Pie95 Pizza in Jacksonville - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

Took the pizza class- so much fun and learned a lot. Great place, fantastic pizza!

Best Pizza I’ve had in Florida!

Love this pizza. Always manage to eat a whole one. Everyone there’s super friendly.

JUST what I wanted! Savory sliced Italian sausage (like NY pizzarias)...Thin crispy dough...simple and fresh. I ordered one to go🤭

Traveled all the way from Atlantic Beach to see if this was as great as we'd read about. It did not disappoint and actually blew us away!! The crust is magical...light, chewy and crispy with a beautiful sauce. Tried the Margherita and Pepperoni pizzas and both were outstanding. Please set up shop at the beaches!!

Absolutely love! Amazing, fresh food all of the time! Owner & Staff are so welcoming and friendly. Truly a hidden gem.

Best Neapolitan inspired pizza in Jacksonville. I lived in Naples, Italy and Pie95 is one of the top five Neapolitan style pizzas I have had since moving back to the US.

Pizza was delicious and the flavor was almost identical to the pizzas I ate while in Italy.

10/10 best pizza in jacksonville hands down! such a great little neighborhood spot. the owner is rad and makes you feel like family. we love it and bring all our friends! you should too!

Pie 95 is a King Street favorite for me! I have loved everything I’ve ever had there from pizza to meatballs to wings and more. Indeed a hidden gem with amazing friendly service, you can’t miss with anything on the menu. Evan, the owner, is one of the kindest, most fun people I’ve known. We’re lucky to have this fantastic spot in the neighborhood!

This place never disappoints! Their food is always fresh and always delicious. Their Romantica pizza is one of my favorites and their meatball appetizer is delicious. You know they make everything fresh bc they run out of some things. 10/10 would recommend

Great customer service, the food was absolutely delicious and the owner was very cool too. We will definitely be frequent flyers. Love this place!

Some of the best pizza in Jacksonville, along with Bones. I lived in NYC for over a decade...and this is comparable with the likes of wood fired pizza like Paulie Gees and Roberta's.

Best pizza in Jax! Great owner and staff. Always kind and welcoming. 🥰 thank you!

Delicious pizza, fun atmosphere, amazing owners and staff!

Best pizza in town! Great service, awesome people and amazing food! You need to try it

The food AMAZING, the service top notch! Atmosphere friendly, engaging & extremely nice!!

What a great night. Family together for some pizza and went to Pie95. Some of the best pizza in Jacksonville by far. Walking in to see a cute and very clean restaurant, so inviting and such a warm greeting from everyone. The aroma of the wood fired oven we knew we were in for a treat. The three pizzas we had was light and crispy but with the perfect amount of chew. The Carnivore, the Fungi and the Margarita all were delicious. So hard to choose which one we like best. We also shared the meatballs, broccolini and the Arugula salad. Again all so delicious and presented in a way that they looked as great as they tasted. As if we needed any more the tiramisu was the perfect finish to our meal. Can’t wait to come back and try some of the other items on the menu.

Great food, all of the servers treat you like a regular, get the meatballs and sit on the patio, you’ll Love it

Literally greeted with warm smiles in a friendly atmosphere. These folks know how to make great pizzas. Recommend this pizza place to everyone I know. I can devour a whole pizza just myself!

Easily the best pizza in jacksonville and the best people. Loved it as a food truck and love it more as a sit down spot. The best!

My family and I love this place and the chef is very talented great place thank you Chefs.

We love these pizzas! We always get either the Carnivore, the Romantica, or the BBR (bacon, buffalo, and ranch) which is not on the menu so you have to ask for it - but it’s my favorite! The Arugula Caesar Salad with pine nuts is also great. Always ask if there is a special appetizer - they are always yummy! And the people are super friendly.The items mentioned above are the only ones we’ve tried so everything else on the menu is probably very good, too.

Pie95 is the best!! Their pizza is amazing! It’s fresh, the crust is chewy and light. The owners and staff are awesome. They have great taste in music and art too! I work in Riverside right on King street, whenever anyone asks me about food in the area I always direct them to Pie95. Nobody has been disappointed! It is a gem!! 💎 Get some!!!

Great pizza! Evan's specials are incredible, he has a history of working at some of the best restaurants, be sure to check this place out!

Best pie in Jax. Outdoor seating in the back.

