El Pueblito Mexican Restaurant in Greeley - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

The place is small and clean, the quality of the food was not as expected, the prices are not so affordable compared to the chic quality of the food. It has little parking space, although it is enough because the place is small.

Love the margaritas and the family that owns it are so nice and welcoming

It was a great experience. It was like a mom and pop shop. The food was delicious. My kids are pretty picky when it comes to mexican food, but they loved it.

Food was good. Friendly service folks.

Decent value, friendly service and tasty food. Standard Tex-Mex menu in the Western U.S., but they know what they’re doing. Salsa has good flavor. Queso is decent. Clean men’s bathroom. We’ve eaten here about 4-5 times in the past two years. Always have an enjoyable experience. There’s a few TVs, usually playing soccer.

The food was really good but the service was lacking. Guacamole could have used a little salt. It was pretty bland. Chile rellenos and fajitas were great!

Very nice people and excellent food.

Food is delicious but oh my gosh the service is terrible! Sooooooo slow and they never came back for refills or ask how our food was. Tried this place twice and sorry to say we won't be back.

Food is not bad but worth the time to stop in once in a while to enjoy a nice time with family and friends.

The chicken was a little dry but the food was awesome!!

I was very disappointed in my last meal before heart surgery. The taquitos weren't bad at all but the cheese enchilada and the chile relleno were substandard in the extreme. Will not turn. At $25 for a late lunch, I was very disappointed.

I have not been in Greeley long, but all 3 times I've eaten here, this place has not disappointed! Food was great. I got the taco salad. Meat was delicious! They don't make it like this up in Oregon (where I came from). Only thing I wish is that their dining area was a little bigger inside the restaurant.

Food was great, service started great. I sat out on the patio. I finished half my plate and then went out to the parking lot to have a cigarette, if they came out to check on my table I didn't want them to think I was dining and dashing so I pulled some stuff out of my purse and left it on the table. I was going to take my leftovers home, and I was going to sit there with my drink and the chips while I continued to wait for my car to be done with its service. I stead when I came back to the patio everything was gone from the table. I went inside to get my stuff back and pay. I explained the situation and that I wasn't done with my food or drink and they never even apologized or offered me a discount.

Fresh and hot food! Delicious. Employees were friendly! Salsa and chips were good.

Our first time going n the food was amazing n we will be going back soon

This place was so good I can’t wait to go back no complaints fast service delish food!!!!

Delicious food, large portions, extensive menu, friendly staff, inviting dining area. Great Mexican food in Greeley.

Food was really good, staff was very friendly, they let you eat with out bothering you every 5 mins, and was there when we needed refills, the chips and salsa they serve first thing was good, the salsa had good flavor and not a lot of heat, everything came out to the table hot, looked and tasted amazing

It's always packed everytime we go there. Service s fabulous they try there best to getcha seated and waited on fast. Small but perfect foods in all of greeley!! Come try it out! U won't be sorry!

Love this place. Great food a great drinks

It closed at 9! Kind of early with margaritas that good.

This is one of may favorite restaurant's in town! Family owned and operated! First place we took our two children after we left the hospital when they were born and that says a lot about the family and the food!! Was just there for lunch. Place looks great. New tables new floor. Great staff great place!!

El Pueblito has been my favorite local Mexican spot for the last several years. They serve what is easily the best chile relleno I've ever eaten, plus great tamales, tacos, and everything else.

Yum! I got the #1 special with two chicken enchiladas and a beef taco. It was so good. I am a pretty harsh critic when it comes to Mexican food and I loved every bite. My husband had four enchiladas cheese, bean, and chicken he also liked everything he had. I super recommend giving it a try!!

Waiting time was less than 1 minute. The waitress was very attentive and went above and beyond to provide great service.

Best carne asada in town! Great service also!

It's such an hidden gem. The food was really good and they made mine a little smaller so I didn't waste food and it was perfect. I'll definitely be visiting again.

I got the chicken burito and it was extremely salty.

Food wasn't bad. Service was a little slow but the servers were nice. May go back

Pretty good ran family restaurant. good food

Very small restaurant but delicious and great service. Even though it is small the space is used well and there were plenty of seats even with a decent lunch crowd. Great food and we will definitely be going back here again.

