Amore Italian Market and Bakery in Cape Coral - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

This is one of the few places I crave. I've always gotten my food to go. Their Italian sub is the best and their cookies are delicious! They never disappoint and I look forward to trying more things.

Always good food, and deserts. Never disappointed

thank u guys, everyone was very friendly and the food very delicious!❤️❤️

Ordered a Italian sub didn't last long so no picture

Everything is fresh and tastes really good!

I've been to this place a few times. Few times I had food to eat and some times just ordered pastries to go. I met the ownere ones, we had a nice conversation. We also bought imported flour there before. Last experience was unpleasant to me, we ended up just paying for the food we ate and not ordering pastries to go (I take GF ones usually) bc one woman was rude to me. Upon asking a guy who was helping us what are the ingredients in some GF pastries he referred to her as he didn't know. She rolled her eyes and with the smirk just mumbled something like "it's gluten free". I was stumbled by this approach like I was asking stupid question. The guy eventually showed me the pack of that flour that being used and I just couldn't pass this rudeness. This is humiliating and unacceptable. We didn't take even the almond flour ones and weren't back there since then and we will not come back. Also the sign (that you have to find yourself as noone mentions it) says there is 3.5% charge to use a credit card but we always paid with debit and still were charged every time. Not sure if that is a disclosure issue or the store charging debit cards as it was credit. The food is good from what we had, not phenomenal.

The staff was super nice and welcoming. Everything we had was delicious!

So glad I found this place on our vacation. Great selection, it was hard to choose.

Omg the pistachio cannolis are to die for, I could not get enough! They fill them right there while you are buying them which keeps the shells super crispy and yummy. Everything else looked good and fresh. Absolutely recommend!

I give the food a 4 because I don't think I made a good choice in the sweets I chose, but they are well prepared and I think their sweets could be very delicious.

The team was baking but took the time to go and explain everything and answer any and all questions. The bakery was fantastic I really enjoyed the cream horn.

Very good bakery with a large selection of pastries all freshly made in house. The girl at the counter was extremely helpful and kind. Overall , great quality of food and the double shot espresso was well made.

Amazing profiteroles cake!! Couldn’t ask for a better birthday cake, thank you so much for make it happen.

We LOVE amore! Whether stopping in for a lunch sub, grabbing sweets, or ordering for an event, everything is absolutely delicious. We ordered the lemon blueberry mascarpone cake for our wedding cake years ago and all our friends still talk about how amazing it was!

Just likes back home! I am from New Jersey Italian sub is the closest. Great cookies .. Too !

Small Italian shop. Great mommas cooking and pastry are excellent. Everything home made onsite. Comfort and other types of food .wonderful selection. But price are bit steep

Called to order a Cassata cake...very NY and Ohio type cake. First question was "Are you from Ohio or NY?" Best question for a first impression! We are from Cleveland and they made a spectacular cake for my MIL 75th birthday!! Actually better than one from Little Italy in our area!! Thanks for asking that most important question!

AMAZING PLACE , THE FOOD THE SWEETS THE PEOPLE.. If you enjoy real home made Italian food an desserts this is the place. Thank yall so much...

I most say very impressed with staff and food. I ordered pastries for my father, over the phone cause I live in R.I. the young man that I spoke to was very helpful and patient with me. The food looked amazing and my parents thought they where getting just a piece of cake. They got a big surprise, I was very jealous to see that amazing box of treats. My father called to say thank you as he munched on a cannoli. Thank you

Not bad but not great, had much better. The lobster tail has the same as the canoli filling which is not to sweet. The eclair was pretty dry and disappointing. If you in the area and you anfan of Italian sweets it's worth stopping but I would go out of my way......

Chicken cutlet sandwich and broccoli salad, my go-tos. And don't forget the tiramisu. This place is incredible.

A great selection of everything. Bought desserts and had an espresso. Friendly staff.

Fun place to buy all the no-no foods you love.

Best Italian food in town. The desserts are super delicious. My favorite is the Lobster Tail.

We absolutely LOVE this bakery. It's a hidden gem we stumbled upon. The Italian cookies are made to perfection and their food is delicious. My Italian Inlaws are very picky about sauce and this is by far their favorite place to grab treats when they visit us. They also carry cakes, sandwiches, soups, pasta meals, oils, dry pastas, boxed and bagged to cook at home yourself...and More! They are Family run, very friendly and always helpful. We've ordered countless cookies for holidays and events and have never been disappointed. I Highly recommend this place to anyone looking for a little piece of Italian delight.