Pie95 is the GOAT of pizza in Jacksonville! The first time I had their pizza was when they were a food truck at the Riverside Arts Market — immediately fell in love! Fell in love with it so much that we had them at our wedding. People still rave about the pizza from our wedding 3 years later. You can’t get better pizza than this! Top tier ingredients, flavor profiles that match perfectly, a really great dining atmosphere, and the friendliest staff! Bonus is watching them make the pizzas and seeing them cooked so quickly in the oven. Couldn’t recommend a place more!

Probably the best pizza you can get in Jacksonville. Nice flat wood burned crust! Tastes absolutely delicious. Only down side is their opening times which is later in the afternoon. Okay pricing for their pizza.

When I say “pizza”, y’all say “party”!! 🍕 🎉 I had the best experience at PIE95 PIZZA on King St. last Tuesday, June 13. I ordered the Bianca Pizza, and it was absolutely delicious! What made it even better was the clever idea of serving it with a lemon wedge. The tangy citrus flavor added a refreshing twist to the pizza. Before placing my order, I called the restaurant for suggestions since I wasn't sure what to get. Evan Eriksen was so amazing and really helped me out. I also tried their Fire Roasted Meatballs…They.Were.So.Good. I almost wanted to drive back up there, and get more sauce to dip my crust in. Overall, my first visit was fantastic. They offer unique and tasty pizza, the staff is friendly and super helpful, and the flavors are truly memorable 👩🏾‍🍳💋 what’s even better is I didn’t have to cross any bridges to get there 😮‍💨🙏🏿 #blessed 2024 Edit: They have been THEE pizza spot for me ever since. I haven’t had much menu exploration and the current BOGO deal is definitely going to change that. My one and only complaint is seating is few and far in between. It’s not a big deal considering the amazing pizza order in the corner!!

Great folks making great food! The Pizzas are all divine but also check out the Arugula Salad it’s astonishing!

Pizza is great - fresh ingredients, tasty sauce. Definitely coming back.

I have had the pleasure of eating pizza at Pie95 At least 10 times. The first experience was eating it across the road at Riverside Church at Park and King, who were hosting a Riverside Avondale Preservation Society function. It was by far the best pizza I’ve ever eaten for free. The very next night, my wife and I went to Pie95 and got pizza yet again. Since then, I have visited this fantastic pizza restaurant multiple times and every time have had delicious pizza made by the most amazing staff. The staff are always super helpful, they make sure every pizza looks like edible art, and they genuinely seem to enjoy what they do. The pizza is best eaten fresh at the store as it is a woodfired pizza. The pizza always has just the right amount of char and the crust is crisp and chewy. I also appreciate they don’t drown the pizza in sauce and toppings, it is a very balanced pizza. I have tried multiple Pizzas here and they are all delicious, even the white pizza and I usually don’t like white multiples Pizzas here and they are all delicious, even the white pizza and I usually don’t like white pizzas. They also offer gourmet seasonal items which are very much worth a taste.

There is a reason pie95 went from a food truck to a brick and mortar. It’s fresh, hot, delicious, and affordable. All this with smiles from everyone. Don’t just search pizza on pizza night… Search pie95!

Solid meatballs & good sauce made a nice appetizer. The garlic, oil and cheese pizza was good. I really liked the crust, light and tender, yet crispy. One serious recommendation, even though its hot out the beer must still be served ice cold. Coke too. Nice little environment out back too.

Wow. Just wow. Do not skip their appetizers/side dishes. The broccolini is so incredibly delicious. The garlic bread is garlicky, soft, perfectly charred, and scrumptious. I got the prawns and they are the perfect amount of spicy. Do not skip over this place!!!

Pizzas are delicious and the service was amazing!!! Definitely we’ll be back ♥️👌🏼

This place was amazing!!! Great pizza and very friendly atmosphere!!! Would definitely recommend!!

Such a great experience! We went for the first time about a week ago. The staff are friendly, they went through the menu with us, and the food was amazing! So flavorful. The restaurant is cozy and clean. We are so glad we finally tried it and will definitely be returning.

Excellent wood fire stove pizza. Freash ingredients. Helpful service. Thank you!

What a brutal place, the service, the food. Excellent, Milll, thank you 🫶🏼

Best Pizza in Jacksonville <333

My wife and I went tonight to try this restaurant because of the youtube videos. First we tried their meatballs and they were fantastic and we're picky. She also got the Barrata Caprese and loved it, then the pizzas came out. They were awesome! We spoke with the staff and they're personable and you can tell they take pride in their food and service. We'll definitely be back.

