Bennington Pizza House in Bennington - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

When I called to order I was excited to found out that they had vegan non-dairy cheese as an option! The vegan pizza was delicious! Hopefully they'll add the vegan cheese as an option​ on the menu.

Ordered 3 subs. 2 Italian combos l,t,o,m and jalapenos, 1 turkey l,t,o, oil, rolls we're old and dry. Onions were rotten/lettuce was rotten. And they didn't put the jalapenos on the subs.this place used to be one of the best in town. Sad to see it go so bad.

NO A/C! Walked in and saw the amount of flies everywhere, because the doors are kept open, and walked out. Food preparation should be done in a more controlled environment. Leaving the doors open allows to many insects and dust.

Ordered the Arthur's pizza and it far exceeded my expectations. Maybe a little heavy handed with the peppers and onions but was top notch none the less. Delivered hot and ahead of schedule. Hats off and highest marks to the people down at Bennington pizza house. Definitely first class food.

Your pizza was so good . From sara

im from long island and know my pizza. trust me, this place is legit. had a slice broccoli, spinach, mushroom. fresh ingredients, delicious crunchy crust. prices are fair. i always come here when in bennington area

Our family favorite pizza shop!!! Looove the menu, everything is amazing and cooked with love 🖤

I ordered stuffed shells stuffed with ricotta cheese. I also got 3 sausage links. It came to just about $22! I got 3 stuffed shells buried in tomato sauce and mozzarella cheese. The sausage links were pretty good although I asked for HOT sausage and got sweet. For $22 it was definitely NOT worth it. It was all tomato sauce and I couldn't even see the shells the were drowned in sauce. Also the sauce was very greasy. You could see the grease floating on top. I won't be getting another pasta dinner at the Bennington Pizza House.. 3 stuffed shells!!

$17.95 for 2 topping Small pizza that's ridiculous going to stop going here!!

Don’t buy pizza from this place we ordered a pizza from here and it took a hour to get and it was burnt to a crisp couldn’t even eat it had to order from some other place to just eat this place is a joke seriously don’t order from here

Not a bad place for quick bite.

Food is good but not excellent. Average quality. Atmosphere in dining area since renovation is not as open or relaxing anymore

Very very disappointed in the food it used to be made very well .. now it looks like this burnt middle …

Horrble food,burned grinder salad was all yellow,garlic knots were dry n gross n tenders were processed n disgusting. Never again will we.order from there n also Will let people know

New to the area and being from Philadelphia our expectations were high. The pizza was excellent and will be coming back again!

Pizza and chicken Parm was excellent

Always amazing service my favorite pizza in town and they don't skimp on the toppings!

The Ceasar salad tasted great! Service was even better! But the atmosphere was a bit too unclean for me.

Owner personally delivered the pizza’s in less than 30 minutes. Quality way amazing and service was A+

Nice little pizza joint in the middle of it all. Great for a quick bite (subs, calzone) while walking around downtown. Good size pizzas to go. Chef's kiss 👨‍🍳😘

Worse antipasto salad ever! Pizza isn't horrible but it's not very good either.

I ordered an Italian sub it literally comes with 3 thin pieces of meat and topped with lettuce. Never ordering from here again. Even subway packs a sandwich better. After I called and asked if they made a mistake the owners son was disrespectful about the whole deal.

The best pizza anywhere! Excellent customer service. You will not be disappointed.

Delicious food - huge servings!

This place has the best GF pizza! I was recently told (by an owner?) that they will be making an even BETTER GF pizza, as they have a new GF ingredient that's even better. Can't wait to try!!

Thicker than NY style pizza, good crust and, previous owners had great sauce. Good pizza and salads. Update to 2023. Bland sauce, undercooked. Mentioned it to Bethany, owner. She said, "order it well done." oh well, looking for a new pizza joint.

Ordered the pastrami grinder. It had 2 dried out pieces of pastrami on it. Disappointed.

Our favorite pizza place was closed, so decided to go to Bennington Pizza House. 1st off the guy that answered the phone sounded like I just woke him up. Not impressed. He said 25 to 35 minutes. Picked it up in 30 minutes. Got home pizza was luke warm and burnt. Won't be going back anytime soon.

Pizza doesn't get better than this.

Meatball sub was delicious, my cold grinder was also great

Best crust in town..A little on the greasy side but I like it that way.

Place is the best in town must get....better to get delivered or rske out as seating area has been vastly reduced...... so worth it

We ordered a large pizza with many toppings, although the pizza was okay, but it became inedible because of water/liquid dripping from it? I'm not sure what happened. Maybe it was from all the veggie toppings?