Great bakery and sub shop! Feels like a mom and pop shop. Never let down stopping in for lunch or dessert. Focaccia is great too

New to the area. Husband picked up cream puffs, tiramisu, and an Italian rum cake. The cream puff dough was soggy and tasted stale. The whipped cream filling tasted like crisco and left an oily film in the mouth. The tiramisu was okay but definitely could be better. The Italian rum cake tasted like a box mixed vanilla cake that was made days ago and was warm and not fresh. No rum flavor at all. I’m not sure if we will try anything else but we may. Service was great and they had lots to choose from!

The Italian Cannoli cake was very good! Will definitely be back to try other items.

First time being here. The cannolis just just been made

Great food and deserts! Service was great!!

I have lived in Cape Coral 2 yrs now never found good Italian pastry till now ..I took the advice of someone online to try so I went in for something small so not to be disappointed got Sfogliatella, a piece of Cannoli Cake and a couple of cookies ...not only was everything fresh flavor was on point ...while it's not a full bakery what the have is a definite must try I will be back for a bigger order lol because the fig cookies were to die for

Best home made pastry and Italian food

Amazing huge eclairs, cannolis, and Boston cream donuts! There's also an excellent selection of Italian snacks and ingredients. Best pastries in Cape Coral!

While visiting the area, we were in search of the best keylime pie for my FIL. I found this awesome bakery down the street from our rental. I bought the entire keylime pie from the family. It was the last day of our trip, and the last pie we would buy. It was prefect, the right amount of tart, sweet, gram cracker crust. The lime zest gave it that home made touch. All of their baked goods looked amazing.

Gluten free sweets are the best around!

Best Ever! I'm from Detroit and I went there three times in one week. Pastries, sub sandwiches, entrees everything was exceptional as were the owners and their staff. Can't wait to go back!

amazing staff & amazing food. 10000/10 🇮🇹 so glad I found this hidden gem of Cape Coral! 🤍

I found this Italian Market and Bakery on Yelp and I am so happy that I did. The service was excellent and everyone was attentive. The dessert was so delicious and I was o a sugar high after. Everything was so organized and clean, definitely recommend this bakery for the Italian experience.

So much deliciousness to choose from! Highly recommend the cannoli donut and the Italian crème cake!!

The best cookies and dessert, especially the cannoli

This is a great little place. The desserts they have are to die for, and the food is absolutely delicious

I go here once a month, it’s the next best thing to South Philly food. First off you can’t get Sandwich rolls anywhere in Florida like back home,However here they ship their rolls in from New York. So there’s that. Espresso is delicious. All of their salads, are amazing. Their hoagies are better than Bach home in South Philly. But my favorite is there desserts. Ones better than the next. Favorite Turtle Cheese cake. Simply amazing food, customer service, and the owner, always chats with you..

Got to say this is a hit and Gem oh my goodness never been here before in all the years that I've lived in Cape Coral definitely recommend . So got to say who came back and now trying to Italian sausage and peppers and onions and this place is amazing spoke to the owner and absolute wonderful person she is, she has very good work ethics the fact that she's here running it with the team that she has is awesome. Very happy with the Italian sausage and onion pepper sandwich.

Authentic quality Italian food, excellent customer service.

The best cherry chicken salad. I am not a foofoo chicken salad eater but this stuff is absolute deliciousness 😋 highly recommend

Never in my life have I seen such a variety of QUALITY pastries, cakes, pies, cookies, etc. I honestly didn’t know there were so many. They also have quite a selection of savory foods, as well. This place is so great that we got food to go from here 3 nights during our 1 week stay in Cape Coral. EVERY thing we tried was absolute perfection in taste and looks. And, if all this isn’t enough, everyone who waited on us was friendly and helpful. If I lived in Cape Coral I’d be 400 lbs!!

2024, like 5 years later, all remain as my first time. Sweet heaven sugar or not. I let you bring opinion back to me. Please 🙏 help my Goggle rating . Like, comment, and follow all plataforms #argeniusbiz

Soooooo yummy!! We will be back when we visit Florida.

Amazing hidden gem for delicious and authentic sandwiches, pastries, and meals. So many options and everything is delicious!! Highly recommend Alessia’s Turkey pesto sandwich and the key lime pie.

We were introduced to this place just days after moving to Cape Coral and we return on a regular basis. The traditional Italian cookies are irresistible. The home made pastas, sandwiches, baked goods... All fantastic!!! Be careful arriving hungry because you will inevitably leave with more then you need.

I attended an event where the cake was catered by Amore. It was a lovely pistachio cannoli cake! Having had such a good experience, I was excited to visit the store to try other desserts. Upon eating the cakes later that evening, the outer layer of each cake had a slight plastic taste. I see another review mentioned that many of the desserts had a freezer burn taste. I believe they need to have their bakery/deli case serviced. It’s the only reason I can think of that a catered cake was delightful but the slices you can buy have a sort of chemical/plastic taste on the outside. Example: I got a slice of the peanut butter cheesecake, the top layer of chocolate and the crust at the edge was plastic-y, but the bottom crust and the bottom couple of layers were great. Service was good, and many of the bites of cake I’ve had from amore have been great, but I felt the need to mention the odd flavor. I’ll keep amore in mind for catering, but unfortunately I don’t have many reasons to order a full cake.