The best place in town. Good food, good service. Great family place to eat .

An absolute joy to eat at this place, great food and great service!

I believe it's under new ownership/management, and it shows.

Very good food and good size portions. Awesome food.

I had a steak salad, and my wife had chicken enchiladas. Taste great, but nothing spacial.

Our favorite since they opened on 2001. Live in Windsor and drive to Greeley or Loveland. Only Mexican that we ❤️

Great place to meet our kids and have dinner! Quiet enough to have great conversations!! The food was excellent!

Wonderful Mexican restaurant with good vibes, fab service, and great menu. The only disappointment was that the takeaway boxes are made from Styrofoam which is the least disposible material.

This is the best Mexican food restaurant in Greeley. The only one we go to anymore. Food is fantastic and the service is good.

We love going to elpublito, the rice and beans are great. I love the tacos...the flavor is to die for. My wife loves the stuffed chilis. Prices are great....staff is wonderful

Had good food decent price large portions it was close to closing when we were there so possibly different in service earlier not as clean as I would like but tolerable

Love this place. Family oriented and always friendly.oh the food is great too!!!

The chef's creativity knows no bounds.

The food is incredible and a good price! I’ve been 3 times this year and it’s my favorite spot for Mexican food in town!

Sad to say we were very disapointed in the service and food we ordered. The menudo was so slimy from being over cooked it slid off the spoon. The sombrero Tacos were to salty, the service was so slow it took an hour to get our food and getting any refills on our drinks seemed like forever. They were not that busy and there was extra people working there. We usually go every two weeks but everything seems to be getting worse. Time to look for a different spot for our weekend out. Bring the original crew back.

I’ve eaten here quite a few times with friends and family. It’s been consistently good food and service.

My husband loved the food I did not like it at all had the carne asada it was overcooked and not seasoned the beans were just canned beans the guacamole was really good though

I really enjoyed the Quesadilla Rellena. It was quite delicious

Unimpressive. Two other places within walking distance have much better food, with more flavorful salsa. The waiter was nice, but other staff were less than friendly.

Never disappointed, always happy to eat there! You are treated as a family member and the food is always fresh and delicious!

The food was good but definitely felt like they were rushing us to leave like they had more people coming.

Food and service were great. I especially enjoyed the carnitas.

I love this restaurant. It’s been years since the last time I was there. The food is still amazing and the service is great!! I highly recommend

Best Mexican restaurant in town, hands down!!!

Everything is amazing this has been a gem for the last 20 years! 🔥

We moved to greeley in 2018, we tried this place because we love small Mexican restaurants. This place though, i have never eaten at a restaurant that i loved as much as el puebs, i know of at least 8 of my coworkers in Loveland who love it as well. I won't ever eat at a different Hispanic restaurant so long as el pueblitos is open.

I've only had the tortas but damn they are good!!

Delicious food. Freshly made. Yummy!

This is possibly the best Mexican restaurant in Greeley, Loveland or Fort Collins...everything is always great.

A group of ladies got together for lunch. We had a blast.

This one of my favorite places to go eat with my family favorite dish chicken fajitas rice and beans the best owners are super friendly I always remember this places to family and friends

Pick anything on the menu. You won't be disappointed!

Good food, friendly on the ball staff, large portions and a peaceful environment.

It was very mediocre food at best. The rice was dry. The burrito was just a fried tortilla with bland ground beef and cheese sauce that tasted like Velveeta with canned diced chilies. Like night and from the last time I went. I'm not sure that I will be going back. Especially with so many choices around there.

The cheese sauce is so good. I got the Alombra with chorizo. Fantastic.

Small place with really good food. Service was a little on the slow end for such a small place but you can easily overlook that by the friendliness of the staff. Overall great experience with good food friendly staff and decent prices.

Delicious food, friendly atmosphere, and good service.

1st time here for lunch. It was great. This is my new favorite Mexican restaurant in Greeley.

Absolutely the Best Authentic Mexican food by far!

