Tony And Al's Deli in Starke - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

Owners of this pizza place: I understand that locals may know you moved, but how about people coming from Rt 301 for pizza? We went to this address today: 200 E Call St, Starke, FL 32091 And looked in the window = the place is Closed and the door is locked. So we went to another restaurant on Call St and talked to the locals...and you moved. How about a sign on the window at #200 giving your new address? How about updating your published (internet) address?

Wow! I’ve been dreaming of an experience like this for years! Even though I'm not from Florida and was only staying for one night, I knew I had to try this place. The food was phenomenal—those stuffed garlic knots didn’t even last 15 minutes on the way back to the hotel. The customer service was exceptional; the staff were welcoming, enthusiastic, and radiated positivity. If I’m ever within an hour of this fantastic hidden gem again, I will definitely be stopping by! A heartfelt thank you to everyone there for making my visit truly memorable!

The food is amazing. Great atmosphere and friendly staff! 🍛❤️

We ate the Chicken Parmigiana and the Pasta Alfredo with chicken and a house salad and it was all great. Our waitress Sarah was very attentive. Good atmosphere as well.

Food was dry and tasteless. Wait staff was nice. Food was so much better at the old place. Will not be returning, very disappointed as I used to be a regular customer.

Love the local feel, food, and the people! Would absolutely recommend to anyone!!

The new location is really nice and the food is excellent. They have a nicely varied menu Good food and friendly staff

I'm very disappointed. This place was great in the original building. Now, it has taken a turn for the worst. Nothing tastes the same their sauces watered down. And the service is not that great. Today we got cheese pizza and most of it was crust.

Fast and friendly service, and the food was excellent! We had garlic knots, ravioli carbonara, and chicken parm. Everything was so good!

The food was delicious and plentiful. I ate half there and the rest for supper.

Everything is always very tasty and good. Great service and fantastic food.

Awesome food! Large amount of food, beautiful clean restaurant. Sarah was amazing, cordial and very attentive. Highly recommend Tony's!

Love the mew location.. the worlds best N.Y. White pizza...Always perfect.. Thank you all

Pizza is delicious , chicken wrap and fries we're good. Fantastic service, restaurant appears clean.

Great food! Super friendly staff!

Management needs to hire competent people at the counter.. been waiting an hour for take out and they still can't keep from screwing this up

Food is amazing. Service is amazing. Nice job.

Delicious food, prepared fresh! I had a Cesar salad, garlic knots, and the chicken parm. I can't wait to bring the rest of the family.

I love Tony & Al's!!! Top notch foods, services and atmosphere. The owners are very down to earth and good people. They always accommodate our needs on services. I forgot to snap the photos before tonight's dinner. I highly advise XL Supreme and XL Meatlovers pizza's and the Tiramitsu is fire 🔥 👌 😍 The photos of the cake we went without the extras but you can add the sauce if you wish. Best pizza for all of Florida!!! Can't go wrong for $50 and size, quality and toppings on these.

christofer was an amazing server! with great service and a positive attitude! food tastes great! chefs kiss

Christofer is phenomenal, so polite kind and knowledgeable of the menu, and he used his big arm muscles to carry all out plates to us!

The tastiest food, nice people all around. Cannot say enough good things about this establishment. Calzone, pizza and garlic knots. Look if you like a ricotta calzone and pizza, you will find no fault here. Customer since 2021. We go here at least once a week.

Service was excellent and the pizza was delicious!

This has been a great and tasty Italian restaurant, I've been enjoying since before they moved, whenever I pass thru town. Their steak calzone is a solid good choice, and what I went for.

Exceptional service,quality and atmosphere. 6 years later still the BEST!!!!!!!!!

The best Italian food I've ever eaten. The owner and his staff are absolutely the best. The atmosphere is light and professional.

Life long Starke customer...especially their calones. First order in new location. Ordered loaded.3/4 bread. Nothing like others no bacon. No hamburger just a few things plopped on top. We love them so will try again but very very dissapointed.