Pie95 is a hidden little gem! My husband and I ordered the burrata caprese, meatballs, wood fired pizza, and we were not disappointed. Truly amazing! The owner and staff were so welcoming and accommodating. Can't wait to come back and try the other entrees!

Great service. Was our 1st time going ..gave us the run down, pizza was kind of small but knew that because it was explained before we ordered. Was fresh hot and delicious. Definitely coming back

My boyfriend and I first tried this place out a few weeks ago and it was AMAZING! We literally crave their pizza like once a week now haha. It’s some of the best pizza in the city. The staff there is super friendly as well. Definitely recommend checking them out!

Soooooooooo gooooood !! Very great customer service 😁

Some of the best pizza you will ever have. Some of the best pizza in Florida. High quality ingredients, beautiful dough! It’s a work of art!

Great intimate pizza place. Staff very friendly. EVERYTHING we ordered tasted great. Tried 3 different appetizers and two pizzas. Plenty of choices for vegetarians.

This is the best pizza in town. Very friendly staff. Worth the trip.

Cannot say enough good things about this place… from the meatballs to the pizza and the tiramisu, everything is perfect. The people who work here also could not be more welcoming & kind. I don’t know how it took me so long to find the best pizza in Jax but I will be back, often 😍😍

We came here weeks ago. Ordered two pizzas, the herb, and meat lovers. I understand why it's priced high because the quality of ingredients are on point. Everything was fresh! The owner and staff are very down to earth. My wife is pregnant, so she's dealing with hot flashes on top of Florida's typical summer heat. The staff were very accommodating with getting her ice and trying to make the space cooler. Will be back and definitely bringing our babygirl here to have her first experience trying pizza.

Pizza was ok. What gets me is... only 1 size. Looks like a medium pizza, but priced like a large. To big for a single pizza, to small for a couple. And the drinks. $2.00 apiece canned soda??? Really???

Pizza was great. I would recommend trying it out.

This place was wonderful! My mom and I stopped in and the owner was so friendly and accommodating. We both got The Bianca and it was fresh and flavorful, some of the best pizza we’ve had in a while. We will absolutely be back

Rustic, friendly and delicious! Pie95 is for sure to be your go to pizza spot! Tucked away on King St, with a charming space for outdoor and indoor Eating. Order a wood fired slice, sit at the bar by the window and people watch. Must go!

1st time in and will certainly be back many more times. The meatballs and garlic bread was fantastic, but the Bianca was magical. Fantastic food and friendly folks here.

What an amazing place! The staff is amazing! And the food is delicious, the dough of the pizza is very tasty and light

A small pizza place on King street. Great atmosphere. The staff and the owner are a delight. Our first time here, they recommended the pizza’s to get. I myself got the carnivore which tasted amazing. The crust was perfect and the toppings tasted great too. Over all will visit to try their other pizzas.

I've been meaning to write a review for my favorite pizza joint in jax! Evan and his team are always super friendly and everytime i walk in I'm greeted like family. Their pizza, and appetizers are OUT OF THIS WORLD. I've never had a pizza i've been disappointed with. When its on the menu, the brisket appetizer is to die for. Scallops? Phenomenal. Everything else? Can't go wrong. Anyone in the greater Jacksonville area looking for some delicious pizza should one hundred percent try Pie95 and say hi to Evan and his team. Special shout out to Maiya for always being an amazing cashier and a constant friendly face whenever i pop by!

Best pizza outside of Italy & the fresh salad is delish! Just go there!!

Best pizza in Jacksonville hands down. Evan is a great guy who has a passion for pizza and loves what he is doing which shows in his craft. So happy there is a brick and mortar of Pie95 and not just the food truck. Glad to see how successful they have become. Well done.

Pie 95 is a hidden gem that deserves to be on every foodie's radar! From the moment you step through the door, you're greeted by the tantalizing aroma of fresh dough and the warm hospitality of the staff🤗 Pie 95 is more than just pies; it's a culinary experience that delights the senses and leaves you craving more. The cozy atmosphere, friendly service, and mouthwatering options make it the perfect spot for a casual or special dinner! If you find yourself in Jacksonville, FL, do yourself a favor and make a beeline for Pie 95! One bite and you'll be hooked!

Been eating pizza here since they were a food truck. Best Pizza in Jax by far maybe even Fl!

Excellent pizza and atmosphere!

