CONEHEADS CARIBBEAN ICE CREAM - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

The Girl Scout: Coconut Icecream, Hot Fudge, Caramel & Graham Cracker Pieces. This normally comes with 3 scoops of icecream in a boat style dish. I asked for 2 scoops as I wasn't that hungry. This had a flavor profile so similar to the Samoas/Caramel Delites. Oh, my goodness this was so awesome. A bit on the heavy side, but delicious nonetheless. Service with a smile and very welcoming. Plenty of parking and seating too.

Really great little place. Excellent float sundaes! Lots of options and plenty of parking. There's a nice little wine store next door as well.

Great little ice cream shop not far from Verona Beach State Park with lots of flavors within view of Oneida Lake. Fun treat if you’re driving through the area on a summer evening.

Delicious ice cream with a ton of flavors to choose from. This is a must place to stop during their summer open months if you are in the area!

Great hard and soft ice cream. Sometimes there might be a line but service is fast and polite. Will be going again.

The young lady that serve us, Natalie, was professional, friendly and quick. We will be back to visit this wonderful establishment again!

Best ice cream Oneida and the one near Sylvan beach. Always look forward to when they open. So much to choose from. My husband and I are watching our sugar and calories. The kids cone is just enough to satisfy. Treat ourselves almost weekly in the summer.

Toasted coconut or Cannoli Hard ice cream all the way. Super yummy 😋

Great ice cream at great prices also

One of our favorite places to visit! Great prices and great products!

Just had the Grass Hopper Boat. If you love chocolate and mint, this is definitely the sundae for you!!! Delicious 🍧🍨

love this place so much! great flavors and good portions.

Ice cream boats are bomb. You'll hem and haw but literally, just get the boat. They are life changing delicious.

I loved thus place was our first time there and it was great friendly quick service will definitely visit again

Lots of flavors to choose from. Very friendly staff. It's usually not mobbed like some in the area. It's our go to ice cream place

The store has views of Oneida Lake, with many varieties of sundaes. The Monster sunrise shake tastes like an orange Creamsicle.

Delicious ice cream, huge variety of flavours, toppings, and options, friendly and efficient staff, and great prices, especially for the amount you get!

Amazing ice cream and so many flavors to choose from.

Wasn't impressed. Basic run of the mill joint. Nothing fancy. Peanut butter boat was boring. Nothing bad just not anything that jumps out at you.

Very, very good ice cream. Friendly service!

Such a cute little place that has amazing ice cream and friendly staff. You can relax and see the lake from there.

Awesome service, great selection and unbeatable prices.

Just a wonderful experience there with warm, courteous and very obliging staff. We went a few times in very late Fall and they were still awesome, even when late people like us dopes show up 15 minutes before they close. A nice family business whom we gladly support! Kudos to each of you! -Mr Danny K

Good friendly service, great ice cream

Nice size ice cream. Very friendly.

They have my favorite Giffords Ice Cream flavor... Toasted Coconut! Best ice cream on the lake! Friendly service by happy people!

I love their ice cream. They got hubby's order wrong though, I blame the masks.

We love Coneheads Carribean. We had hard ice cream. Delicious. Lip smacking good.

Friendly, good prices, delicious!

Bavarian chocolate yogurt. Awesome

Better than I thought and better than the other ice cream shops in the area

Always great place to get ice cream, floats, sweet treats!! Friendly staff. Always clean.

Excellent, Please support your local economy 🏡

Great place amazing service butiful area and they don't skimp on the flavor or amount of icecream very affordable highly recommend will be coming back!

Great ice cream , attentive workers.

Best service and great selection of ice cream

We love going here. Ice cream is delicious, staff is friendly and our kids love to play in the sandbox.

Great deal medium cone was almost more than I could handle for only 3 bucks. Loved the little glass shop next door also.

Great service and great ice cream!

Good ice cream; many flavors,too...Oneida Lake area.

Nice and fresh. Everything was delicious. The server was very friendly and professional.

Very quick and efficient. Nice place to sit and watch the boats across the road from afar. Thanks 😊

We have been going to this Ice cream stand faithfully for 3 years we are there opening day and closing day every year our family really enjoys the prices and quality here keep up the great work and enjoyable ice cream we will always be loyal customers

great view - great prices - great hours - great staff & most importantly GREAT ICE CREAM!