Ordered stromboli and it was very good‼️ The crust was delicious as well‼️

Truly great food and service! Love the new place!!

We love the new location . More room, but the same type of food. Thanks for the improvements.

Delicious food! I ordered the chicken Parmesan, garlic knots and side cesar salad. I definitely waited too long to try this place.

Very good pizza, lots of cheese and nice crust.

So we usually take the 301 bypass between Jacksonville and Gainesville but decided to stop because somebody was becoming hangry. We found this spot and we were delighted. Everything was delicious. We particularly enjoyed the garlic knots and the eggplant. Even my picky eater said the chicken Alfredo was better than Olive Garden. We’ll definitely stop in again next time we’re in the area.

Food was very good. Clean and good service. Would eat there again

A bit disappointing. Reviews were better than the experience. Food is a bit bland and way too much cheeze on everything.

They never disappoint! Excellent food, haven't had one thing that I didn't like! Stuffed salmon with lobster sauce is one of my favorites.

Tony and his team are amazing! We’ve never had a bad meal, and in fact many times it’s the best we’ve ever had! This is worth a drive in , if you’re out of town!

Fast friendly service and the food was hot and delicious. Love this place. Please try it out. Always a good meal.

So I've been to the Tony and Al's in Alachua their food is okay the service and atmosphere is very good but this place the food is excellent the service is good and the atmosphere is very nice I had the Philly cheese steak and it was delicious real pieces of steak not like most places that use shaved steak this was actual pieces of steak and it was delicious

If this place had raccoon & opossum pizza on thier menu I'd buy it. Pizza is the best around. Dough is so good.

Visited this local hangout. This place was a surprise find for me. Located in downtown historical district of Starke its in an old corner building, kinda cool. I ordered the Stromboli was pretty good. Fresh made and hot with a side dip sauce. Along with the Stromboli I ordered an iced tea: and they gave me one for the road too! Out the door with tip: $18.95 I'll be back !!

Old dated building. Not inviting. Good mediocre. At least the price was reasonable.

I really was happy to find a good pizza. Recommended by a coworker/friend. The sauce, maybe a little on the sweat side. Well cooked and toppings were fresh. I like the small village atmosphere and not crowded for a 2pm Saturday take-out order. The staff and fellow patrons were friendly. You get what you give out in this world 🌎 Thank you, T&A's Starke

Was in Starke to do some business and at stopped by here to grab some lunch. Utterly delicious! Best pizza I've had in Florida. Really wish they had a place open back home as well lol Props to Sarah for being a great waitress!

Usually LOVE this place, decided to try something new today. Got the lasagna...😡 worst lasagna I've ever had!!! It was dry, no sauce....I do not recommend at all.

Food was absolutely delicious and is served fresh and hot. The stuffed garlic knots are served with a red sauce. We got a side of Alfredo sauce, and I feel that kicked it up to another level. The pizza was delicious as my son ate over half a large by himself. The eggplant parmigian, lasagna, Italian sub, and chicken wrap were also delicious. Depending on the size of your party, you will definitely need to order more than 1 order of the bruschetta and garlic knots. The staff was friendly and quick to check on us throughout our dining experience. This being said, we were there between lunch and dinner time. The dining area is small, so it can be tight when busy. This place is also located on the main street in town so parking could be tough at certain times of the day, but it's worth it for the food.

Awesome food, pizza is amazing and so are the Calzones, always friendly staff.

Delicious food! My dad and I split a pizza and it was enough for the both of us. Highly recommend!

Great Pizza and Sandwiches at a very reasonable prices.

Doesn't look like a great place but the food was absolutely incredible. Best calzone ever! I would recommend you try the calzone Supreme

My wife and I have been here a couple of times. We realized today that we have never left a review. So here it is! The food here has been delicious everytime we visited! Today we both got the Chicken Parm with meatballs & sausage. For an appetizer we got the bruschetta which was very, very good. That alone will keep us coming back. And a must-have is their garlic knots stuffed with mozzarella. You will fall in love with those! The service was fast and friendly.