Always friendly quick and we LOVE the Monday night pizza deal I personally think its the Best pizza place in town

Smelled of cigarettes as soon as I walked in the door. The restaurant had garbage all over the floor and a dead fly stuck to one of the pictures. It was $60 for a salad, small pizza and 2 sandwiches. Highly disappointed!

Not very good. We went on a Monday night, the website lists as dine-in but it's really just 3 very tight tables in the front. The pizza was not great; very greasy and crust was undercooked. The staff was good, they worked quickly and were courteous. Wouldn't go back.

10/10/22 Pretty decent pizza. I wasn't crazy about the chicken wings, they weren't crunchy. Good place o stop just the same.

Quite an unassuming place, the interior is a bit dated and could use some sprucing up, but the pizza was very tasty and staff very friendly.

I’ve never had bad food here until the past few recent orders. I’m not sure if it’s new owners or management, but the quality of food has taken a dive. The pizza (pic) was so burnt, it looked, tasted, felt and smelled as though it caught fire before someone put it in the box. The consistency of the stuffed shells was like a warm pudding goo covered with a burnt, hard layer of cheese. I hope someone steps in and makes some positive changes here.

This used to be my go to place for Pizza years ago. Not sure what has changed with them but wow, I ordered an extra cheese, extra sauce pizza last night and it was not even close to the quality I used to receive.It was dry, bland and tasteless. The cheese was oily and tough, and the sauce was so thin you couldn’t taste it.

Glad to have Bennington Pizza House back. Generous portions an Friendly Staff..

The only place in town that knows what extra extra cheese is... Love their pizza 🍕

Love this place. Monday night special pizza prices you cannot beat. This restaurant recently had an electrical fire in kitchen and is closed temporarily. Miss them so much. Can't wait for reopening. Very nice owners n workers.

Very delicious food and friendly staff.

A great family owned pizza shop. They got lackluster reviews on Yelp but I suspect it is all the pizza snobs from NYC coming up for vacation. I got the veggie pizza and it was smothered in veggies, they definitely do not skimp on the toppings here. If you are in the mood for pizza this is your spot. Stop in to the pub next door for some delicious Vermont beer to go too while you are in the area.

Both my husband and I both ordered Chicken Parmesan subs and dined in the shop. They were delicious. Service was friendly and it was nice to get out of the cold into a warm spot.

Great pizza, great people. Always friendly and a wonderful part of our community.

Amazing food and better service.

Good salads. Service was very fast. Pizzas are great

Glad I listened to everyone's advice, this is definitely the best pizza in Bennington!

So, I order the same thing every single week, a BLT, light tomato, extra bacon, extra crispy and let me tellll you, every single time, without fail, my sandwich is PERFECT! like,.I couldn't make a better BLT myself. You guys rock! 🤘

Great pizza and you can order by the slice. Plus many other Italian dishes.

I have only experienced the take out pizza being delivered to my work place. Ok pizza. The only real thing I can say about them is.... The delivery person just left the pizza and never waited to receive their tip??? Both times I ordered... I even told the person answering the phone that I would give a tip upon delivery. I am only saying this because I know there is a cost for delivery on the driver

A great place for pizza & dinners Excellent food & prices

The pizzas and calzones here are excellent, even the smallest sizes are more than enough to be a full meal.

We were faithful pizza plaza people, then we got a few not so great items and decided to try main Street pizza house! Omg their dough is delicious 😋 and the pizza is always smooth good always perfect amount of sauce and cheese that is my favorite part

Excellent meatball sub tonite. Very good

They'll mess up your wing order and they taste like they are boiled and seasoned instead of grilled or fried then seasoned (this is coming from a prep cook)

At the moment they are not requiring customers that come into their establishment to wear masks or follow covid safety protocols. This is a violation of state regulation and local ordinance, but it can be dangerous to enforce. Staff all follow protocols and their remodel is great for covid safety but some customers ignore. Pick up at your own risk or order take out if you're able. Food is delicious. I think it's the best pizza in town.

Very good pizza. Ready on time & delicious.

Really like the people that work here, super friendly. Pizza is pretty decent too!

Very good food. Best pizza in town. Good prices. Great calzones.

We had the best sub that we have had in a very long time.

So good! Tried for first time after living in area for awhile. Delivered quickly and left right at door, earlier than expected, even during covid pandemic. My new fav pizza place, crust is perfect!