The owner and his team are fantastic and a great time to talk with! The pizza is unparalleled and the outdoor patio is a great place to eat!!

Great food and great food fired pizza Service ess lovely, had a nice talk with the chef - great guy. 100% Recommend the place

This was my first visit to Pie95; and first impressions were great! The atmosphere is Rustic, the pizza is delicious, and the staff are friendly and communicative. I like the small references to the Ninja Turtles as well 🤘🏽 Five stars from me, I recommend!

Great atmospher, and the only thing better than the food (which is 🤌) is the service. Wicked friendly, welcoming, quick to act and respond, and even handy with a power drill!! Made our out of town experience a great and memorable one!

Phenomenal, perfect experience. Had the meatballs, the pepperoni pizza and the tiramisu. Meatballs were perfect, pizza was amazing (especially the crust), and the tiramisu was phenomenal. Great experience with the staff and outdoor seating and will come again next time I'm in Jax.

Absolutely love Pie95!! The food is incredible and the customer service is always great. Love the backyard outdoor seating area as well. It is the perfect spot to enjoy the best pizza in Jax.

Workers are super pleasant and always greet with a smile. The place is clean and well maintained. Food is awesome! One of our favorite fo to's!

By far some of the best pizza I’ve ever had. I had their pizza first as food truck coming to Atlanta doing a pop up. Seriously was blown away by the flavor of the dough. Happy to see them now in a brick and mortar serving pies to the masses!

Love Pie95! We come here often and have taken their pizza class too. Myself and my partner are from Long Island, NY and have made this our regular pizza spot. It is different than NY style pizza but equally as good.

Tired of trying to do business with this establishment. Last straw ordering food only to be canceled and putting a hold on my debit card. They clearly have no business in small local restaurant business nor care about their patrons.

Best pizza in town, the owner Evan is super nice too. Would highly recommend, there's a bunch of outside seating in the back too.

This place is amazing the food and service is always great. The only thing they're missing is a wider beer selection. The atmosphere at the back is always so peaceful and to an extent disconnects you from the front hustle and bustle. The margarita and garlic bread is always 10/10

This was our first time here last Saturday 4/13/24, as I was told by a friend this was a must try pizza place. We actually arrived about an hour before they were open for business, and they were not making pizzas at that time. However, as we walked in, we were greeted with the friendliest hello and immediately we felt respected, and like a valued customer!! Evan the owner chatted with us and was very informative about the history of his business and his passion for what he does! Being from Naples, Italy pizza is a very passionate meal for us. Evan actually said the most respectful thing I have ever heard a pizza chef say about his pizza. He said due to not wanting to disrespect Naples he did not want to call his pizza Neapolitan. But said it is with those type qualities and his NY background that he puts into his version of pizza. They allowed us to place an order and come back and in about an hour and they would have it ready for us. When we returned, they waited until they saw of coming in to start making our pizza to ensure it was fresh and hot and it only took about 4 minutes from start to finish. It was the most AMAZING pizza and hands down the best I have had in many years!! The dough is perfectly made and cooked with an amazing woodfired taste. You can really feel the passion that Evan and his staff puts into his pizzas and how much he cares about his customers! We are absolutely coming back and going to bring the entire rest of the Italian family to also have this amazing pizza. I warned Evan that with the entire family it will be loud, and we will need to sit outback lol. If you have not tried Pie95 Pizza yet you are no doubt missing out!! get there as soon as you can, and you will be blown away!!

Great pizza, great atmosphere. Definitely recommend!

Delicious, fresh! Perfect pepperoni size. Love the broccolini and the wood fired pizza. For dine in, we would prefer non plastic flatware, but thankfully pizza is often handheld!

Been here a few times, always great service and great food. Definitely my favorite pizza spot in Jax, and probably my favorite pizza spot ever.

Run, don’t walk! Hands down, great spot for pizza, veggies, prawns, and more! Thank you, Pie 95 for being a wonderful gem in the heart of Riverside.

I had all but given up on finding good pizza in Jacksonville. Pie95 is all fresh and high quality ingredients. I’m in love with the Bianca pizza and arugula ceaser salad. My husband is a big fan of the meatballs. Looking forward to taking family and friends!

Excellent flavor and texture on my Bianca pizza. The staff and atmosphere were warm and inviting. The price was perfect. Highly recommend Pie 95 for your next pizza.