The food here is delicious! We got the Chicken Parm with meatballs & sausage. For an appetizer we got the bruschetta which was the best I've had in a long time. That alone will keep us coming back. And a must-have is their garlic knots stuffed with mozzarella. You will fall in love with those! The service was fast and friendly.

Good family restaurant, food is made fresh and delicious 😋

Drive from Melrose for it! Great people yummy food!

I ordered a supreme calzone. It was very good. Definitely recommend it. It was a little bit of a wait. Due to it was a little bit busy when we got there. But all in all a good experience. It's a nice local sit-down restaurant. The staff was very accommodating and polite. Wasn't a long wait to get seated as well

My wife and I visited about a year ago and shame on me! I forgot! Great little place right in the heart of Starke, Fl. Great atmosphere, Great service, and above all......Great tasting food! Excellent!!

Always great food. Servers and owners are awesome.

We LOVE Tony and Al’s - anytime I’m in Florida we stop in at least once. It’s a family run spot with great food and amazing service. Tony himself is a gem of a human, it seems like the whole town loves him. I always order the steak and cheese sandwich, but the pizza is darn good, too!

Best in town. If you're visiting you gotta stop by. Doesn't matter what you order, it's all great.

We ordered 8 pizzas to go for our monthly youth night. Everyone loved them.The customer service and quality of food is fabulous!

Small dining area. Great take out.

Passing through. Seems like a great small-town pizza place! They were popping on a Monday evening. My kids loved it! The special that day was 2 large pizzas for $16. I'd return to taste other menu items.

Amazing food, excellent service. Right in the heart of downtown.

Everything was good. Except the waiter with the black hair. She was really rude and bossy. I didn't care to much for her at all.

We enjoy coming here when in town visiting our family!Fantastic food!!

Wonderful place to eat some delicious Italian food. Service and food were perfect!

Best meal for flavor and appearance Down home feeling for a first timer. If you eat there you will be in for a great treat.

We went as a family of 4 our girls got a large pep Pizza my hubby ordered the turkey Sub while I got a Calzone (think it was the calzone it was the one with the Ricotta) food was very good. We didn't have to wait long and even my hubby said the sub was toasted perfectly. We spent under $40 total for a very good meal.

Been here two times now both times the food was great. My favorite so far is the Italian sub however I'll be back to try that Jambalaya.

Great food excellent service 👌 and fantastic prices

The tables are very wobbly, the food tastes amazing, but im sensitive to texture, so i had to rate it 4 (had a soft/soggy texture)

Food was amazing! We got the all meat calzone, spaghetti with meat sauce, and the brushetta. Was the best calzone I have ever had!! It's a small place but service and food was excellent. Will definitely be back when in the area.

We really enjoyed the food and the friendly atmosphere, and loved that food was made fresh .

Great calzone. Wish they had artichokes available as a topping or an all-veg (rather than a $1 per topping) option for the calzones. Recommend on the street parking since the lots are still under construction. Service was ok, but our calzones were mixed up and since it's not obvious from the outside, we didn't know until we had each eaten from another person's. The dessert menu was chocolate cake, cannoli. The lemoncelllo should be brought back, and maybe add pannacotta?

We love it very fresh cook rock before your eyes.

Supernfriendly waitstaff, food comes out hot and fresh. Spaghetti was great, eggplant rollatini superb, and the garlic knots are excellent.

We love Tony and Al's so much! The food is always great, the staff are all very friendly. Try the stuffed Salmon, we love it so much we can't order anything else now. They make amazing garlic knots, and the stuffed (with cheese) garlic knots are very popular in our family.

Hostess was also waitress and buser! Awesome job! The food was AMAZING! Ordered an pizza and have to say it was one of the best I have had. My wife had a chicken salad which she also enjoyed very much! Restaurant is packed! Aways a good sign of good food!

