Sugar Daddy's in Madeira Beach - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

The Italian Ice is amazing!!! Love this place we go here almost everyday when we are down in Florida. Highly recommend for anyone that is looking for a small ice cream shop.

We were in the area for spring training baseball and came to John’s Pass on the recommendation of a local friend. We had just finished eating dinner on the dock at Caddy’s and came looking for ice cream… and this place did not disappoint! We love supporting local and independent ice cream places like this especially when the product is so good. I got a waffle cone with Captain Butterscotch and my wife got one of their chocolate ice creams - both were very good. And it’s just fun to eat ice cream on the boardwalk! Definitely recommend!

Showed up at 8:45 and it was closed. Says it closes at 9:30. Waste of a trip, gas, parking fees, etc.

Guy was friendly, we got Cookie Monster and it taste delicious. They also have classic candys from early 2000s

This is another great place to go and have some really good ice cream walk around the boardwalk see the dolphins and the different types of fish sugar daddy is a wonderful place to take your family

The service was okay, the milkshake was delicious. Unfortunately without cream!

Interested to go there but it was closed early than the closing time (30mins prior).

Great ice cream, but the service was incredibly slow. I can't blame the young man working there, but I don't understand why they only have one person working on a Sunday night, during tourist season, and with a line out the door?

We tried almost all of the ice cream shops in Johns Pass and this was in my top two - for value and flavor! And I'll give you another reason to stop by, they sell pop 20oz bottles for $2.35 and a Monster for just $3

Delicious ice cream, warm and friendly service. Got to try several creative flavors which was appreciated. Will definitely return next time we're in town!

The gentleman working provided excellent service. The portions and prices were great for the area. Highly recommend!

Great place. Gave me and my friend a place to cool off when we needed it badly. Had my favorite flavor of ice cream.

Very good Ice cream but overprized. We had to pay over 20$ for just four ice cream‘s. Even it was delicous, this was too much!

Soooooo yum! Girls working were so super sweet! The key lime cheesecake and blueberry cheesecake were definitely in my top 3! They had some super unique flavors, and they weren’t hesitant to offer samples. Even when customers came in, staff stayed engaged and helpful to ALL customers. This attentiveness in such young staff was super impressive 14Apr22 6-close 💞 staff? Wonderful place. Will definitely visit if I’m ever in town again. Also couldn’t help but to love the cute cow decor!

Muy sabroso y muy buena atención las chicas que atienden muy lindas y muy buena forma de ayudar a los que no sabemos mucho de inglés, le doy 5 y merece más lo recomiendo 100%

The atmosphere was so-so. The person who welcomed us was nice and gave us time and options. One of the employees showed up and they started talking about random stuff. I get that they wanted to talk, but it was just a little weird in my opinion. Other than that I enjoyed the ice cream. We got the ocean mist flavour and moose tracks. I would recommend having some music to spicen up the area but overall it was ok

Great selection of icecream right on John’s Pass Boardwalk and old fashioned candy! 🍬🍫🍭🍦🍨🍧

Dairy Free Options! I had the cookies and cream and my daughter had the watermelon Italian ice . Delicious !! Excellent customer service. Our server was Collin and he made the experience great! Will be back!

Few days since being in Madeira Beach, we decided to look for ice cream places since it is hot down there. They have amazing flavors, the service was fun. If you are looking to get some ice cream in Madeira Beach go to Sugar Daddy's. 🍨🍦🍧

Really good ice cream! What a great location and friendly service.

So many flavors to choose from!

ABSOLUTE GREAT SERVICE! One man - hundreds of customers, he gets the ice cream done fast and easy, sad he is the only one running it. Out of all the ice cream shops here, it is very hood, tons of flavors and options. Recommend for ice cream lovers.

Nearly after 10 years of coming here, we still love it!

I was at sugar daddy's ice cream shop not eagle parasail.

Great service. We have two people with celiac disease (can’t eat wheat), and they got out a fresh barrel of ice cream for them to ensure there wasn’t cross contamination. Thank you!!!

I’ve been going here since I was a child. Best ice cream that has ever existed! You need to try the chocolate peanut butter!

Great Icecream, only complain I have is the price for the milkshake being $7 when other places at John's pass have it for $3, $4 or $5.

Good ice cream, but nothing really special and not cheap.

Delicious handmade ice cream...

The owner is amazing and super nice! Never been disappointed here

My Heavenly Hash was angelic. The fam got Strawberry Cheesecake, Crazy Cake, Gator tracks, and watermelon Italian ice. We stood on the boardwalk and watched the dolphins. Great experience.

Had the cappuccino Kahlua ice cream and it was amazing! Very reasonable prices as well.

Whoa, what a great find at John’s Pass! Home made ice cream at an affordable price.

Great ice cream, great people. Got two scoops to share for just $5 and was almost more than we could finish. We finished anyways because it was so good.

Its a icecream place its pretty decent