in the least bit. Get the banana split and tip well.

Best ice cream I have tried. So many options and all are delicious. I'll definitely come again.

Amazing ice cream best around. Nothing compares. Nice owner.

Great service, really good ice cream, decent price. Thank you!

The banana pudding ice cream is to die for!! Never had anything like it.

Sooo many flavors to choose from. Delicious.

A little pricey for what you get and the location is not great. The ice cream was good.

Great ice cream. Great staff. Generous portions and ki d to all who walk in.

Best ice cream in town.. . . Still the best ice cream in town. 2/5/23

Amazing prices great owner very friendly