We will never go to another deli. Better than publix me and my girlfriend are already planning are next visit. Thank you all for a incredible experience.

Best cheesecake I ever had! 5 stars!

The girl, Sabrina at the front was honestly the kindest person I’ve encountered as far as going to restaurants there’s anyway to give her a Raise you definitely should. Prime example beautiful young lady who knows how to work

The Best Italian Deli in Cape Coral. Food is absolutely fantastic! Desserts are magnificent! Staff are super friendly! If you don’t visit this place, you are missing out. Will definitely be back when I am in town!

The best Key Lime Pie hands down.

Unbelievable food!! People are always nice! Real Italian bakery!!! Best in cape! Cookies, cake, Unbelievable subs!

The best chicken parm sub I have ever had. I had to come back the next day and get it again. The service is top notch, unbelievable pastries to bring home for dessert later on as well. 10/10 recommend going if you haven’t already!

The food at this place is amazing! Their Italian sandwich is the best and made fresh in front of you! I would definitely come back here any day!

Love Amore! The cheesecake is so good and service is amazing!!

Delicious sandwiches amazing 👏 food 😋

Awesome gem in Cape Coral. Focuses on great quality foods and the services always great.

Sunny days so brisk and sweet Amores is the place to eat. Miles and miles of sandwiches & smiles. I tried the Daniela special which is truly as amazing as she is. Specialty hand crafted sandwich made with premium roasted ham, Swiss cheese, mayo, vinegar, spicy pickled pepper relish and lettuce. If your looking for a perfect mix of sweet and spicy you have to go see Daniela and the rest of the crew. Don’t forget to grab a variety of delicate delightful deserts on the way out.

Great location right off of Cape Coral Parkway and Chiquita. I really like the pistachio cream, cannolis and lobster tails. The premade lasagna is great for a quick dinner after a long day at work. They also have a wide variety of cookies that are absolutely delicious.

such a nice little spot! HUGE variety of freshly made pastries and breads. We tried the cannoli cake and the salted caramel banana cheesecake and loved them both - highly recommend!

Good food and friendly but people behind the counter were not that knowledgeable about what they were selling.

I always wanted to try arancini, so I cruised on down to Amore's. The food was excellent and staff was helpful. Will be back.

Their Italian sub is large, full of meat and delicious. The seasoning, oil & vinegar were spot on and the bread is freshly baked and awesome. One of the best subs that I've had. The Italian sub was so good that I'll be back consistently.

The raspberry chocolate ganouche cake was moist and full of balanced flavors. The almond cookies and Linzer cookies were also outstanding. The three stars is for the Sfogliatelle which was burnt and had the taste and texture of day old burnt toast.

Great oasis of Italian deliciousness. With the drive out to west cape for sure. Subs are amazing as well.

Excellent selection ! Could of stayed there all day. Staff friendly and knowledgeable. Will be back soon !

This place is like Toys “R” Us for your mouth! Everything is amazing! I recommend the chocolate chip cannoli!

The food is really good and the ambience/staff are amazing! Love the music there too!

Ask for Brandon smith best salesman at Sutherlin Nissan of fort myers

Delicious. Check this place out.

Very good cannolis and the coffee beans weren’t burnt

This place is AMAZING moving here from New York I was skeptical on finding any bakery tasting like home and this place never disappoints! I ordered a peanut butter cheesecake and it came out better than I could imagine! This is a must try place and the staff is amazing every time

There are plenty of reviews of how wonderful the food is at Amore. Our review is to chime in on their amazing customer service. We called and spoke to Joann this morning hoping to get a basket of goodies delivered to a guest at our villa. She asked for our budget, made a call to their delivery partner, and called us back promptly. Within a few hours, they delivered a box packed with cookies, cannolis, and other Italian treats that our guests raved about. Exceptional customer service and can't wait to do business again with Amore

Always delicious everything I’ve had is amazing yummy homemade food and incredible pastry selections! Weekly I’m there omg fabulous staff also! Thanks for being so close and welcoming love every single bite yummy food 😋😋😋

Fantastic Italian market. Cookies were deeelicious!

Im vacationing in Cape Coral Fl, and the house we're renting has recommendations for local businesses. Me and my daughter decided to go get some pastries and we were not disappointed. Our favorites have cannoli cream in them. The cannoli cream was so smooth. It was the best cannoli filling we've ever had. They also had italian gourmet products. They make sandwiches there but we didn't order from that section. I can see someone in the back decorating a cake. If I lived in Cape Coral I would be in this bakery often. We plan to stop by again before leaving.