They're friendly, fast and the pizza is better than the others in the downtown.

Old fashioned Pizza house. Only thing missing is the arcade games

Driving through from out of town ...amazing pizza. Delicious well cooked crust. Great sauce. Plentiful toppings. Reasonable price. Polite staff. Clean facility. Overall excellent experience.

Small cozy restaurant, great pizza.

Best pizza I have had in a really long time. Quick service, friendly staff. Will find an excuse to go there more.

This place is good, lots of options beyond pizza

Both nights were filled with friendly service. Highly recommend.

Very good! Highly recommended! Small, so not much seating space.

I went in and the young lady at the counter today was wicked awsome. She got me a nice roast beef sub and cracked a couple jokes . The sandwich was , wicked pissa . I hadn't one like it since the eighties. Love the tatoos all over. I think i will call her to let her know

Easy to order from online using Slice. Food arrived hot and delicious within the advised timeframe.

On the way back home from a weekend in VT my sister and I stopped in to give VT 🍕 a try. Other than it being a little oily, it was quite tasty. I've had similar tastes in Brooklyn as well. In think they need to switch to a better quality, low moisture cheese. It shouldn't be that greasy. Sauce had a little sweetness to it which I like and it had nice crust. Also, the slices were pretty big. That's a bonus!

We were visiting from new Jersey for a day. We asked what was around for food and the hotel said try here. We did. The pizza was fantastic. We normally do not get pizza out of our area since it is not good. This was as good as the pizza from home. It is the normal pizza place. Nothing special inside, but good pizza

Pizza was really good and so was a calzone

My husband likes to get the eggplant parmesan grinder...sooo big and yummy. I get the gluten free pizza. It is actually edible :). So many pizzas I have had at other places taste like cardboard. It so nice to get a "real" pizza that tastes good.

Amazing crust! Almost bagel-like, in the best possible way; soft and chewy inside, outside tiny crispy bubbles like a fresh hot bagel.

Got a large pizza. It was huge and yummy!

Everything is always cooked correctly. Delicious. Hardest part is figuring what you want from their vast affordable menu.

Thanks for letting us enjoy Larry's graduation everything was perfect and food was delicious 👌

Great place and pizza, if you can keep the hot toppings from sliding off of the slice!

Really good pizza. The crust is kind of sourdough-y, and has just right amount of play in between firm crispiness on the outside and chewy softness within. The pizza might have been a little light on the red sauce, but that could also just be my preference kicking in. The ambiance is local hole-in-the-wall style, but with updated furnishings and fixtures. A nice balance on all accounts.

Very family-oriented very generous portions everything is very fresh good value

Great Ny style thin crust pizza! They also offer Gluten free options which is nice considering the high volume of people who suffer from a Gluten allergy! Highly recommended!

Awesome place to have lunch. My sister and my Mother went there to eat before my sister went to Georgia. She treated us to lunch there which I have never been there. It was wonderful food. I recommend everyone to check it out, you will love the food. Customer service was awesome.

The pizza is very good! The crust is a perfect balance of crunchy and chewy. The cheese is good, the spices are great. The sauce is okay and doesn't detract from the overall taste. The restaurant itself is spacious and cozy. I would definitely eat there again.

We get pizza here regularly and have only had one issue and the manager went over the top to make it right.

Great pizza!! And that's coming from someone who doesnt typically like pizza

My favorite pizza, always delicious and made right!

Got a hot Italian. It was good. Pizza is always tasty.

I havent lived here in years..but i come up every once in a while to see my father since i went to florida in 86..ann maries was the best hands down..i tried ramuntos a few times and it was good..we went there tonight and they were too packed..we gave the pizza house a try and hands down best pizza in bennington now...great food and service..i will be back..

Friendly atmosphere, gluten free pizza, avoid eggplant grider

Best pizza in town. Established in 1968.

We ordered pizza a few hours ahead, requested a delivery time of 6:00pm and Ryan arrived at 5:55pm! The pizza quality was honestly the best pizza we've had in Bennington in a long time! On top of everything else, we live in an area where most food delivery advise that they don't deliver to us. When I called there was no question, they come to our neighborhood. Excellent service and excellent pizza!

Great tasting pizza. A little pricey, but not bad.

Love this place..Good food, friendly service, and inexpensive exp on Mondays..They make the best subs and Calzones...The family is so nice and inviting

It's hard to find good pizza this far from NYC. Bennington Pizza Main St, is the best in town.

Very tasty Pizza, reasonably priced.