I went last week and I was happy and sad at the same time. I was happy because of the price of the food, but I was sad to find out they charged me $ 5.00 for a side of guacamole and to be honest it wasn’t the best. It didn’t have the color I was expecting and the taste wasn’t that great either. I’d definitely go back but not buy anything extra…

I love this place great food friendly people been going there for over 15 years

Very friendly staff, fast service, great food!

Been going there for 8 years on regular basis. Always always delicious!

Years ago this restaurant had great food,atmosphere, and service now all 3 are very poor, not sure if it has changed ownership, if so than that is the reason why it now SUCK'S,FOOD,ATMOSPHERE, AND SERVICE

Nice people and the flavor was definitely there, however the meat had alot of fat. I personally can't handle eating fatty meat so I could only eat about half of one Taco. Also with the amount of sauce on the meat two tortillas instead of one would have allowed for easier eating. I don't believe I will return.

Had a 'to go' order. I received it at the time they said it would be ready. Well packaged which is great because I had to stop suddenly and the order fell off the passenger side seat. Nothing spilled! Great flavor! I have allergies so they cooked my food order special - just told them and they made everything just right. Great service! They did some upgrades. Beautiful atmosphere. Yes, they are wheelchair accessible. 5 stars!

Pretty good Mexican food, nice staff and good service. Was introduced to this place by some people from church and it is good. I have had better Mexican food, but it fits the bill for a nice place here in Greeley - which there are few. I will go back.

I've been here a few times and the food is okay. The rice isn't the best, and enchiladas are decent. The burrito was pretty good and filling. The service could be better (they seat you and forget you).

Honestly some of the best Mexican food I have ever had. Staff was very friendly and quick service even with a packed Friday night. Prices very reasonable - you'll get plenty to take home.

Came in, ordered take out, the waiter who helped me was friendly and professional. Their chips and salsa are the best 😋

Great food. I had the fajitas and would get them again!

I used to go there all the time, when I was younger, and things changed so much, wait staff forgot us, and I ordered a number 18, all they brought was the burrito never got my taco. And there flavors of there food taste like can instead of good Mexican.

Not a good experience. The chips were'meh', the salsa was tasteless, the guacamole was bad, tea was stale/tasted funky and the fajitas weren't very good. Would not recommend! Not sure how they got the rating they did, but they don't deserve it.

Great Mexican food. Our pastor recommended this restaurant as one of his favorite. The food was outstanding. I now have two favorite Mexican restaurants in Greeley.

Outstanding service and food was great as usual. They never disappoint us here

Third time at El Pueblito and I haven’t found anything on the menu that isn’t excellent. I’ve been eyeing the Lengua Asada and finally ordered it tonight. Tender and flavorful - the chimichurri added a great layer, but my daughter wouldn’t try the Lengua because she knew what it was. Guacamole was top notch and sopapillas to finish the meal off.

Wonderful experience, Great food! We will eat there again. Thank you

The food was ok. Service was ok. The place closes at 9pm. I do not want you looking at your watch as I walk in at 8:17. We were done before 9pm, bill paid and out the door! The bill had a charge of $1.64 for non cash payment. What?! This fee is to be paid by the mechand, not the customer. That's the cost of doing business. You can't tell me something costs $15 and than add a charge if i decide to pay with a card. At least be upfront about it if you want to really do that. If at least the food and service had been great i would not care but for an ok experience, this just made it worse.

Great tasting food friendly atmosphere 😋

Last time was great But this time there was to much fat in my burrito. I won't be back.

Dried out food yuk I'll never eat it again

Consistently amazing for years now. Great staff.

Always great service and they make a mean super burrito I've been getting there for over a decade! A great place to eat while in Greeley.

Delicious and safe for those who have Celiac Disease! 💯

Food is amazing!! The quesadilla rellena was one of the first things I had n after that I was HOOKED!!!!

I liked it, the burrito was very good.

This restaurant serves the best Mexican food. The owner and his family are hands-on business people. Great food and excellent service!

Good authentic Mexican food. Great friendly service.

Great vibe. Laid back crowd, large number of families enjoying the evening. Service was quick. Would recommend the Enchiladas Rancheros