The food and the service are excellent!

Just... great. I was only sad there were no more cannolis left, but that just means they're probably great and made fresh, so I'll be back to try those too. Edit: The cannolis are awesome, too. Great food every time.

Small corner pizzeria, good specials, good pizza and their sandwiches shouldn't be missed!

We came hungry but definitely needed to-go boxes! The food we ordered was hot, fresh, & delicious! Our server was great! She was by herself but was hustling the whole time. Excellent experience!

My husband and I were in Stark and were looking for a good place to eat dinner. Ratings were good for Tony and Al's deli so we thought we would give it a try. We will definitely come back if we are in the area. Our friendly server Taylor was very knowledgeable of the menu and checked in on us often. Check out was fast. It was a friendly laid-back atmosphere. It was a positive dining experience for us.

The steak and cheese was gross, it tasted like burned paper. It took 40 min to be served. I will not be eating here again. So very gross.

A little tight, but you will not go wrong here!!! Delicious, affordable, and super friendly staff. The pizza is too door for, and do not forget to order the stuffed garlic knots!!! ❤️❤️❤️❤️

Service was great. Server and trainee was very helpful and always checking on us. Food came out in a reasonable time and was delicious. Great amount of options to choose from and it was fresh and tasty. The place is smaller but nice. Clean and just enough to get a small group of 5-8 people in and not be too crowded. Will definitely be back to try the whole menu. Good job.

This place was referred to us for some good Italian food which is hard to find in the JCP area. A little bit out of the way but we’ll worth the trip if your out & about in STARKE. The staff was very friendly & prompt. Best of all , very reasonably priced ! I will be back for round 2 !

Food is always GREAT! Never a disappointment!

First time at Tony’s and Al’s I ordered takeout and the food is delicious The prices are reasonable and the service was great So happy to find this little gem

Everything I have tried has been great. The people are happy and give great service.

Excellent food. Service is amazing.

I had their spaghetti and lasagna! Bread is AMAZING! I love their homemade marinara

We happened upon Tony and Al's Deli at the suggestion of some relatives we were visiting near rustic downtown Starke, street parking only. We arrived on a quiet Saturday afternoon around 3:00 p.m. the seating is very limited. They have maybe eight tables. Owing to that, they have some very nice to-go specials, a few days during the week. However, by the time we left around 5:15 the crowd had blossomed to the point where we could not even carry on a conversation. I'll start out by saying Wow. Just WoW! The service was pretty decent. Everyone was Keen to try the lasagna. It came with some nicely toasted bread, (much better than my experience with Al Dente in St Augustine earlier in the week, where I cut the roof of my mouth on an overly toasted rind). The lasagna was declared two thumbs up by everyone. The portion was decent for the price. We also ordered the obligatory Pizza which we had to take out due to being stuffed already. I ordered a half Hawaiian / half meat lovers Pizza so I could try more than one set of their toppings. The quantity of toppings was average, and the toppings seemed fresh and tasty. The real winner here was the pizza crust. I seldom eat the crust on a pizza. This was the first time, in a long while, that I actually ENJOYED eating the CRUST, as well as, the pizza! We will definitely be back to try more items when we are in the area again. I hope to visit again soon!

Their chicken Alfredo is not good at all. They use spaghetti and not penne pasta or the normal pasta. Although their Stromboli is great. I've never had any of their pizza, but it's got to be good. It looks like it is. And their restaurant seems to be full on the weekends.

I've never had soggy crust before. But the toppings were good.

We always have the best food when we come. One of the best places in town! Today we got bruschetta with shrimp, ravioli carbonara and I had pasta Siciliano. Never disappoints!.

We love Tony and Al's, friendly staff, good, cute place.

Food was great. Didn't wait long for anything.

Good food... Decent pricing... Fast service and good people. Would go back when in the area!

Delicious food, fresh, homemade, fast service, friendly people. We will definitely be back!