I almost never post reviews but just had to this is our go to place for Friday night pizza for our family movie night. They now know us and always greet us with a smile and my daughter absolutely loves the girls that take our order. The food is incredible, the specials are always delicious and the pizza is chefs kiss 😘- I just had the prawn appetizer and literally almost called them to tell them how much I enjoyed 😂.

I almost cried at the first bite. I’ve been looking for a pizza that reminds me of home( New York City) for years while living here and this, THIS is it! As I walked in I was greeted with the friendliest hello although they were not open I felt respected and impressed to return during their open hours! It was my first visit, the cashier was very kind and straightforward letting me know they do not offer slices! After I received my order I understand why they don’t! Because “one slice is disrespectful” that’s what the nail tech said! And the nail tech was RIIIGHT! After one slice I was ready for the next one! The Chef was also kind by explaining to me the difference with the pizza that he offers and well, I was sold at the mention of Italy! I normally add oregano, Parmesan and sometimes chili flakes to my pizza for extra seasoning but after reading about Evan and his beginnings I decided to try my order with out adding the extra seasonings that were available! And am glad that I did! I ordered half marinara and half light cheese, I appreciate the chef for the “create your own” option. This pizza is enough not too much and nothing is missing for me to enjoy a brief day getaway from my regular duties! I will be back and I will tell more people about this hidden gem on Kings st! Thank you Pie 95 for your hospitality more so thank you for my pizza! Bless up Chef!

Amazing restaurant! Every menu item looks as good as it tastes. The service is fast and super friendly. The Bianca pizza is our favorite. The wings were super flavorful. The brocalini appetizer is a new must have. You won't be disappointed.

The cutest little pizza spot I’ve ever entered! Maiya’s artwork is captivating and helps set the vibe of the atmosphere. Everyone was so friendly, even with us walking in 30 minutes before opening. The garlic bread and cheese pizza was so scrumptious that the plates were cleaned with no leftovers. Definitely will be returning anytime I’m in town!

The pizza was delicious along with the garlic bread. The Beautiful artwork made me not want to leave.

The food was delicious! I loved the hot honey on top (:

Always a friendly atmosphere when I visit. Photo attached is “The Fungi” pizza and it’s one of my favorites! The mix of mushrooms with a Bianca base (another good selection of their’s) is such a nice combo. The dough is perfectly made and cooked with an amazing woodfired taste. This is honestly quality pizza and I highly recommend coming here all year round.

This place is the TRUTH! One of the best wood fired pizzas I’ve had. I’ve come back multiple times, each time it’s been great! The staff is also super friendly - always a welcoming vibe.

Omg a 3rd Generation Italian the dough was to die for! Taste’s the same as Nanas!!!!

It's truly a great pie. Go here no regrets if you like a neopolitan style pizza. The dough is unforgettable. We ordered the burrata too and was good. More balsamic and more tomatoes (heirloom)would have been better I think. Beers in a can or bottle but really should be on tap. They are here to stay so please get some taps and maybe cover some of the outside. This should be extremely popular all day and night long. Will be back! Love it

We decided to do something different on a Sunday, and tried a pizza making class at Pie95! We each got to make our own pizzas from scratch and got to chat with Evan the owner. You can really feel the passion that he puts into his pizzas and how much he cares to get to know his customers. I’m so glad we found a friendly and delicious pizza shop to add to our go-to restaurants!

Food is always awesome and the service is amazing!

Unbelievable. Best pizza in Jax. Great ingredients. Amazing staff too!!

My wife and I moved to Jax 6 months ago and Pie95 is our go to pizza spot!! They also offer pizza classes which is an awesome date night. The owner is from NY so he knows a thing or two about pizza!

A great vibe and the best pizza in town. Tried them out many years ago when it was a food truck, the brick and mortar is great spot in Riverside. Can't go wrong with wood fired pizza.

Pie95 is a gem of a restaurant that serves the most scrumptious wood fire pizza and other dishes. My family and I had a wonderful time there, enjoying some pizzas, the crispy wings, and the tender meatballs with the flavorful red sauce. The pizza was cooked to perfection, with a thin and crispy crust, gooey cheese, and fresh toppings. The staff was courteous and helpful, and the ambiance was warm and welcoming. The food looked and tasted so good that I couldn't resist taking some pictures, but they didn't do justice to the real thing. Pie95 is a must-try for anyone who loves pizza and great service. I can't wait to go back and try more of their menu. Five stars all the way!

Great pizza definitely will come back!